Evelyn looked down at her battered house slippers. She then looked at the slightly ajar front
door behind her, and finally brought her piercing gaze back to the Sergeant.
"Sergeant, I am standing on my porch, drinking coffee in my pajamas. If this is how
burglaries are being committed in this day and age, I must say, criminals have become
remarkably relaxed in their methodology."
Near the second patrol car, Officer Reed shifted his weight uncomfortably. He recognized
the absurdity of the situation, but his commanding officer was already locked into a power
struggle.
Harlan did not appreciate Evelyn's dry wit. "Ma’am, I need to see your identification right
now."
"No."
The word was spoken softly, but it landed with the heavy, unmovable weight of a concrete
block.
Harlan’s face immediately flushed red. "Excuse me?"
"No," Evelyn repeated, enunciating clearly. "You may ask for my identification. And I am
declining to provide it."
"You are refusing to identify yourself during an active police investigation?" Harlan
challenged, his voice rising in volume.
"I am refusing to produce identification without reasonable, articulable suspicion that I
have committed, am committing, or am about to commit a crime. Terry v. Ohio, Sergeant.
Look it up."
CHAPTER 5: THE ESCALATION
Harlan stared at her. This was the exact moment he realized that the woman standing on
the porch did not sound like the panicked or submissive suspect he had expected to find.
She sounded like a textbook, and she sounded dangerous to his ego.
Evelyn continued, her voice echoing the practiced, measured cadence of a courtroom
lecture. "A vague, unsubstantiated call from a neighbor who simply dislikes the way I look
standing on my own property is not, by itself, probable cause. It does not give you the legal
authority to detain me, to search me, to enter my home, or to demand my identification
under threat of arrest."
Officer Reed’s eyes widened slightly. He had just graduated from the academy six months
ago. He knew exactly enough constitutional law to recognize that the woman in the slippers
was not guessing; she was citing binding legal precedent flawlessly.