"Son," he said. "I never touched her."
"Her shoulder is bleeding."
"It is not—" Franklin caught himself; he could see the scrape from where he stood, raw and bright, and disputing it was a fool's errand whatever its origin. "There is a mark on her shoulder. I did not put it there. Dominic, look at me. Look at me and tell me you believe I am a man who — "
"He said you'd say that."
It came from the wall. Alana's voice, wrecked and small, insinuated itself into the two feet of air between father and son with an accuracy that, later, would make even her own skin crawl. "He said — in the kitchen — he said if I ever told, you'd have to choose, and a son can't—" A sob closed over the sentence. "He said you'd never be able to believe it of him. He counted on it, Dom. He told me he counted on it."
"Is that true?" Dominic's face had swung back to his father. "Did you say that to her? In the kitchen?"
"No. No, I — Dominic, I have barely been alone with her in — "
"Answer him!" The shout was so sudden that Evelyn flinched, and Franklin's hands came up again of their own accord, and Alana, against the wall, buried her face in the crook of her arm so that no one could see her expression — which was just as well, because her expression in that second was not terror. It was arithmetic. She was listening to the exchange the way a safecracker listens to a lock: counting the clicks. Every sentence Franklin began and Dominic cut across was a click. Every question Dominic asked her husband's father instead of her was a click. She had stopped screaming. She no longer needed to scream. The machine she had built out of silk and shouting had begun to run on its own fuel, and all she had to do now was feed it at the exact moments it sputtered — a phrase, a sob, a hand pressed to the scrape as if it had begun to burn again.
Franklin saw what she was doing. That was his private damnation in that hallway, and Evelyn, watching his face from the stairs, saw him see it. He understood — completely, and a moment too late — that he was not in an argument. He was in a production. Every protest he made would be staged, lit and framed by the woman at the wall: his calm was coldness; his bewilderment was acting; his denials were, in advance, the very denials she had predicted he would make, which made them proof. He tried the second thing then, the thing he had been holding back since Dominic came through the door — the thing that had actually brought them all into this hallway — because a man drowning reaches for the heaviest thing he owns and calls it a raft.
"Dominic. There is something you don't know." His voice went lower, faster, trying to get under the noise the way you slide a letter under a door. "Something about the founda— something about money, son, about the foundation, and she knows it, that is what tonight was — ask her. Ask her what I called her into this hall to say. Ask her about the forms, Dominic — "
"Forms?" Dominic stared. "She's standing there torn and shaking and you're talking about forms?"
"Because the forms are the — "
"He's doing it!" From the wall, high and breaking: "He's doing it right now, don't you see — he's making it about business, he'll bury it in business, he'll talk until it's all paper — that's what he does, you told me that, you told me he can talk any room around — "
Dominic swung on his mother. It was the turn of a man who has discovered that the contagion might be everywhere, that the whole house might have been in on the secret of his own blindness. "Did you know? Did you know she'd been afraid — did she tell you, did anyone in this house know except me?"
"Dominic, I knew nothing." Evelyn's voice shook for the first time. "I came down those stairs to screaming. I don't know what has happened in this hall. I don't — "
"She lived here two years. She ate at our table. If she was afraid for weeks, somebody—"
"Then ask me why she was afraid to tell you!" It burst out of Evelyn with a force that surprised even her — the matriarch's voice, the one that had ended board dinners and church-committee mutinies — and it stopped her son for exactly one breath. "A woman who is afraid does not announce it, Dominic Kingsley. That is the nature of the thing. Do not stand in my hall and do arithmetic with it." She was breathing hard, one hand pressed flat to her own breastbone as if holding something in. "Something has happened here. Somebody in this hallway is lying, and I have been in this family long enough to know that the person shouting is not automatically—"
"Mother." Dominic's voice dropped, and the drop was worse than the shouting. "Look at her shoulder. Just look at it. Then tell me about shouting."