It was the first time in my life I had answered the Hollis family in ink instead of in person. In person, I had been a wife, and then an ex-wife, and both of those are roles in which a woman can be made to cry in a kitchen and have it called a conversation. In ink, I was a director with a file, and the file did not cry, and the file did not forget, and the file could be read aloud in rooms I would never enter by people who did not love me or hate me and were therefore the first fair audience I had ever had in that family's affairs. Diana had sent her threat traveling in an envelope marked concern because envelopes can be denied. I took it out of the envelope, copied it, stamped it, and filed it under its true name. Whatever happened to the loan now — and I did not yet know what I believed should happen to the loan — the threat would be sitting in the record, dated before the decision, where no one's memory could soften it. I went home that night and slept six hours, which was the best I had done since the restaurant, and I did not dream about Ryan at all. I dreamed about paper.
Twice in those nine days I considered recusing myself, and I want the consideration in this account too, because it was not weakness and it was not theater. The first time was the morning after the pitch, when I sat in my office with the door closed and drafted, in my head, the clean, defensible letter: the evaluating director has a personal history with the applicant's principal; in the interest of the process she withdraws. It wrote itself in ninety seconds, that letter. It was so clean. And it was, I understood by the second cup of coffee, a lie of exactly the kind I had sworn off — because recusal would not have purified the process, it would have edited it. It would have removed from the room the one evaluator who knew what Ryan Hollis's signature looked like when he was lying by omission, who knew the memo format was dead because she had once ironed shirts in the house where that paper lived. My knowledge was not contamination. It was evidence that had taken three years of marriage to gather, and the file deserved it, provided — and this was the whole of the discipline — that every use I made of it could be sourced to a document and not to a memory. Clara, when I put it to her, said the thing I have since had framed in my mind if not on my wall: "A conflict of interest is when your interest decides. Yours is a conflict of knowledge. The remedy for that is not absence. It is disclosure, and footnotes." So I disclosed — a second memorandum, shorter than the first, placed ahead of Diana's in the file, stating my prior marriage to the applicant's principal, my lack of any remaining financial interest in his company, and my undertaking that every adverse finding in my evaluation would cite its document. Let the file show its own seams. It was the opposite of the way I had lived for eight years, and it felt like breathing through the mouth after a long time under water.
The second time I considered it was at the site. I went on the eighth day, unannounced, in the late afternoon, because a file can tell you that two hundred and thirty people are unpaid but it cannot tell you what unpaid looks like at ground level, and I have never trusted a number I had not stood next to. The second tower ended at the thirty-second floor in a crown of rebar. The first tower's glass was in up to the fortieth floor and filmed with the particular dust of a building that is being neither built nor abandoned but waited with. The security guard at the gate — a Hollis employee, paid, I noted, which meant someone at that company still understood which payroll keeps a site from being stripped by morning — walked me as far as the fence and no farther, which was his job and I respected it. A man was coming down from the hoist as I stood there, in the day's last light, with a lunch bag in one hand and his helmet in the other, and he looked at my suit and my car and me with the flat appraisal of a man pricing a stranger. Delgado, the crane operator from Ryan's photographs, eleven years with the company. I did not give him my name. I told him I was with a firm reviewing the project's financing, which was true the way a half-built tower is a building. He asked me one question — whether the review meant the job would restart or the job would be sold — and I told him, honestly, that I did not know yet, and that anyone who told him otherwise was selling something. He nodded as if I had passed a test I could not see. "Eleven years," he said, "and the checks stopped in the spring, and Mr. Hollis still comes every Friday and walks the floors and tells us next month. Next month is a place he lives in. The rest of us just visit." He said it without self-pity, the way Miguel read subpoenas, and he went out through the gate to a bus stop, and I stood a while longer looking up at the two towers with the river going black behind them, and I understood that whatever the committee decided, it would not be decided about Ryan. It would be decided about whether next month was a place two hundred and thirty people could afford to keep visiting. I went back to the office and worked until the cleaning staff came, and I did not consider recusing myself again.