His throat tightened.
"Where did your father get this?"
Rebecca looked at him.
"He served as a chaplain during the war."
Caleb remembered.
Reverend Hale had rarely spoken of his military service.
He had always said there were some memories that belonged to God alone.
The document listed ammunition shipments, medical supplies, and troop movements.
At the bottom appeared a handwritten order.
Redirect the medical wagons to the southern road. Priority cargo to be secured under Captain Silas Vane.
Caleb's hands began trembling.
"No."
Rebecca watched him.
"Mr. Ward?"
Caleb shook his head slowly.
"Those wagons never came."
Miriam looked at him.
"What wagons?"
"Medical wagons."
His voice was barely audible.
"We had hundreds of wounded men. Men bleeding in the fields. Boys lying beneath fences with no bandages, no medicine, no surgeons."
He gripped the table.
"We were told the wagons had been destroyed."
Rebecca lowered her eyes.
"The records suggest they were diverted."
Caleb stared at Vane's signature.
For twelve years, he had carried the memory of wounded soldiers crying for help while supplies never arrived.
He had believed the disaster was caused by confusion.
Bad orders.
The chaos of war.
But now—
Now he understood.
Someone had chosen profit over lives.
Someone had allowed wounded men to die because the wagons carried medicine worth more than soldiers.
Caleb stepped backward.
Miriam reached for him.
"Caleb."
He could barely hear her.
The church seemed to tilt.
In his mind, he saw the battlefield again.
Mud.
Smoke.
Blood.
A boy named Peter Collins reaching toward him, begging for water.
A surgeon shouting for clean bandages.
Abigail's voice calling from somewhere far away.
Then another memory came.
Daniel.
His younger brother standing beside him after the battle, asking why the medical wagons had never arrived.
Caleb had no answer then.
He had one now.
Silas Vane.
Rebecca touched the ledger.
"Daniel believed these documents could bring Vane before a federal court."
Caleb looked at her.
"Where is he?"
She hesitated.
"I don't know."
"Rebecca."
"I swear."
He closed his eyes.
She continued.
"But he left something else."
She moved toward the pulpit and removed a small wooden box.
Inside lay a silver pocket watch.
Caleb recognized it immediately.
It had belonged to their father.
Daniel had carried it since childhood.
Caleb lifted it gently.
The glass was cracked.
Inside the back cover, Daniel had scratched a message.
North Fork. Three days after the first snow.
Caleb looked toward the window.
Snow had fallen two nights earlier.
His brother was waiting somewhere along North Fork.
Or he had been.
Caleb closed the watch.
"We leave now."
Rebecca stepped closer.
"Mr. Ward, there is more."
He turned.
She looked frightened.
"My father wrote one final warning before he died."
"What warning?"
Rebecca opened the last page of the ledger.
Across the paper, in shaky handwriting, were seven words.
Silas Vane is not working alone.
Caleb stared at the message.
Rebecca whispered, "The sheriff knows more than he's telling you."
Before anyone could answer, the church bell began ringing.
Once.
Twice.
Three times.
Rebecca looked up in confusion.
"No one is supposed to be in the tower."
Then came the sound of breaking glass.
A flaming bottle crashed through the eastern window.
Fire spread across the floor.
Miriam screamed.
Caleb grabbed the ledger.
Another bottle shattered near the altar.
Flames raced along the curtains.
Someone had set the church on fire.
And they had locked the doors from outside.
Smoke filled the church faster than Caleb expected.
The first flames caught the dry curtains and climbed toward the wooden rafters. Burning glass scattered across the floor. Within seconds, the eastern wall glowed orange.
Rebecca ran toward the main doors.
"They're locked!"
Caleb handed the ledger to Miriam.
"Keep that safe."
He crossed the room and threw his shoulder against the doors.
They did not move.
Outside, someone had pushed a heavy timber across the entrance.
Caleb stepped backward.
Then drove his boot into the lock.
The old wood cracked.
He kicked again.
Still nothing.
Miriam covered her mouth with her sleeve.
"Caleb!"
He turned.
Flames had reached the altar.
The heat was becoming unbearable.
Caleb grabbed a wooden bench and dragged it toward the nearest window.
"Help me!"
Miriam and Rebecca lifted one end.
Together, they drove it into the glass.
The window shattered.
Cold air rushed inside.
Caleb knocked loose the remaining shards with the butt of his rifle.
"Rebecca first!"
She climbed through.
Miriam followed, clutching the ledger against her chest.
Caleb turned toward the altar.
The flames had reached the pulpit.
For a terrible moment, he saw another burning building.
Another desperate escape.
Another room filled with smoke.
Then Miriam called from outside.
"Caleb!"
He shook himself free of the memory.
The roof cracked overhead.
He jumped through the window just as a burning beam collapsed where he had been standing.
They landed in the churchyard.
Rebecca coughed violently.
Miriam dropped to her knees beside her.
Caleb rolled onto his back, drawing cold air into his burning lungs.
Then he heard hoofbeats.
Three riders came around the corner of the building.
Their faces were covered with scarves.
One carried a revolver.
Another held an empty bottle.
Caleb rose to one knee.
"Down!"
He fired.
The first rider fell from his horse.
The others scattered.
One shot struck the church wall behind him.
Caleb fired again.
A horse screamed and bolted, throwing its rider into the snow.
The third man escaped down the road.
Caleb lowered his rifle.
Smoke poured from the church roof.
Within minutes, townspeople began running toward the flames.
Buckets appeared.
Men formed a line from the well.
Women carried blankets and supplies away from nearby homes.
Sheriff Harlan arrived with two deputies.
He stopped when he saw Caleb standing beside the burning church.
"What happened?"