"Only five are identified individually."
"Which five?"
Price read from his notes.
"Two complaint reports, one dispatch summary, one internal memorandum, and a document described as a supervisory review matrix."
Evelyn wrote down the phrase.
"Supervisory review matrix."
Agent Bennett nodded.
"We found a reference to a similar document in another department's audit materials. It appears to have been an internal tracking tool, but we don't know what information it contained."
"Could it have been a list of complaints involving particular officers?"
"Possibly."
"Could it have been a list of complaints the department considered sensitive?"
"Also possible."
Evelyn closed her notebook.
"Then that's what we need to establish."
She looked at Nathaniel.
"What about the anonymous message?"
"We've preserved it. The sender used a number associated with a prepaid service, but that doesn't tell us who sent it. We're examining the available records."
"Any further contact?"
"Nothing."
Evelyn considered the possibility that the sender was Marianne, Rachel, a current employee, a former officer, or someone who had no direct involvement in the department at all.
The message might be an attempt to help.
It might also be an attempt to manipulate the investigation.
She had no intention of treating it as reliable merely because it pointed toward something suspicious.
"Let's return to the original complaint," she said. "Who made it?"
Price opened another document.
"The name was redacted in the copy provided to us. However, the dispatch system retains a caller classification and a telephone suffix. We have requested the unredacted record through the appropriate process."
"How long?"
"Hopefully today."
Evelyn glanced at the clock.
"Then we have work to do while we wait."
For the next two hours, the team compared complaint reports, dispatch summaries, and supervisory approvals. They created a table of every incident associated with Hawthorne Lane and identified the officers involved.
The pattern was disturbing, but not yet conclusive.
Some residents had reported aggressive behavior. Others described conversations that appeared ordinary until they were examined in context. In several cases, the officer's report differed from the resident's account. In others, the available evidence was too incomplete to support either version.
The problem was not that every complaint had necessarily been valid.
The problem was that the department appeared to have used the same narrow classification to close complaints without consistently examining the evidence.
A complaint did not need to be proven true before it deserved a fair review.
And an officer's report did not become infallible merely because it had been written on official stationery.
At 3:27 p.m., Price discovered a reference to a former employee named Robert Gaines.
Gaines had worked in the department's records unit until two years earlier. According to personnel records, he had resigned unexpectedly after twelve years of service.
His departure had been classified as voluntary.
However, a short internal memorandum described a disagreement involving archival procedures.
The memorandum was only three paragraphs long.
The final paragraph read:
Mr. Gaines was advised that all future inquiries regarding restricted records must be directed through the administrative office.
Evelyn read the sentence twice.
"Find him."
Agent Bennett checked the available records.
"He's living outside Westbridge. We can arrange an interview."
"Do that. But don't tell him what we suspect. Ask him about his responsibilities, the transfer process, and the circumstances surrounding his departure."
Nathaniel nodded.
"If he remembers the archive, he might know where the old files went."
"Exactly."
At 4:10 p.m., Evelyn received a call from Marianne Ellis's attorney.
The attorney explained that Marianne was willing to speak with the investigative team, provided the interview took place outside Westbridge and that her personal safety concerns were taken seriously.
Evelyn agreed to coordinate a secure meeting.
Before ending the call, the attorney added something unexpected.
"Marianne says she remembers your first conversation with her."
"I remember it too."
"She says there was one thing she didn't tell you."
Evelyn sat straighter.
"What was it?"
"She believes someone copied the supervisory review matrix before the original files were transferred."
"Does she know who?"
"She says she has a strong suspicion, but she wants to explain it in person."
"All right. Please tell her we'll listen."
After the call ended, Evelyn walked to the window.
The city below was busy with the ordinary rhythms of the late afternoon. Cars moved through the intersection. Office workers crossed the street carrying bags. A delivery driver hurried toward a building entrance.
Life continued as though the records on her desk were nothing more than paperwork.
But Evelyn knew how much damage paperwork could do when it was used to replace truth.
A false classification could make a legitimate complaint disappear.
A missing recording could deprive a resident of the only independent evidence of an encounter.
A signature could turn an unverified accusation into an official account.
And a quiet instruction from someone in authority could convince an entire office that asking questions was more dangerous than remaining silent.
She returned to the conference room.
"There's something I want us to keep in mind," she said.
The others looked up.
"We are not investigating whether every officer involved in these reports is corrupt. We are investigating whether the department's processes were manipulated, who was responsible, and whether anyone knowingly violated the law or retaliated against people who raised concerns."
Agent Bennett nodded.
"That's the right scope."
"If the evidence clears someone, we document that. If it implicates someone, we document that too. No one gets blamed because they worked in the wrong office, and no one gets protected because they have the right title."
Nathaniel smiled faintly.
"That sounds like the Evelyn Carter I know."
She returned the smile, but only briefly.
"Then let's make sure our work reflects it."
At 5:46 p.m., the team received the first unredacted dispatch record.
The caller's name was not included in the document, but the number had been linked to a residential telephone account.
The account belonged to a person named Patricia Lang.
Evelyn searched the case database.
Patricia Lang had filed no complaints against the Westbridge Police Department. She had no known employment relationship with the city. She was not listed among the residents who had provided statements about the incidents.
But there was one detail that stood out.
Her address was less than a mile from Hawthorne Lane.
"Who is she?" Evelyn asked.
Agent Bennett reviewed the available public records.
"Retired school administrator. She lived in Westbridge for more than thirty years."
"Any connection to the department?"
"Her husband, William Lang, served on the city's public safety advisory committee until his death five years ago."
Evelyn looked at the dispatch record again.
"That could be entirely innocent."
"Yes."
"Can we establish whether Patricia Lang actually made the call?"
"We'll need to verify that through the available records and, if appropriate, an interview."
Evelyn nodded.
"Do it."
At 6:20 p.m., another document arrived.
It was a copy of the internal memorandum associated with the archival transfer.
The previously obscured approval line was now readable.
Deputy Chief Alan Mercer.
Evelyn stared at the signature.
Mercer had approved the transfer of twenty-three records into a restricted administrative repository shortly after the first Hawthorne complaint was closed.
The same deputy chief who, according to Rachel Miller, had directed employees to alter complaint classifications.
The same administrator who had reportedly wanted the supervisory review matrix removed.
It was a significant connection.