Fletcher leaned forward.
“Where did you take him?”
Whitcomb hesitated.
Then she answered.
“To Richmond.”
For sixteen years, investigators had believed Nathaniel disappeared somewhere near Ashford County.
Now Whitcomb claimed she had driven him more than an hour away.
Fletcher asked for details.
Whitcomb described the route.
She remembered stopping for fuel.
She recalled that Nathaniel spent much of the drive discussing the technical report.
He wanted the county to preserve the records.
He wanted independent testing.
And he wanted legal advice before signing any additional documents.
“Where did you leave him?” Fletcher asked.
Whitcomb looked down.
“At a hotel near downtown Richmond.”
“Which hotel?”
She named it.
“Did you see him enter?”
“Yes.”
“Did he have luggage?”
“A laptop bag.”
“Did he appear injured or distressed?”
“He was upset, but physically fine.”
“Did he say where he was going afterward?”
“He said he would contact his attorney.”
“Did you hear from him again?”
Whitcomb shook her head.
“No.”
“Did you report this information when he was declared missing?”
She looked down.
“No.”
“Why not?”
Her voice became quieter.
“Because I was afraid.”
Fletcher waited.
Whitcomb continued.
“I thought the county would be blamed for his disappearance.”
“And you believed remaining silent would prevent that?”
“Yes.”
She paused.
“It was a terrible decision.”
The investigators verified Whitcomb's account where possible.
The hotel had changed ownership.
Most records were gone.
But archived financial statements showed a room payment on the date in question.
The payment had been made with a card associated with Nathaniel's employer.
A former hotel clerk remembered a man matching his description.
The clerk could not recall his name.
But she remembered that he had asked for a quiet room and directions to a nearby law office.
The evidence supported part of Whitcomb's account.
It suggested Nathaniel had reached Richmond.
But it still did not explain what happened next.
Fletcher contacted Samuel Hart again.
The retired attorney reviewed his old appointment book.
He found an entry.
N. Cross — urgent consultation.
The appointment was scheduled for the afternoon after Nathaniel disappeared.
But another notation appeared beneath it.
Client requested earlier meeting. Unable to accommodate.
Fletcher stared at the words.
“Did he call you again?”
Hart frowned.
“I don't remember.”
“Could he have come to your office?”
“Possibly.”
“Would there be a record?”
“Maybe in the old reception logs.”
The law firm had merged with another practice years earlier.
Its records were stored off-site.
Investigators obtained the relevant files.
Among them was a visitor log.
On the date Nathaniel disappeared, a handwritten entry appeared at 4:18 p.m.
Nathaniel Cross — walk-in consultation request.
Beside it was a note.
Attorney unavailable. Client left message.
Fletcher looked at Hale.
“He made it to the law office.”
Hale nodded.
“Then he was alive in Richmond that afternoon.”
“Yes.”
Fletcher looked at the time.
“Now we need to know where he went afterward.”
The next clue came from a parking garage.
The law office had occupied a building connected to a public garage.
The garage operator retained certain old billing records.
Investigators found a transaction associated with Nathaniel's employer card.
It showed a parking payment at 5:02 p.m.
But Nathaniel had not been driving his rental vehicle.
That vehicle had already been returned.
The payment suggested he may have used another car.
Investigators examined the associated records.
The vehicle registration belonged to a rental company.
The rental agreement had been issued under Nathaniel's name.
It had been opened at a Richmond branch that afternoon.
The vehicle was returned three days later.
Not in Virginia.
In North Carolina.
Fletcher stared at the record.
“Where?”
Hale looked at the screen.
“Greensboro.”
The discovery changed the direction of the case.
Nathaniel had apparently traveled from Richmond toward North Carolina.
The rental vehicle had been returned in Greensboro.
But the person who returned it had not been identified in the surviving records.
Investigators contacted the rental company's archives.
A scanned receipt contained a signature.
The name was difficult to read.
It did not clearly match Nathaniel's handwriting.
Fletcher requested a forensic examination.
The results were inconclusive.
The signature could not be reliably attributed.
The investigation remained open.
Caroline received the update with mixed emotions.
For sixteen years, she had believed Nathaniel disappeared in Virginia.
Now investigators had evidence suggesting he may have traveled closer to home.
Greensboro was less than two hours from Raleigh.
He might have been trying to return.
Or he might have been traveling for another reason.
The uncertainty was painful.
Emily sat beside her mother.
“Mom, this means he was alive after the meeting.”
Caroline nodded.
“Yes.”
“That's something.”
“Yes.”
Emily looked toward the photograph on the mantel.
“Maybe he was coming home.”
Caroline closed her eyes.
“Maybe.”
Victoria learned about the Greensboro connection during a visit from Emily.