Elias looked at her. "You knew?"
"I drafted the trust amendments with Mother. You were busy opening the Chicago location."
There it was again: not accusation exactly, but the record of an absence.
Naomi turned to the service-charge reports. Servers had been told that a portion of private-event gratuities was reserved for 'administrative handling.' The handbook promised full distribution, minus disclosed processing fees. The totals did not match.
"This could be thousands of dollars," Naomi said.
Nora corrected her. "Across eighteen months and nine locations, it could be much more. We need an independent payroll specialist. Do not accuse anyone until the records are preserved."
Elias asked Naomi whether Victor had been notified of his visit.
"He called at six. Said he was flying in this afternoon."
"Tell him to come. Tell him the books remain untouched and every employee will be paid for interview time. And tell him I won't be signing anything until we know what happened."
Nora gave him a cautious glance. "That's a beginning."
"It's all I have today."
The door opened. Rosa stood in the threshold with a handwritten list.
"I'm sorry to interrupt," she said. "People keep telling me there's going to be an investigation. If there is, I think you should speak to the dishwashers."
Elias rose. "Please come in."
Rosa held the list close to her apron. "We don't have lawyers. Some of us barely have English enough for the complaint forms. The night shift's been losing hours on the payroll system, and when we ask, they say the computer must be right."
Elias looked at Nora, who was already pulling up a chair for her.
"Then the computer is the next thing we question," he said.
Rosa laid her handwritten schedule beside the printed timesheet and pointed to a Tuesday three weeks earlier. She had arrived at four in the afternoon to help prepare a corporate dinner. The system recorded her clock-in at five fourteen. On the Friday after, it recorded her departure at nine when she had stayed until nearly midnight.
"Did you report that?" Nora asked.
"Twice. My supervisor said the entry was adjusted by headquarters because the event went over budget."
Nora's pen stopped. "Those are two very different things."
Rosa opened a paper folder containing bus receipts, text messages and photographs of the kitchen clock. She had kept them because her late husband had always told her to save proof of important things. The photographs showed team members cleaning pans well after their recorded clock-out times.
"I asked the others to write down their hours," Rosa said. "Some didn't want to. I don't blame them. But twelve people gave me something."
Naomi studied the forms. The missing time wasn't random; discrepancies clustered around large private events, exactly when management bonuses depended on labor-cost percentages. A complicated electronic payroll system could make an error, but it would not consistently favor the employer in one type of event without raising questions.
"We need every employee's record, not only yours," Nora said. "And we need a way for people to speak without their supervisors listening."
Elias reached for the photograph of the kitchen clock. In the background a young porter was laughing at something out of frame. "What's his name?"
"Mateo. He stopped coming last month."
"Why?"
"He complained about missing tips. They said he'd abandoned a shift. His mother was in the emergency room. He had asked to leave early."
Elias felt a prickling shame. He had seen the monthly turnover figures and congratulated Victor for keeping staffing 'flexible.' The phrase now sounded like a polite word for someone else's panic.
Before lunch Nora called an employment lawyer from a firm that did not do business with Mercer Dining Group. The lawyer, Amrita Shah, agreed to organize a confidential payroll review, provided she could speak to employees without management present and preserve records before anyone changed them.
"You're asking us to uncover our own liability," Elias told her.
"Yes," Shah answered. "If you're seeking reassurance, you've called the wrong person."
He liked her immediately.
Meanwhile Adrian was sent to clear silverware in the empty banquet room. He knew the investigation had started because the staff group chat was erupting with speculation. Some called him a fool. Others said he had only followed orders. One person posted a photo of Elias in his old coat beside a caption: GUESS WHO BRINGS THE REAL MONEY.
Adrian deleted the conversation without responding.
When Naomi found him, he was lining up forks so precisely that their handles formed a ruler-straight edge.
"Amrita Shah will interview you this afternoon," she said. "You can have a representative or support person there."
"Do I get paid?"
"Yes."
"And Brent?"
"He'll be interviewed separately."