Cut the row. Cut Sadie's row. Take a saw to the trees she had planted with her own hands and feed them to a fire.
"No," he said.
"Ned —"
"I said no." He turned away, his hands shaking. "You don't understand what you're asking."
"I understand exactly what I'm asking." She caught his sleeve, and her grip was strong. "I'm asking you to choose between the memory of your wife and the life of everything she built. Because those are not the same thing, and you have been pretending they are for four years."
He jerked free and walked away from her, out past the barn, past the creek, until the orchard swallowed the sound of his boots. He did not know where he was going until he found himself at the fence line, staring west at the tangle of Sadie's row, and his chest was heaving like he'd run a mile.
That evening, Hattie would not eat. Andy tried to coax her with a story about a mule he'd once seen walk into a church. She stared at her plate. Jo watched Ned not eating either, the two of them at opposite ends of the table like bookends holding up nothing.
It was Andy who broke it. Fourteen years old, all elbows and scowl, he pushed his chair back and said, "Mr. Ned, can I ask you something?"
Ned looked up.
"When my pa died in the mine cave-in, Mama kept his workshop exactly like it was for a whole year. His tools all hung up. His apron on the hook. Nobody touched anything." Andy picked at a splinter on the table edge. "And then one winter the roof started leaking right over his workbench, and Mama just stood there looking at it, and I said we had to fix it, and she cried. But we fixed it. And then I started using his tools." He looked up, and his face was very young and very old at once. "I don't remember my dad by keeping his workshop exactly the way it was, Mr. Ned. I remember him by using his hammer to build something new."
The kitchen went absolutely silent. The clock ticked. Somewhere outside, an owl called once.
Ned stared at the boy. He thought of Sadie's row — the cankered bark, the black heaps of windfalls, the rot humming underneath. He thought of the half-sentence in the journal. *If this scion takes.*
"Your mama raised you right, son," he said hoarsely.
Andy shrugged, embarrassed, and went back to his beans. But Hattie was looking at her father with something dawning in her face, something like the first crack of light under a door.
---
Late that night, Jo found Ned in the equipment shed, sharpening his grafting knife on the whetstone with slow, even strokes. The blade sang faintly with each pass. On the bench beside him lay Sadie's journal, open to a page near the middle — a diagram of a whip-and-tongue graft, her neat hand labeling each part: *scion, stock, cambium matched to cambium.*
"I can save the variety," Jo said quietly from the doorway. "That's what I should have said this afternoon, instead of just telling you to cut." She came in and stood across the bench from him. "The Snow Apple she was breeding — the variety lives in the wood, Ned, not in the roots. We cut healthy scions from her trees, this week, before the blight takes the upper limbs. We graft them onto hardy young rootstock in the nursery bed. Her apple goes on living — on new trees, clean trees." She paused. "But the old row has to come down. All of it. There's no other way. I'm sorry."
Ned ran his thumb along the knife's edge. A thin line of blood welled up. He watched it without flinching.
"She'd hate me for it," he said.
"No." Jo's voice was firm. "She'd hate the blight for it. There's a difference, and I think you know it."
He looked up at her then, and the lamplight showed his face stripped bare — not the controlled orchardist, not the grieving widower performing his grief like a duty, just a tired man of forty-eight holding a knife he didn't know how to lift.
"Tomorrow," he said. "We'll do it tomorrow."
Jo nodded. She didn't touch him. She didn't need to. She picked up a second knife and began sharpening it beside him, stroke for stroke, and the two blades sang together in the lamplit shed like something being tuned.
Outside, the wind moved through Sadie's row — through the crossed limbs and the cankered bark and the black heaps under the trees — and for the first time in four years, Ned listened to it not as a widower guarding a shrine, but as an orchardist hearing a diagnosis.