THE WITNESS WHO WROTE THE LAW

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“That was your mistake.”

Nobody laughed.

Nobody celebrated Daniel's embarrassment.

Even the judge seemed uncomfortable.

Because Arthur wasn't trying to humiliate him.

He was teaching him something.

In 1981, Arthur Bennett was twenty-nine years old.

He wasn't a famous attorney.

He wasn't a politician.

He was a legislative researcher.

His specialty was public access and civil rights.

He spent months interviewing ordinary citizens.

Farmers.

Small business owners.

Factory workers.

Disabled residents.

Teachers.

People who rarely had an opportunity to speak to lawmakers.

They all told him the same thing.

The law was supposed to protect them.

But too often, complicated wording made that protection impossible to understand.

Arthur believed legislation should be clear enough for ordinary people to understand.

He joined a committee tasked with drafting a new public-access statute.

The committee had lawyers.

Judges.

Professors.

Politicians.

And Arthur.

He was the person who kept asking one question:

“What happens to an ordinary person when this law is actually used?”

His colleagues initially found him frustrating.

But eventually, they realized he was right.

Every paragraph was rewritten.

Every definition was debated.

Every exception was examined.

Arthur wrote much of the original language.

He spent years defending it.

And decades later, the same law was still being interpreted in court.

Arthur had never stopped caring about it.

The case before the court involved a dispute over one sentence.

A corporation argued that the statute did not apply to a particular group of citizens.

The plaintiff's attorney, Daniel Whitmore, believed the wording supported his interpretation.

Arthur disagreed.

The judge asked:

“Mr. Bennett, why do you believe the disputed section should be interpreted differently?”

Arthur opened his folder.

“Because one sentence is missing.”

Daniel looked confused.

“What sentence?”

Arthur pulled out an old document.

“The original draft included this.”

He read the handwritten note.

News in the same category

THE WITNESS WHO WROTE THE LAW

7 Part