THE RIGHT TO WAIT HERE

Chapter 14

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The conference room on the fourteenth floor had no windows, which Eleanor decided was deliberate — a room designed so that no one could look away toward anything kinder than the table. The court reporter's fingers hovered over her machine. David Okafor sat across from Eleanor with a legal pad, a water carafe, and the unhurried patience of a man who had done this a thousand times and intended to do it exactly right one more time.

Eleanor's own lawyer, a woman named Greta Lindqvist with silver hair sat beside her and said, "Just answer the question asked. Nothing more."

"Good morning, Mrs. Price," David said. "Please state your full name for the record."

"Eleanor Diane Price."

"Mrs. Price, I'm going to play a recording. I'd like you to listen carefully and then tell me if you recognize the voices."

Greta shifted. "Objection to the characterization —"

"You haven't heard the recording yet, counsel," David said pleasantly, and pressed play on the small speaker.

The room filled with the flat, compressed sound of a 911 call. A dispatcher's voice: "911, what's your emergency?" And then Eleanor's own voice, bright and civic-minded, a voice she used for school fundraisers and neighborhood watch meetings, saying, "Yes, hello, there's an unfamiliar Black man at our community pool. He's been there for some time and he doesn't look like he belongs here."

Eleanor watched her own hands on the table. They were perfectly still. She had no memory of deciding to make them still.

"Is that your voice, Mrs. Price?"

"Yes."

"And when you said 'an unfamiliar Black man,' what did you mean by 'unfamiliar'?"

"I didn't know him."

"Had you ever spoken to Mr. Reed?"

"No."

"Had you ever seen him before that day?"

"I may have. In passing."

"So he wasn't unfamiliar to you."

Greta said, "Objection, argumentative."

"I'll rephrase. Mrs. Price, the dispatcher asked you what the man was doing that seemed suspicious. Do you recall your answer?"

Eleanor looked at the transcript David slid across the table, her words printed in neat black rows. She read them the way one reads a stranger's diary.

"'He's just lying there,'" David read aloud. "'On a lounge chair. Sunbathing.' Mrs. Price — was Mr. Reed breaking any pool rule?"

"I don't know the pool rules by heart."

"Let me help." David produced the HOA's own pool regulations, highlighted. "There's no rule against sunbathing. There's no rule against being unfamiliar. There's no rule, in fact, that Mr. Reed violated in any way that day. Isn't that right?"

"He made people uncomfortable."

"Which people?"

A pause. "Several residents mentioned it."

"Name them."

"I don't remember exactly —"

David nodded as if she'd given him a gift, and made a note. Greta leaned in. "My client has answered. Move on, Mr. Okafor."

"Of course. Mrs. Price, let's talk about the word 'belong.' You told the dispatcher Mr. Reed didn't look like he belonged. The Reeds have owned their home for three years. They pay the same assessments you do. In what sense did he not belong?"

"He wasn't — I meant he was unfamiliar."

"Unfamiliar people use that pool every day. Guests. Grandchildren. Real estate agents. Did you call 911 on any of them?" Then he stood, walked to the screen at the end of the table, and dimmed the lights.

"Let's look at some text messages, Mrs. Price."

The projector threw her words ten feet tall. "Keep an eye on 14 Magnolia." "Suspicious vehicle again (the black SUV — you know the one)." "T wants extra patrols this weekend." Eleanor stared at the wall of her own sentences and felt the peculiar vertigo of being quoted accurately.

"Did you write these messages?"

"They were — it was a neighborhood watch chat. We discussed security."

"'The black SUV — you know the one.' Which one, Mrs. Price?"

"The Reeds' car."

"How did the other members of the chat know which one you meant?"

Silence. The court reporter's fingers moved, capturing the silence, which Eleanor understood — with a sudden cold clarity — was also testimony. "Let's try another one," David said. "'T wants extra patrols this weekend.' Who is T?"

"I don't recall."

"Your initial is E. Tom's is T. Was your husband requesting extra patrols?"

"You'd have to ask him."

"I intend to. He's noticed for next Thursday." David smiled, and Greta wrote something down so hard her pen tore the paper.

David let the quiet sit. Then, gently: "Mrs. Price, Officer Cho's report says he warned you, on the record, about making false reports. After the second 911 call. Do you remember that warning?"

"I remember he was very rude."

"Did you understand it as a warning?"

"I understood that the police had better things to do."

"Than respond to your calls."

"Objection," Greta said.

David held up a hand, conceding the point the way a fencer concedes a touch. He sat back down. For a long moment he simply looked at Eleanor — not unkindly, which was worse.

"Mrs. Price," he said, "is there anything you want to say to Mr. Reed? He's not here. This isn't for the jury. I'm just asking."

Something broke in Eleanor's face then — a crack, quick, before the mortar of fifty-six years reset itself. Tears came, sudden and humiliating, spotting the transcript.

"I was protecting my community," she said, and her voice shook. "That's all I ever did. I kept this place safe. Ask anyone. Ask —" She stopped. Wiped her eyes with the back of her hand, a gesture no fundraiser had ever seen. When she looked up, the crack was gone, mortared over, and her jaw was set.

"I was protecting my community," she repeated, flat now, daring him.

Greta put a hand on Eleanor's arm — a signal, or a mercy — and Eleanor understood that she had a choice: she could cry again, or she could be the woman this room expected her to be. She chose the room. She always chose the room. David regarded her for a moment. Then he closed his legal pad with a soft, definitive sound.

News in the same category

THE RIGHT TO WAIT HERE

20 Part