Cleary shifted in his chair.
"The system has an automatic retention schedule."
"Who is responsible for suspending it?"
"The evidence supervisor."
"Was the supervisor notified?"
"I'd have to check."
Foster nodded. "Please do."
The exchange lasted less than two minutes. But for Cleary it was unfamiliar territory. He was accustomed to being asked whether his department needed more money or equipment, not whether its internal procedures could be independently verified.
After the hearing, a reporter approached him outside.
"Do you regret the way you handled Mr. Brooks?"
Cleary looked toward his vehicle.
"The case is being reviewed. I'm not discussing it."
"Do you regret breaking the identification card?"
His jaw tightened.
"No comment."
He drove away irritated that people seemed unwilling to accept his explanation. At a stoplight, he remembered Mooney asking whether they should verify the card.
He had heard the question as defiance.
* * *
For the first time, he considered that the deputy might simply have been asking him to do his job.
Isaiah's first volunteer assignment was at a neighborhood repair day organized by a church near Naomi's house.
The volunteers painted railings, replaced smoke-detector batteries, cleared overgrown walkways, and helped elderly residents with small repairs they could no longer manage themselves.
Isaiah worked with Denise from his inspection class. Their first stop was a one-story home where an eighty-year-old widow named Mrs. Parker needed help replacing a loose porch step.
Denise measured while Isaiah held the board steady.
Mrs. Parker watched from a lawn chair.
"My husband built those steps in 1987," she said.
"He did good work," Isaiah replied. "The wood's just had a long life."
She laughed. "Haven't we all."
When they finished, she insisted they take bottled water and homemade cookies. Isaiah accepted both.
Later that afternoon, they inspected a loose handrail at another house. Isaiah found himself explaining why the fasteners had failed and how a simple change could make the rail safer.
Denise listened.
"You teach well," she said.
"I did a lot of it in the Army."
"Maybe you should teach this stuff."
He shrugged. "Maybe after I learn it properly."
On the drive home, he passed a billboard advertising a sheriff's department community event. Cleary's photograph appeared in one corner.
Isaiah felt the familiar tightening in his chest, but it eased before the next intersection.
At dinner, Naomi asked how the volunteer day had gone.
"Good," he said. "Fixed a porch step. Met a woman who makes cookies better than yours."
Naomi pointed her fork at him.
"Careful."
Ava laughed, and Isaiah laughed with her.
For a few minutes the conversation had nothing to do with evidence, hearings, or the damaged card.
That was progress too.
The mediation session was held in a plain office building with a view of a parking garage.
Isaiah sat beside Caroline while representatives for the county and its insurer occupied the opposite side of the table. The mediator explained that the process was confidential and voluntary, and that the purpose was to explore whether the civil claims could be resolved without a trial.
Isaiah had prepared a statement, though Caroline had warned him he might not need to read it.
When the mediator invited him to speak, he unfolded the paper.
"I didn't come here because I wanted special treatment," he began. "I came because I was stopped on a public road, and the person with the badge decided I was lying about who I was. He broke my identification before verifying it. Then he wrote a report that didn't match the recording."
He looked at the people across from him.
"I know police work can be difficult. I know people make mistakes. I spent my career supervising people who made mistakes. The question was always what happened next. Did we tell the truth? Did we correct the record? Did we learn anything?"
His voice remained steady.
"I lost two days of my freedom. I lost money. I lost sleep. And I started feeling nervous doing things that used to be ordinary, like driving to visit my sister."
He folded the paper.
"I want the county to acknowledge what the evidence shows. I want the records corrected. I want changes that make it harder for this to happen again."
The mediator thanked him.
The discussions lasted most of the day. There were breaks, private conversations, requests for clarification, and long periods when Isaiah and Caroline sat alone with paper cups of coffee.
No one made a speech that changed everything.
At one point Isaiah asked Caroline whether settling would mean admitting the sheriff had done nothing wrong.
"Not necessarily," she said. "The terms matter. So does what you need from the process."
"And if I don't like the terms?"
"We don't agree."
He looked at the parking garage.
For years he'd been trained to make decisions quickly with incomplete information. This one required him to slow down and consider what kind of outcome he could live with.
By late afternoon the parties had narrowed several issues but had not reached final agreement.
Isaiah was tired. He was also relieved that nobody had demanded an answer before he was ready.