And the Birmingham branch had received unusually high customer satisfaction scores even though its internal complaint volume appeared almost impossibly low.
The numbers did not make sense.
Otis knew enough about restaurant operations to understand that a location serving hundreds of customers each week would inevitably receive complaints.
A perfect record was not always a sign of excellence.
Sometimes it was evidence that nobody was allowed to complain.
He had printed copies of the deleted complaints and placed them inside the glove compartment of his red pickup truck.
He had also arranged for two compliance teams to wait in unmarked vehicles approximately four miles away.
They were prepared to enter the restaurant once he gave the signal.
But he wanted to observe the situation first.
He wanted to know whether the problems were limited to food storage.
Or whether the entire management culture had become corrupted.
His grandfather's old recipe card rested inside his wallet.
It was one of the few possessions Otis had kept through every stage of his life.
The card was yellowed with age.
Its corners were soft.
A faint brown stain marked the bottom edge, probably from a kitchen accident decades earlier.
His grandfather had written the recipe in careful handwriting.
Four ingredients.
One preparation method.
And one sentence at the bottom.
Feed people the way you'd feed your own child.
Otis had carried that card for more than thirty years.
It reminded him that the company was never supposed to become simply another restaurant chain.
His grandfather had believed food was an act of trust.
When somebody paid for a meal, they were trusting the person preparing it.
They trusted that the ingredients were safe.
They trusted that the kitchen was clean.
They trusted that the people behind the counter cared whether they became sick.
That trust was the foundation of Magnolia Morning.
And Otis had begun to suspect that somebody in Birmingham had forgotten it.
He selected booth seven.
It was positioned near the middle of the dining room, close enough to the kitchen pass-through that he could observe the employees without appearing to stare.
A waitress approached with a coffee pot.
She was an older white woman with silver-blond hair pulled into a loose bun.
Her name tag read MAY.
"Coffee?"
"Please."
"Regular?"
"Black."
She poured carefully.
"Menu's right there. Take your time."
"Thank you."
May offered a brief smile before moving toward the next table.
Otis wrapped both hands around the coffee cup.
It was hot.
The restaurant was moderately busy, but not crowded.
A construction worker occupied booth two.
Two elderly men were discussing a football game near the window.
A young couple sat beside the pastry display.
At booth six, an older white gentleman was reading a newspaper while eating scrambled eggs.
Behind the counter stood the shift manager.
Donnie Pike.
Otis recognized him immediately from the personnel records.
Thirty-eight years old.
Three years with the company.
Promoted to shift manager after receiving favorable recommendations from regional director Brett Howerin.
Donnie wore a white shirt, black trousers, and a narrow red tie.
His dark hair was slicked backward.
His smile was polished, but there was something uncomfortable about the way it changed depending on who approached him.
When an older white customer asked for additional coffee, Donnie personally carried a fresh pot across the dining room.
"Of course, Mr. Jenkins. Anything else?"
"Could I get another biscuit?"
"Absolutely."
Donnie laughed.
"Wouldn't want you going hungry."
The customer chuckled.
A moment later, a young Black delivery driver approached the counter.
"Excuse me. I have an order for pickup."
Donnie did not look up.
"Name?"
"Terrence."
"Last name?"
"Walker."
Donnie glanced at the tablet.
"Not ready."
"Okay. About how long?"
"When it's ready."
The delivery driver nodded and stepped aside.
Otis watched the exchange.
He did not immediately draw conclusions.
A busy employee could sound impatient without being discriminatory.
A manager could make mistakes without being malicious.
But patterns mattered.
And Otis was beginning to recognize one.
Through the kitchen pass-through, he noticed a Black woman working at the preparation station.
She appeared to be in her late forties.
Her hair was pulled beneath a dark kitchen cap, and her movements were deliberate and economical.
She checked a tray, wiped the counter, inspected a container, and returned to preparing food.
Her name tag read LORETTA.
Otis recognized her name from the employee records.
Loretta Hayes.
Eleven years with Magnolia Morning.
No disciplinary history.
Several positive customer comments from earlier years.
Three safety reports submitted during the previous six months.
All three had been closed without documented corrective action.
Otis watched her for several seconds.
She looked up.
Their eyes met.
Loretta did not smile.
Instead, she glanced toward Donnie, then toward the storage hallway behind the kitchen.
Something about her expression caught Otis's attention.
It was not ordinary suspicion.