them.
"Yes, I'm at Blackstone," Jim said. "With Leo. He's here with me. He's safe. He's — Sarah, he's done
something wonderful today. He fixed Dutch's bike."
Another pause. Longer this time. Jim's face tightened.
"I know," Jim said. "I know it's been a long time. I know why I stayed away. I thought — I thought
you wanted —" He stopped. He took a breath. "Sarah, Leo found something. In the bike. He found
it himself."
Leo leaned in closer, trying to hear. He could hear a faint sound from the phone, like a voice far
away, but he could not make out the words.
Then Jim's voice changed. It got quieter, and more careful, and Leo saw fear pass across Jim's face
— fear that he was saying too much.
"I haven't told him everything," Jim said quickly. "I haven't — Sarah, I promise, I haven't told him
—"
He stopped again, listening. Leo watched his big hand tighten around the phone.
Then Jim said, softly, "I understand. I won't. I won't tell him anything else."
He held the phone out to Leo. "She wants to talk to you," Jim said.
Leo took the phone. It felt big and warm in his small hand. He pressed it to his ear.
"Mom?" he said.
"Leo, sweetheart," his mom said, and her voice sounded strange. Not angry. Not the way she
sounded when he was in trouble. Fearful. Like she was trying very hard to sound calm, but her
voice was shaking underneath, the way a table shakes when a big truck goes by outside.
"Mom, are you okay?" Leo asked.
"I'm okay, sweetheart," she said, but Leo did not quite believe her. "I'm just — I wasn't expecting a
call from Jim. Not after all this time. Leo, listen to me. Did Jim tell you — did he show you
something?"
Leo looked at Jim. Jim was looking at the floor, his eyes down, his hands clasped. Leo remembered
what Jim had just said on the phone: I won't tell him anything else. And he remembered his
mom's fear. He did not want to lie to his mom, but he also did not want to make her more scared.
"He showed me a letter from Dad," Leo said, truthfully. "And a picture. And a paper about Dutch's
bike."
His mom was quiet for a second. Leo could hear her breathing, fast and shallow, like she had
been running.
"Leo," she said, very carefully, "do not — sweetheart, I need you to listen. Do not let Jim tell you
anything else. Not yet. Not until I get there. Do you understand?"
Leo nodded, even though she could not see him. "Yes, Mom."
"Good boy," she said, and her voice wobbled. "I'm coming. I'm coming right now."
Leo swallowed. The question that had been growing in his chest all afternoon, since he read his
dad's letter, since he found the transfer paper, since he heard about the second chance — it
pushed its way up, and he could not hold it back anymore.
"Mom," Leo said. "Why did Dad need a second chance?"
There was silence on the other end of the phone. Not a short silence. A long silence, the kind that
fills a whole room, the kind Leo had heard in the garage after the engine shut down. He could
hear his mom breathing. He could hear a clock ticking somewhere in their house, far away.
Jim was still looking at the floor. He had not moved.
Leo waited. He held the phone tighter. He thought about his dad's letter: "He gave me a second
chance when nobody else would. And someday, if the time is right, someone will have to tell you
what that second chance was."
Maybe the time was right now. Maybe his mom would tell him, right now, on the phone.
Leo waited for her answer.
9
"Mom?" Leo said again, because the silence had gone on so long he was worried the phone had
cut off.
"I'm here, sweetheart," his mom said. Her voice was quieter now. Not shaky-quiet. Steady-quiet,
the way a person sounds when they have decided something important.
Leo held his breath.
"Because, sweetheart, Arthur Hayes wasn't the name your father was born with."
Leo stared at the phone.
He did not understand. He understood each word separately — because, sweetheart, Arthur
Hayes, wasn't, the name, your father, was born with — but put together, they did not make sense.
His dad's name was Arthur Hayes. It had always been Arthur Hayes. It was on the tag. It was on
the letter. It was on Leo's own last name. Hayes. Leo Hayes. How could Arthur Hayes not be the
name his father was born with?
Leo's mind raced, the way it did when he was trying to figure out an engine problem and all the
pieces were there but they would not fit together yet. Was his dad's name something else? Did
that mean his dad had been somebody else, before Leo, before his mom, before the garage and
the kitchen table?
He opened his mouth, but no question came out. His throat felt tight. His hand, holding the
phone, felt numb.
Jim's eyes were still on the floor. Jim did not look up. Jim did not say anything. Leo could tell Jim