Becker studied her face for a long moment. He had expected, Carla thought, either a refusal or a flash of temper, and she had given him neither. What he did next surprised her slightly: he nodded, and the nod was not a smirk.
"I am willing," he said. "If it works, Master Sergeant, I will be the first one to say so."
"And if it does not work," Carla said, "then we will all have learned something useful, including me."
She dismissed the class ten minutes early, and the students left in a buzz of talk that followed them out into the corridor. Becker stayed behind, rolling his shoulders the way he always did when he was thinking.
"Master Sergeant," he said, quieter now, "I want you to know this is not personal. I have been doing this for ten years. I have seen instructors come through here with ideas that sounded good in a classroom and fell apart on the mats. I do not want this class to be the one that finds out the hard way."
"I understand that, Sergeant," Carla said. "That is why I would rather show you than tell you."
He left, and she stood alone on the mats for a while, aware of what she had just agreed to. A demonstration was a risk in both directions. If she handled his kicks cleanly, the class would trust her method. If she did not, or if the demonstration turned into something uglier than she intended, she could lose the class in a single afternoon. She had agreed anyway, because she believed in the method, and because Becker's question had been honest. An honest question deserved an honest answer, and sometimes the only honest answer was to stand on the mats and let someone come at you.
That afternoon she went to Major Okafor's office and told him what had happened. She did not dress it up. She told him Becker's exact words, her exact answer, and the risk as she saw it. Okafor listened without interrupting, his hands folded on his desk, and when she finished he was quiet for a moment, looking past her toward the window.
"A demonstration is not a bad idea," he said at last. "But it will not be a fight, and it will not be a spectacle. If I approve this, it happens under my conditions, and my conditions are not negotiable."
He listed them, counting them off on his fingers. First, the demonstration would take place at the end of the following week, after both of them had time to prepare, and it would be closed to everyone except the class. Second, Becker's kicks would be thrown at controlled speed, not full power, and there would be no contact to the head. Third, either participant could stop the demonstration at any time, for any reason, without explanation. Fourth, a medic would be present, and Okafor himself would observe from the edge of the mats. Fifth, there would be no scoring, no winner, and no talk of winning afterward. The point was to show the class what controlled defense looked like, not to settle an argument.
"Do you accept those conditions, Master Sergeant?" he asked.
"I do, sir," Carla said. "And I would add one of my own. I set the pace. Sergeant Becker does not throw until I am ready, and we stop after four kicks. No more."
Okafor nodded. "Four kicks. Agreed. I will inform Sergeant Becker myself."
Word of the demonstration reached the instructors' office before the end of the day, and it reached it in the form Ray Dalton preferred: as a concern. He waited until the other instructors were in the room, two of them drinking coffee after their own classes, and then he raised it the way a man raises something he has been turning over in his mind.
"Have you heard about Reyes and Becker?" he said. "She has agreed to let him kick at her in front of the class next week."
Staff Sergeant Morales, a wiry woman who taught groundwork, looked up from her paperwork. "A demonstration? That is not unusual."
"It is unusual when the instructor has been here two weeks," Dalton said. "Calloway never needed to prove himself with a demonstration. His record proved it for him. Reyes has a record too, of course, but I notice nobody has seen it. And now she is putting herself on the mats with the strongest kicker in the class, in front of students who are already unsure about her. If he lands one, she loses the room. If she makes him look foolish, she poisons the course. Either way, it is a risk she did not need to take."