“Tie Me Up” Apache Woman Told the Rancher Who Bought Her to Free Her - The Lonely Man Didn’t Know…

Chapter 38

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Samuel continued.

“He could barely sign his name. When he needed to make a mark on a document, he used an X. The man who wrote this knew his name but never knew him.”

Whitcomb shrugged.

“Perhaps someone wrote it for him.”

“Perhaps. But there's another problem.”

Samuel pointed to the date.

“Henry Voss died eleven years ago. Tomas was killed six years ago.”

The courtroom fell silent.

Whitcomb's smile disappeared.

Judge Hargrove looked down at the paper again.

“Mr. Whitcomb, explain this.”

Whitcomb hesitated.

“I was given the statement by a reliable source.”

“Who?”

“I don't recall his name.”

“You presented a dead man's testimony without knowing who supplied it?”

“I was told it was authentic.”

Samuel looked toward Nathaniel Crowe.

“Ask him where it came from.”

Nathaniel stood.

“This is becoming absurd. Mr. Whitcomb is clearly mistaken. His involvement in these events has been exaggerated, and I see no reason to continue entertaining accusations from an unstable man.”

Whitcomb turned sharply.

“You told me to bring it.”

Nathaniel's expression changed.

Only for a fraction of a second, but enough.

The judge struck his gavel.

“Silence!”

Whitcomb's face flushed.

He had expected the document to protect him. Instead, it had exposed the weakness of his position.

Samuel stepped away from the table.

“I knew Henry Voss. He rode with me for a few months when I was younger. We were both working cattle trails west of here. He had a bad temper, a worse habit of drinking, and a remarkable ability to get himself into trouble. But he never worked for Crowe. He never met Tomas.”

Whitcomb stared at him.

“Then why did you leave that life?”

Samuel paused.

For years, he had avoided speaking about the man he had been before Clara, before the homestead, before the quiet life he had tried to build.

But the courtroom was full of people who had been asked to trust him.

He owed them the truth.

“I left because I learned what happens when a man stops asking whether the orders he's following are right. I once rode with a group of men who believed a landowner had no right to resist a powerful buyer. We drove families from their homes. We burned fences. We threatened people who couldn't defend themselves.”

He looked at Nita.

“I was young. I told myself I was only doing a job. It took me too long to understand that a man cannot separate his hands from the things they do.”

The room remained silent.

“I never met Tomas before he was dead. I never took money from Crowe. But I won't pretend I have always been an innocent man.”

Nita lowered her eyes.

Samuel continued.

“That is the difference between me and the people standing here. I can tell you what I did. They are still trying to hide what they did.”

Whitcomb looked toward the judge.

“This is a distraction.”

“No,” Samuel said. “It's the truth.”

Judge Hargrove placed the false statement on the desk.

“Mr. Whitcomb, you will remain available for further questioning. I will not admit this document as evidence unless its origin can be established.”

Whitcomb's confidence had vanished.

He looked toward the courtroom doors.

Samuel noticed.

So did Robert.

“Don't let him leave,” Robert whispered.

But before anyone could move, Whitcomb raised his injured hand.

“There's something else you should know.”

The judge frowned.

“Speak.”

Whitcomb took a breath.

“Tomas wasn't killed because of the survey alone. He had another document. Something that could have destroyed the railroad's entire claim to the river.”

Nita stepped forward.

“What document?”

“A transfer agreement.”

“What agreement?”

Whitcomb looked at Nathaniel.

“He had proof that the river rights had been transferred to the families along its banks long before the railroad company was formed. The company knew about it. The agreement had been filed under a different name, and the original was kept outside Red Mesa.”

Mateo leaned forward.

“Where?”

Whitcomb looked at Samuel.

“In the old territorial records office at Santa Fe.”

Nathaniel's face hardened.

“That's nonsense.”

Whitcomb ignored him.

“The original agreement was signed by the first landholders. It established that the river could not be privately owned by a single company. Tomas had discovered a copy. He was trying to find the original when he was killed.”

Nita's heart began to pound.

“Where is it now?”

“I don't know.”

“Who does?”

Whitcomb hesitated.

Then he looked toward Daniel Crowe.

“He does.”

Daniel rose so quickly his chair fell backward.

“You're lying.”

Whitcomb gave a humorless smile.

“Perhaps. But I think you know exactly which document I'm talking about.”

For the first time that morning, Daniel seemed genuinely frightened.

Nathaniel turned toward his son.

“Sit down.”

Daniel did not obey.

“You have no idea what you're talking about, Whitcomb.”

“Then tell them where the original is.”

Daniel's face darkened.

“Your Honor, this man is a criminal. He has been caught stealing company property and attempting to blackmail my father. His testimony should not be considered.”

Judge Hargrove leaned forward.

“Mr. Crowe, I have not asked you to comment.”

Daniel slowly sat down.

Nita looked at Whitcomb.

“Why are you telling us this now?”

His gaze shifted toward the courtroom windows.

“Because the people who paid me are no longer interested in protecting me.”

“Who paid you?”

“Crowe's company.”

“Which one?”

Whitcomb's jaw tightened.

News in the same category

“Tie Me Up” Apache Woman Told the Rancher Who Bought Her to Free Her - The Lonely Man Didn’t Know…

45 Part