Two Cops Throw Elderly Black Woman to the Ground — Until They Blocks the Entire Street

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The internal affairs file grew by the day, and it grew in the particular language of the institution. Use-of-force packet. Witness canvass: three neighbors, two statements taken, one — Mr. Abernathy — declined to be recorded but confirmed what the video showed. Civilian video: one file, authenticated, chain of custody logged. Medical: Mrs. Taylor had been treated at the station by EMS — chin laceration, cleaned and closed with adhesive strips; contusions to the left cheek and right knee; blood pressure elevated, monitored, released. The nurse's note, which the investigator read twice, said the patient had been "calm, cooperative, and dignified throughout," and had asked only whether her car was locked.

The solicitor's office called on Wednesday afternoon. The elected solicitor himself did not call — that would have been a signal, and everyone knew it — but his chief deputy did, and the conversation was short and careful and full of the words lawyers use when they are building a record: "evaluating," "reviewing all available evidence," "no decisions made." Reyes hung up and told his deputy chief what they both understood: when a prosecutor's office starts using the word "evaluating" about a police officer's conduct on camera, the question is no longer whether charges come, but which ones, and when, and how the department positions itself before they do.

The city council met in closed session on Wednesday night. Reyes was not invited — the city manager briefed them, and the city attorney gave the exposure assessment — but he heard about it afterward, the way chiefs hear about everything: the council wanted Lawson gone, the council wanted it fast, the council wanted to know why a man with three South Side complaints was still making traffic stops on the South Side. The city attorney's answer, as relayed to Reyes, was the honest one: the complaints had been closed as unfounded, the union contract made termination a process and not a decision, and the department had mistaken a clean two years for a changed man. The council did not find this satisfactory. No one in the room did.

On Thursday morning, Chief Reyes stood at his office window looking at Tom Hall Street and thought about Beatrice Taylor. He had not met her. He had watched her, four times now, on a screen — her hands at ten and two, her chin striking asphalt, her voice saying I served this country for twenty-eight years — and he understood, with the clarity that comes to chiefs in weeks like this, that the department was not the victim of the video. The video was the witness. The department was the defendant. And the direction of the investigation, which had been murky on Saturday and contested on Monday, was now clear to everyone in the building: it ended with Lawson's badge, and it ended with a reckoning for Morrison, and it ended — Reyes was honest enough to say it to his deputy chief, in the quiet of the office with the door closed — with the understanding that a seventy-four-year-old woman with a veteran's cap had done more for the integrity of this department in ninety seconds on a Saturday morning than the department had done for itself in years.

He picked up the phone and called the number the family attorney had left. It went to voicemail. He left a message, brief and formal: the department was conducting a full investigation; Officer Lawson had been placed on leave; the chief would welcome a conversation at the family's convenience. He did not say he was sorry. The lawyers had told him not to say he was sorry. He hung up and stood at the window a while longer, and the building held its breath around him.


The Town

Fort Mill learned what had happened the way small towns always learn anything: unevenly, and all at once.

The cruiser had been gone by the time the school buses would have passed, but Magnolia Drive was a street of people who watched things, and three of them had watched the whole of it. Dorothy Perkins had been on her own porch with her watering can when Beatrice went down. She had not screamed. She had stood with the can tilted in her hand until the water ran out onto the porch boards, and by then the cruiser was pulling away with Beatrice in the back seat, her hands still cuffed behind her.

By Sunday morning, the video had begun to move. The youngest of the three neighbors, a college student home for the weekend whose name will not matter here, had recorded thirty-nine seconds of it on a phone. He had shown it to his mother, who had shown it to her sister, who had shown it to her deacon, and by the time Pastor Allen's congregation filed into the sanctuary that Sunday, half the pews had seen a seventy-four-year-old woman thrown face-first onto pavement at Magnolia and Elm.

Pastor Allen did what pastors do when a congregation has seen something it cannot unsee. He did not preach about it from the pulpit. He simply said, before the closing hymn, that Beatrice Taylor had not been able to make it to the pantry on Saturday, that her shift had been covered by Mary Ellis and the Hendersons, and that anyone who wanted to pray for her was welcome to stay a moment after the service.

The pantry was a church-affiliated operation in a low brick building across town, and on Saturdays it ran on a roster Beatrice had kept, in practice, for eleven years. She had never missed a Saturday except when her knee was replaced two years before, and even then she had called Mary Ellis every Friday night to ask how the shelves looked. This Saturday she had not called. The box she had packed — fourteen cans of soup, eight cans of beans, a box of children's books, three blankets — sat in the trunk of her Honda in the police impound lot until Monday morning, when Raymond had it released. When Mary opened the trunk, the cans were still upright, still arranged the way Beatrice always arranged them, and Mary had to sit down on the bumper for a minute before she could lift them out.

It was Mary who said it first, on that Monday, to the volunteers unpacking donations: "Betty's shift is Saturday. Saturday is Betty's shift. We hold it."

So they held it. The following Saturday, while Beatrice sat in her living room with an ice pack on her jaw and her chin bandaged, the pantry ran with her roster, her clipboard, her way of doing things. The volunteers took her list and worked it like a service order. Nobody made a speech about it. At the end of the morning, Mary Ellis taped a note to the pantry door: Betty — 342 families served. The shelves are stocked. See you when you're ready.

Dorothy Perkins did not wait for anyone to organize anything. On Wednesday morning she told her husband she was going to sit on Beatrice's porch at six in the evening on Friday, and if anybody wanted to pray, they could come pray. She called six people. She did not call the newspaper. She did not call the television station, which by then had heard anyway and had sent a van to the end of Magnolia Drive on Tuesday, where it sat for two hours and then left when nobody on the street would talk to it.

News in the same category

Two Cops Throw Elderly Black Woman to the Ground — Until They Blocks the Entire Street

20 Part