were. Pieces of a machine, and the machine had been a wagon, and the
wagon had gone up to a clean spring in the dark with a load no honest
manifest would carry.
Slade was brought in with his hands chained in front of him, and the room
went quiet in a way that had judgment in it. He had dressed for the day in a
good coat, and his lawyer had shaved him, and neither did what it was meant
to do, because a man in irons is a man in irons, and the chain spoke louder
than the tailoring. He did not look at Emmett. He looked at the table — at the
sack corner and the hub-band — the way a man looks at a letter he wishes he
had burned.
The judge was a spare, tired man named Alcorn who had the manner of a
103
schoolmaster who has stopped expecting the class to improve. He opened the
matter without ceremony. There were, he said, two questions before the
court, and the court would take them in order. The first was a question of
water: the claim filed by Vernon Slade asserting that the Cole well drew
upon and diminished a source in which Slade held an interest, and asserting a
prior right. The second was a matter the court would hear as an examination:
whether Vernon Slade should be held to answer, at the territorial court, for
the poisoning of the Eagle Rock spring. The claim first. Paper first.
Brandt was sworn and took the chair, and told it the way he had lived it —
plainly, in order, with the times of day attached. The morning at the Cole
ranch. The riders on the ridge. The written demand Slade had served,
claiming the well. The confession Burt Kellam had made and signed, which
Brandt had in his coat. And then the thing Brandt had done, described
without any ornament at all, as if it had been the only idea available to a
reasonable man: standing between Slade's hired rifles and the Mescalero
camp across the creek, he had read both papers aloud — the claim and the
confession — loud enough for every man on the ridge and in the yard to hear
exactly what the paper said.
"And then?" the judge asked.
"Then his men started doing arithmetic," Brandt said, and a sound went
through the room that was not quite laughter. "A claim's one thing, Judge.
Men will ride for a claim if the pay's right, because a claim might be law. But
Kellam's paper said poisoning, and that's a hanging kind of word to hear read
out in the open. They put their rifles down one at a time. Mr. Slade fired one
shot at the ground by my feet — the only shot fired that morning — and I
arrested him, and it's my testimony he fired it after the arrest was declared,
which the court can weigh as it likes."
104
"Were you afraid, Sheriff?" Slade's lawyer asked, on the cross. He was a
smooth young man from the capital named Teague, with a watch chain and a
voice like warm oil.
"I was scared the whole morning," Brandt said. "It's why nobody's dead.
Scared men read paper. It's the fearless ones that shoot first, and there wasn't
a fearless man on that ridge, including the one in irons."
Emmett watched the clerk write it down, the pen moving without pause, and
felt something shift in his understanding of the morning that had decided his
life. He had remembered it as a stand, a thing of nerve and rifles. In the
record it was becoming something else: a reading. A man had stood in a yard
and read two documents aloud, and an army had dissolved because the words
were true and spoken where they could be heard. Paper had nearly killed
them all, in the shape of a claim. Paper had saved them, in the shape of a
confession read aloud. It was not the paper. It was who was willing to stand
behind it in the open.
Slade's lawyer argued the claim then, and argued it well. The well and the
spring drew on one basin, he said; his client's filing was regular, his interest
prior in time. He spoke of doctrines and sections for nearly an hour, the dust
hanging in the light from the high windows, while Emmett listened to his
whole life discussed as a question of underground geography and felt no
anger at all — only a deep strangeness, as if he had died and this was the
inventory.
Then they brought in Burt Kellam, and the room's attention changed its
quality, the way air changes before rain.
He had been Slade's foreman for six years. He was a big man gone soft in the
middle, with a freighter's hands and a face weathered into something
honest-looking by twenty years of sun, and he came up the aisle with his
105
eyes on the floor, holding his hat in both hands the way a man holds a bowl
he is afraid of spilling. The clerk read his confession aloud first, every word
of it, so that the testimony would walk ground the paper had already covered.
The night rides to the Eagle Rock spring. The sacks, three to a load, freighted
up the arroyo on Slade's big wagon with the wheels wrapped in sacking
against the noise. The cutting of the sacks at the pool's edge and the shaking
out of their contents — arsenical sheep-dip powder, bought by Slade at Fort
Union for a flock he did not own — until the water went the color of weak