THE WOMAN WHO RAN TO THE RIDGE VULTURES: A MOTHER’S SECRET, A SON’S LIES AND THE CLUBHOUSE THAT BECAME HER HOME

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She wore the navy dress with the small white collar, the one she wore to church, and carried her purse on her forearm like the Queen of England in a newsreel. Inside the purse, Logan knew, there was no yellow envelope anymore. Grace Holloway had the files now — bank records, the nurse's notes, Cal's ledgers, the declaration — bound and tabbed and heavy enough to change the weather in a room. Eleanor's purse held a comb, a handkerchief, a small wallet, and a folded church bulletin. She had put the war in a lawyer's briefcase and come to court carrying only herself.

The gallery was full. Duke had shaved. Jax wore a shirt with buttons and kept touching the top one as though it might be a trick. Cal sat in the second row with his silver beard combed and a legal pad he did not need, because Cal Brennan had the whole two years of it in his head, down to the cents. Behind them sat men who had ridden escort to this building three times now and had learned to be quiet in it, which for Ridge Vultures was a kind of liturgy.

Daniel was already at the defense table when they came in. He looked smaller than he had at his mother's door in October. The county had given him back his own clothes for the hearing, but the gray jacket hung differently on him now, and he had the particular stillness of a man who has been told by his lawyer, in the hallway, in plain words, what the morning is going to do to him. He was out on release conditions. He had been out on release conditions the night he crossed the clubhouse lot in the dark and put his hand to his mother's window. Logan watched him look at Eleanor once, quickly, the way a man glances at a stove he has burned himself on, and then look away.

Judge Patricia Sloan took the bench at nine o'clock precisely, with the air of a woman who had read everything twice.

Ms. Holloway, she said. "Your remaining witness."

Your Honor, the petitioner recalls Dr. Alan Harlan.

Logan felt Eleanor's hand tighten, once, on the bench beside him — not fear, he thought. Bracing. Like a woman on a boat who has seen the wave and decided to meet it standing.

Harlan came through the gate in a brown suit and took the oath with his hand steady and his eyes not. He was sixty-three and looked ten years older than the last time Logan had seen him. Grace led him gently, the way you lead a man across ice you have already tested.

Dr. Harlan, how long has Eleanor Mercer been your patient?

Eleven years. Since her husband's bypass.

Your chart contains notes, over the past two years, describing cognitive decline. Confusion. Forgetfulness. Fearfulness, quote, 'of things that haven't happened.' Did you write those notes?

I did.

Did Mrs. Mercer, in your examining room, present as confused?

Harlan looked at Eleanor then, fully, for the first time, and Logan saw the man's face do something complicated and honest.

No, he said. "She did not. In eleven years, in my office, Eleanor Mercer has never once presented as impaired. She is lucid. She is oriented. She is precise to a degree that has, frankly, kept me on my toes. The reports of decline in that chart came to me by telephone. They came from her son. He reported missed appointments she had not missed. He reported episodes of confusion that had never occurred in my presence. I wrote his words into her medical record, more than once, without examining her, because he was her son and he sounded — " He stopped. "He sounded like care. That is the word I keep coming back to. He sounded like care, and I transcribed him."

Doctor, did you have occasion to re-read your full chart before signing the declaration you provided this court?

I read it three times. The last entry before all of this — three weeks before she left her home — records her blood pressure, one twenty-two over seventy-eight, and a remark of hers about my handwriting. She said my prescriptions looked like a cardiogram of a frightened man. A breath of something went through the gallery that was not quite laughter. "A woman in cognitive decline does not make that joke, Your Honor. A woman in cognitive decline does not track her own lab values and correct my nurse's arithmetic, which she also did, in April. Mrs. Mercer has never presented as impaired in my presence. The reports of decline were her son's, repeated by me. That failure is mine, and I have come here to put my name on it under oath, since I put my name on the other thing without thinking at all."

Daniel's lawyer rose for cross-examination with the careful energy of a man defusing something. "Dr. Harlan, you would agree a physician relies on family reports. That's standard practice."

It is standard to listen, Harlan said. "It is not standard to stop seeing the patient in the room. I stopped seeing her. I won't call that practice."

News in the same category

THE WOMAN WHO RAN TO THE RIDGE VULTURES: A MOTHER’S SECRET, A SON’S LIES AND THE CLUBHOUSE THAT BECAME HER HOME

30 Part