At the top of the first page she wrote, in her small exact hand, the sentence Ruth Callahan had written on the whiteboard on the first day of the Ashford program, and which had never, to Claire's knowledge, been printed anywhere official.
Win without breaking anyone.
She looked at it a moment. Then she turned the page and got on with the timetable.
The syllabus went to Voss's inbox at 21:40, because Claire believed that a man who was going to object should be given something specific to object to. She had expected the reply, if one came, in the morning. It came at 22:15, in person. She heard the knock, opened the office door, and found him standing in the corridor with the printed pages in his hand, already marked in pencil.
"You've read it," she said.
"I've read it." He held up the first page. "Forty minutes on day one. Forty minutes, Lieutenant, on how to fall down."
"On how to fall down and get up unhurt, yes."
"These are soldiers. They know how to fall."
"Your audit disagrees with you." She said it without triumph, as a fact of paperwork, and it landed the way paperwork lands — heavier than insult. "Eleven of the unit's training injuries in eighteen months happened in the first ten seconds of an exchange. Not in the hard part, Sergeant. In the falling part. People get hurt where the floor meets them wrong, and after that they get hurt because they're afraid of the floor and fight stiff. We fix the floor first. Everything else is built on it."
He turned pages. The pencil marks, she noticed, were not what she had expected. They were not deletions. Most of them were small checks, and beside the week-two section on redirections he had written, in a cramped hand, one word: works. He had not meant her to see that, she thought, and she was careful to look at his face instead.
"You taught this before," he said. It was not a question.
"I was taught this way."
"By whoever is in the file."
"By a master sergeant named Callahan," Claire said, "who is retired and lives twenty minutes from this post and has never once appeared in any file anyone has offered to show you." She let that sit. "The program had a name. It doesn't matter now. What matters is whether the method works, and the method is the timetable. If you want to argue, argue with the timetable — that's what it's for. In writing, please. I'll answer in writing, and the board can read both."
For a moment she thought he would laugh. Something moved at the corner of his mouth that was not quite anger and not quite respect, and he folded the pages once, precisely, along their existing crease.
"In writing," he repeated. "All right, Lieutenant. In writing." He went down the corridor at the unhurried pace of a man who has decided to win an argument properly, with documents, and Claire closed the door and stood in her small office feeling something she had not expected to feel on the first day of the hardest three weeks of her recent life.
Relief. Not because he agreed — he plainly did not. But a man who intended to sabotage the course would not have read the syllabus twice and marked it in pencil. A man who intended to sabotage it would have smiled in the meeting and waited for it to fall. Voss, whatever else he was, was preparing to fight her in the open, on the merits, in front of witnesses.
Four years ago she had watched a program die in closed rooms, by quiet decisions, with nobody willing to argue in the open at all.
She could work with an open fight. She sat down, opened the timetable again, and began preparing for week one.
The first morning of the pilot, the mats were full and the gallery was fuller. Word had gone around Fort Calder in the way word goes around any closed community — not through channels but along them, in the gaps between official sentences — and by 08:00 there were soldiers standing two deep along the wall of the training hall who had no earthly business being there at that hour, watching twenty-four students learn to stand still.