The silence that followed had a different quality from the silence before — heavier, and cleaner.
"What do you propose?" Caroline said at last, quietly.
"A formal review, opened in the morning, on the record, with the board informed tonight — by you, in your words, before they hear it from a retired judge, which they otherwise will, because she has written to them, and to my office, and her letter will be the least of what arrives." He folded his napkin. "Staff will be interviewed: the desk, security, housekeeping, the bell staff, the concierge. All records preserved — footage, logs, reports, memoranda." He pronounced the last word without emphasis, which was its own kind of emphasis. "I will conduct it with two of my colleagues from the Review. No one is dismissed, transferred, or coached while it runs. And Caroline—" She looked up. "You will not speak to Madison Pierce tonight. Whatever that girl is carrying, she is carrying it honestly. I saw her face at twenty past six."
Later — much later, when the evening had been dismantled around them and the courtiers had gone home to telephone each other in whispers — Caroline Drayton sat alone in her office in the dark, with the city glittering beyond the glass, and did the thing she had not permitted herself to do at the table. She took from her desk the Saint Aubin's copy of the footage request form that legal would file in the morning, and she looked at the empty line for the time stamp, and she thought about four minutes past four, and about a sentence she had written two years earlier in an elegant format, and about the girl she had been about to feed to the evening like a coal into a furnace to keep the house warm one more night.
She thought: I wrote it down. That was her whole defense and her whole indictment, and she held both of them in her hands for a long time, like a woman holding the two ends of the same rope.
The formal review opened at nine the next morning in the Bordeaux Room, which the hotel used for board meetings and small weddings, and which had therefore seen roughly equal quantities of champagne and consequence.
Amos had brought two colleagues from the Review: a senior evaluator named Paula Rendell, who had the stillness of deep water and took the official notes, and the Review's counsel, a soft-spoken man named Whitlock, whose function was to make everything said in the room admissible to the future. Caroline sat at the table with the hotel's own counsel beside her. The board had been informed — by Caroline, at midnight, in a call she would remember as the worst of her professional life — and the board's instruction, relayed and repeated, was total cooperation. Evelyn Hart, the chair, would come herself when testimony was done. For now, the room belonged to Amos, and to the staff of the Saint Aubin, who came through its door one at a time like guests at an unfamiliar hotel, unsure where to put their hands.
Theo Baptiste came first, at his own request, which the room noted.
He brought the lost-property log book with him, held in both hands like something christened. He gave his name and his job and his two years of service, and then, in answer to Amos's single question — "Tell us about the day before yesterday, starting wherever you think it starts" — he told it from the suitcase. He described the case standing forgotten by the desk. He described carrying it to the cage himself, and weighing its quality in his hands, and writing the entry. Then he stopped, and looked down at the book, and opened it to the pages he had marked with slips of paper, and said, in a voice that shook once and then steadied, "Sir, it doesn't start there. I need to show you the rest of the book."
He read them out. October, the man who asked to use a telephone. November, the woman with two children, crying. January, the veteran who wanted to sit out of the rain. March, the lady who wanted tea. April, the young man with the stutter, laughed at — I heard, he read, and looked up, and said, "I wrote that in the book because I didn't know where else it belonged. It belonged somewhere." May, the man in the wheelchair, sent round to the service door without help, while it rained on the front steps with the awning over them.