Then a folded letter slipped from between two ledgers.
His name was written across it.
SILAS MERCER.
His hands stopped moving.
Molly noticed.
"That's yours?"
Silas stared at the handwriting.
He knew it.
He knew every curve.
Every slant.
Every imperfect R.
Ruth.
He opened the letter.
The paper was yellowed.
The ink had faded.
But the first line remained clear.
Silas,
If this reaches you, then Vale has already discovered I kept copies.
Silas stopped breathing.
He read it again.
Then again.
Ruth had written the letter twelve years earlier.
Before her supposed death.
She explained that while volunteering at the county infirmary, she had discovered Vale was falsifying death certificates and property records.
She had found names of dead miners whose land was being transferred to companies secretly controlled by Vale.
She had discovered payments made to doctors.
She had discovered false burial records.
She had planned to expose him.
Then the final paragraph made Silas's hands tremble.
If they tell you I died of fever, do not believe them.
Silas pushed back from the table.
The chair fell behind him.
Molly flinched.
He continued reading.
They have threatened to move me under another name if I speak. Dr. Voss is helping Vale. If I disappear, look for the burial register. They cannot erase both books without exposing themselves.
Silas closed his eyes.
For eleven years, he had visited Ruth's grave.
Eleven years.
Every Christmas.
Every anniversary.
Every spring.
He had stood beneath the cottonwood and spoken to the woman he thought lay beneath the earth.
He had told her he was sorry.
He had told her he should have been there.
He had told her he still loved her.
Now he wondered whether the grave had ever contained her.
Molly pointed toward the bottom of the page.
"There's more."
Silas looked.
A later note had been written in different ink.
RUTH MERCER TRANSFERRED — BENNETT COUNTY WOMEN'S HOUSE, NAME CHANGED TO RUTH HALE.
Silas stared.
Hale.
His mother's maiden name.
He sat down slowly.
"She's alive."
Molly nodded.
"Who?"
Silas looked at her.
"My wife."
The girl said nothing.
Something in her expression troubled him.
"You knew."
Molly looked away.
"Mama told us about her."
Silas stood.
"What did she tell you?"
"That Ruth was our mother."
The words struck him harder than any bullet.
Silas could barely breathe.
"What?"
Molly looked frightened.
Before she could explain, the sound of a horse came from outside.
Silas moved toward the window.
Nobody.
Just snow.
He turned back.
"We're going to town."
Molly shook her head.
"No."
"You are."
"We can't."
"Why?"
"Mr. Vale knows about the bag."
Silas froze.
"How?"
"Mama said he would come if she died."
The sentence had barely left Molly's mouth when a rifle shot shattered the window.
Silas threw Molly to the floor.
A second bullet tore into the wall.
Bluebell screamed outside.
Silas grabbed his rifle.
Men appeared through the snow.
Three riders.
At the center was Edwin Vale.
He dismounted slowly.
"Mercer!"
Silas moved beside the door.
Vale shouted:
"Those documents belong to the county!"
Silas looked at the papers.
Then toward Molly.
Then back at the door.
"So did Lydia Bennett's food."
Silence.
Then Vale laughed.
"She was a thief."
Molly stood.
Silas grabbed her arm.
But the girl stepped toward the broken window.
"You killed my papa!"
Vale's smile vanished.
That tiny reaction was enough.
Silas saw it.
Murderers could lie.
They could threaten.
They could smile.
But sometimes they forgot to control their faces.
Vale had just forgotten.
"Molly, down!"
Gunfire erupted.
Silas fired once.
One of Vale's men fell from his horse.
The second bolted.
Vale ran toward the barn.
Silas pursued.
The storm swallowed them both.
The Name Ruth
Vale entered the barn and slammed the door behind him.
Silas kicked it open.
The smell of hay and horses filled the air.
Vale seized a pitchfork.
"You should have stayed lonely, Mercer."
Silas stopped.
"What did you say?"
Vale smiled.
"Ruth always said loneliness would make you careless."
Silas felt the blood drain from his face.
"You saw her."
Vale said nothing.
"You saw Ruth after the infirmary."
"She was difficult."
"Where is she?"
Vale lunged.
Silas stepped aside.
The pitchfork struck a wooden post.
Silas drove the rifle stock into Vale's jaw.
The county administrator crashed against the stalls.
Silas seized him by the coat.
"Where is she?"
Vale laughed through blood.
"You think Lydia found those papers by accident?"
Silas stopped.
Vale's eyes glittered.
"She didn't find them."
Silas tightened his grip.
"Who gave them to her?"
Vale smiled.
"Ask Molly."
Silas slowly released him.
He turned.
Molly stood in the barn doorway.
Her face was white.
Silas walked toward her.
"Molly?"
The girl began crying.
These were not the quiet tears of hunger.
These were frightened tears.
"Mama made me promise."
"Promise what?"
Molly reached into the inner pocket of her cardigan.
She pulled out a small silver locket.
She opened it.
Inside was a tiny faded portrait.
Silas forgot how to breathe.
Ruth.
Older.
Thinner.
But Ruth.
He had memorized that face.
He had spent eleven years remembering it.
Molly whispered:
"Her name is Ruth Hale."
Silas looked at the girl.
Then at the photograph.
Then back at Molly.
Something about her eyes suddenly became impossible to ignore.
He had noticed those eyes in the shack.
He had simply refused to see what they meant.
"You look like her."
Molly cried harder.
Silas's voice became barely audible.
"Is Ruth your mother?"
Molly nodded.
"And Annie?"
"My sister."
Silas stepped backward.
His mind began doing arithmetic he did not want to do.
Ruth had disappeared eleven years ago.
Molly was eight.
Annie was four.
They could not be his daughters.
Unless—
Vale began laughing.
Silas turned toward him.
"What?"
The county administrator wiped blood from his mouth.
"Still don't understand?"
Silas raised his rifle.
"Talk."
Vale smiled.
"Ruth escaped three years after we moved her."
"Moved her where?"
"Between the infirmary and the women's house."
"Why?"
"Because she knew too much."
Silas's voice shook.
"And the children?"
Vale's smile widened.
"She took something with her."
"What?"
"Your frozen samples from Dr. Voss's fertility study."
Silas stared blankly.
For a moment, the words meant nothing.
Then a memory surfaced.
A doctor's office.
A younger Ruth sitting beside him.
Dr. Voss explaining that they were trying an experimental fertility procedure.
Silas signing papers.
Medical samples.