Elias glanced toward the stream.
"The tunnel?"
"Water has to go somewhere."
"That doesn't mean people can follow it."
"No. But it means we should look."
They moved along the stream toward the natural arch.
The water deepened as the passage narrowed. Beyond the arch, the current disappeared into a low tunnel barely four feet high.
Elias crouched.
Cold air moved through the opening.
He held the lantern near the water and relit it.
The flame flickered toward the tunnel.
"There's airflow."
Talia nodded.
"An opening somewhere ahead."
Behind them, Rusk's voice echoed through the cavern.
"I know you're in there!"
A gunshot cracked.
Stone fragments scattered near the entrance.
Elias swore.
"That settles it."
They entered the tunnel.
The water reached their knees almost immediately.
The ceiling was low enough that Elias had to bend forward, and the uneven floor made every step dangerous.
Talia moved ahead, one hand against the wall.
The current pushed steadily south.
After several minutes, the tunnel widened.
They emerged into a chamber filled with pale mineral formations.
A narrow ledge ran along the eastern wall, rising above the water.
Talia climbed onto it.
Elias followed.
Behind them, distant voices echoed through the passage.
Rusk's men had entered the cavern.
"We need to move faster," Elias said.
Talia stopped suddenly.
"What?"
She pointed toward the wall.
There, beneath a layer of mineral deposits, someone had carved another symbol.
An arrow.
Beside it were three letters.
S.M.
Elias stared.
"Samuel."
The carving pointed toward a narrow crack above the ledge.
They climbed through.
Beyond it lay a dry passage sloping upward.
The air grew warmer.
After another ten minutes, they reached a small opening hidden behind a curtain of hanging roots.
Sunlight streamed through.
Elias pushed the roots aside.
They emerged onto a rocky hillside overlooking the northern valley.
Below them, the canyon stretched toward the river.
Farther west, a line of dark green trees marked the edge of Crowe's estate.
Talia stepped into the sunlight.
"We made it."
Elias looked back toward the opening.
"Samuel knew this route."
"He wanted someone to find it."
"Maybe."
Elias unfolded the map.
The northern gate was marked near a ridge overlooking Crowe's land.
If Samuel's notes were accurate, someone had blocked the natural underground channel that once fed the San Pedro River.
The diverted water had been redirected toward Crowe's private reservoir.
Elias understood now why Crowe wanted his property.
The Mercer ranch stood directly above the old channel.
If Elias discovered the obstruction and restored the flow, Crowe could lose control of the valley's most valuable resource.
And if Elias sold the ranch, Crowe could bury the evidence forever.
Talia looked toward the distant estate.
"Your brother was killed because of this."
Elias's jaw tightened.
"I don't know that."
"But you believe it."
"Yes."
She studied him.
"What will you do?"
He looked at the map.
"Find proof."
"And then?"
"Take it to the authorities."
Talia's expression darkened.
"Will they listen?"
Elias thought of the sheriff, who owed Crowe money. The county judge, who attended Crowe's dinner parties. The land commissioner, whose brother worked for Crowe's cattle company.
"I don't know."
"Then we need more than proof."
"What do you suggest?"
"People."
He looked at her.
"People?"
"Others have lost water. Others have lost land. They may know things you do not."
Elias considered her words.
For years, he had fought Crowe alone.
He had refused every offer, every threat, every attempt to force him from his property.
But stubbornness had not saved the orchard.
And it had not brought Samuel home.
Perhaps Talia was right.
Perhaps the fight required more than one man.
They began descending the hillside.
By late afternoon, they reached the horses, which had remained tied near the canyon entrance.
Rusk and his men were nowhere in sight.
Elias suspected they were still searching the underground passages.
He almost hoped they would get lost.
They rode home quickly.
The sun was setting when the ranch came into view.
Something was wrong.
Elias noticed it before Talia did.
The barn doors stood open.
A fence rail lay broken beside the road.
And smoke rose from behind the house.
He urged Bishop into a gallop.
Talia followed.
They reached the yard to find the haystack burning.
Flames climbed into the evening sky.
The milk cow bellowed inside the barn.
Elias jumped from his horse.
"Get the animals!"
Talia ran toward the barn while Elias grabbed two buckets from beside the well.
The fire had already spread to the dry grass.
He threw water onto the flames, but the heat drove him backward.
Talia emerged from the barn leading Buttercup and the two mules.