"I heard breathing," Emily insisted, her voice
rising to a hysterical pitch, fighting against his grip.
"Mark, I swear to God, I heard someone breathing
in there!"
Mark looked at the hole. His jaw tightened. The
protective instinct of a soon-to-be father took over.
A few moments later, the two officers emerged
from the hole in the nursery wall. Between them,
they dragged a figure.
Emily gasped, taking a step back.
It was a man, though he barely looked like one.
He was emaciated, his clothes hanging off his
skeletal frame in filthy, rotting rags. His hair was
long, matted, and gray, hanging over a face that
was smeared with dirt and grime. But it was his
eyes that struck Emily the most. They were wide,
feral, and darted frantically around the brightly lit
nursery, blinking against the sunlight as if it burned
him.
He didn't look like a master criminal. He looked
like a ghost that had been dragged kicking and
screaming into the land of the living.
"Is that... Elias Thorne?" Mark asked, his voice
filled with disbelief, referencing the century-old
photograph Emily had told him about.
"Hardly," Sergeant Miller panted, shoving the
man toward the doorway. "Though he looks like he's
been in there since the house was built. This is
Arthur Vance."
Emily frowned. The name meant nothing to her.
But Mrs. Gable at the library would have
recognized it instantly. Arthur Vance was a local
drifter, a man with severe mental illness who had
gone missing from the Oakhaven homeless shelter
nearly five years ago.
"He's been living up there," Deputy Davis said,
brushing dust off his uniform with a look of intense
disgust. "In the attic space above the turret. He's got
a whole nest set up. Blankets, food wrappers, jars
of... waste. He was tapping into the electrical lines
to run a small space heater."
Emily felt a wave of nausea wash over her. Five
years. This man had been living in the walls of the
house for five years. Through all the previous
owners, through the vacancy, and through the
months she and Mark had been renovating. He had
been there, separated from her by a mere inch of
plaster, listening to her sing lullabies, watching
them through the cracks.
The breathing she heard. The click of the latch.
It was all real.
"Why did he come down to this level?" Mark
asked, gesturing to the hole behind the crib.
Miller shone his flashlight on the interior of the
passage. On the back side of the nursery wall, there
was a small, sliding wooden panel—a peephole,
likely built by Elias Thorne a century ago to spy on
the occupants of the house.
"He was watching you," Miller said grimly.