What Sank in the Cornfield on Miller's Hollow Road

Chapter 24

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Then there were the duplicate invoices. Carol found them when she was reconciling the account for the annual meeting, and she showed us how they worked. Reilly Drainage would send an invoice for a smaller job, something plausible, like clearing a culvert or jetting a drain line, for three thousand dollars or four thousand dollars, and the HOA would pay it. Weeks later, a second invoice would arrive for the same job, the same description, the same amount, sometimes with a slightly different invoice number, and it would be paid again. Carol counted them one by one, and the duplicates added up to forty-one thousand five hundred dollars. She had circled each pair in red ink, and the red circles marched down the pages like a trail. Some of the duplicate payments went to the Reilly account, and some of them, Clara noticed at once, did not. Some of them were routed, through a second transfer Carol had flagged but could not explain, to an account described on the bank statement only as a marketing account, and when Clara traced the name on that account through the paperwork Carol had brought, it led to a brokerage marketing account that Vanessa Hartley controlled. Vanessa sold houses for a living, and the account was the one she used for advertising, open-house signs, and mailers with her own photograph on them. The drainage money of Meadowbrook homeowners, in other words, had been spent in part on selling other people's houses.

I sat there listening, and I felt something shift in my chest that was not satisfaction. I had expected Vanessa to be careless and arrogant, and she was, but this was not carelessness. This was a pattern, and it had been running while she was driving through my cornfield and telling me the lane was basically a road. The total, when Clara added the reserve transfer and the duplicate invoices and the other diverted assessments Carol had found in the same accounts, came to two hundred sixty-one thousand four hundred dollars across fourteen households' assessments that had been diverted or double-billed. I wrote the number down in my own logbook that night, because I did not trust myself to remember a number that large correctly, and Margaret read it over my shoulder and said nothing for a long time. Fourteen households. People who had paid their dues believing the money would keep their streets plowed and their pond maintained, and some of it had gone to a drainage project that did not exist and to advertising for a broker who was supposed to be serving them.

Carol told us she had raised the question once, at a board meeting, in the careful way a bookkeeper raises a question, asking whether anyone had photographs of the western drainage work for the annual report. Vanessa had answered before Rick could, saying the work was underground and therefore invisible, which was a clever answer and also, as Daniel would later point out to me with some heat, a dishonest one, because underground tile work leaves spoil piles and survey stakes and a paper trail of permits, and there were none. Rick had changed the subject. Carol had gone home and kept her duplicate copies, and she had waited. She said she waited because she did not want to accuse a neighbour without proof, and because she was afraid of what Vanessa would do to her reputation in a small subdivision where everyone knew everyone else's business. I understood that fear. I had lived with a version of it myself, standing at my own gate while a woman in a luxury SUV told me my farm lane was a road.

Clara explained to Carol what would happen next, and she explained it to me as well, in the same calm voice. Clara would not go to the HOA board with this, because the board included the person at the centre of it. She would take the printouts and the minutes to the Story County Sheriff's Office and to the county attorney, and she would let them decide whether it was a criminal matter. Carol asked if she would have to testify, and Clara said she might, but that her records spoke for themselves and that a bookkeeper's duplicate copies, kept at home and dated, were hard to argue with. Carol nodded, and she left the tote bag with Clara, and Margaret and I drove home in silence for the first ten miles, until Margaret said, very quietly, that she was glad Carol had found her courage, and I said I was too, and that I hoped it would be enough.

News in the same category

What Sank in the Cornfield on Miller's Hollow Road

45 Part