He came around the desk.
"Mrs. Ellis. I'm Jonathan Harrison."
Margaret shook his hand.
"Thank you for seeing me."
"I apologize that you had to wait."
"I have waited longer for less."
Jonathan did not smile. He recognized that the remark was not intended as a joke.
He gestured toward a chair.
"Please sit down."
Margaret took the seat nearest the window. Helen remained standing until Jonathan asked her to join them.
A small table stood between the chairs. On it were a carafe of water, two glasses, and a copy of the founding covenant.
Margaret looked at the document.
"You found it."
"We did."
"Was it difficult?"
Jonathan paused.
"More difficult than it should have been."
"That is often the case with things people would rather not find."
He accepted the criticism without argument.
"I have read the first sections of the agreement. Our legal department is reviewing the entire document. I don't want to make promises before we know what obligations remain in force."
"That is sensible."
"May I ask why you came today?"
Margaret opened her handbag and removed the sealed envelope.
"I received notice that the bank was reorganizing its historical records. I was concerned that the original documents might be separated from the records that explain them."
She placed the envelope on the table.
"This contains copies of the founding covenant, several memoranda, and a letter from Samuel Whitmore. He was the bank's original legal adviser."
Jonathan looked at the envelope but did not touch it.
"Why did you wait so long to bring this to us?"
Margaret considered the question.
It was a reasonable question, but it had been asked in ways that made it sound like an accusation.
"I did not wait because I forgot," she said. "I waited because I believed the bank might correct the problem without forcing the people who depended on it to endure another public crisis."
"And did it?"
"No."
Jonathan lowered his eyes.
Margaret continued.
"I also waited because I was tired. I had a husband who was ill. I had a daughter who needed me. I had a grandson who deserved a grandmother who could enjoy his childhood instead of spending every holiday reading legal correspondence."
She folded her hands.
"And, if I am honest, I waited because I was afraid that the people who had made the original decisions would use my persistence to portray me as an enemy of the institution."
Jonathan listened carefully.
"Do you believe the bank still owes you money?"
"No."
He looked surprised.
"You don't?"
"I believe the bank owes people the truth. Whether it owes me money is a question for lawyers and accountants. I did not come here to negotiate a personal settlement."
"Then what are you asking for?"
"An independent review of the reserve. A complete accounting of what happened in 1989. And an assurance that the covenant will not be altered or ignored while the review is taking place."
Jonathan looked at the document between them.
"That could be a substantial investigation."
"It should be."
"Some of the people involved are no longer alive."
"I know."
"Some records may be incomplete."
"I know that too."
"And if the review finds that the bank acted within its legal authority?"
Margaret nodded.
"Then I will accept the findings, provided the review is genuinely independent and the evidence is made available to the appropriate parties."
Jonathan studied her.
"You seem very certain about that."
"I am certain about what I am asking. I am not certain what the answers will be."
He leaned back.
For years, Jonathan had attended meetings where people came to his office seeking favorable decisions. Some wanted money. Some wanted exceptions to policy. Others wanted him to make a problem disappear before it became visible to someone more senior.
Margaret was asking for none of those things.
She was asking him to examine the institution he led and accept the possibility that its official history might be incomplete.
That was more difficult than approving a loan.
"Mrs. Ellis," he said, "I want to understand something about the founding covenant. What did it mean to you?"
Margaret looked toward the window.
"It meant that people could trust the bank with things they could not afford to lose."
"Was that all?"
"No."
She turned back to him.
"It meant that the people who created an institution had a responsibility to think beyond their own lifetimes. We knew that none of us would remain in charge forever. We knew that future managers would face pressures we could not predict. We also knew that a promise made when things were easy might become inconvenient when things became difficult."
She touched the edge of the envelope.
"So we wrote it down."
Jonathan remained silent.
Margaret continued.
"The bank grew. It became successful. It acquired buildings, hired thousands of employees, and began serving customers whose names would never appear in a newspaper. That success was good. I was proud of it."
Her voice softened.
"But success can make people forget the conditions that made it possible. They begin to believe that the institution exists because of their decisions, their intelligence, and their ambition. They forget the ordinary people who trusted them before there was anything impressive to trust."
Jonathan glanced down at the covenant.
"Do you believe that happened here?"