Chapter 1: The Empty Chair
Elias Grant had set five places at the table, and then, out of habit, he had set a sixth.
He stood looking at it for a long time — the white plate, the folded napkin, the glass catching the late light from the window — before he picked it up again and carried it back to the cupboard. Three years since Nora's funeral, and his hands still remembered a house that no longer existed.
“Just five, Dad,” he said to himself. “You can learn five.”
Outside, the Vermont wind moved through the bare maples. Inside, the roast was resting, the potatoes were keeping warm, and the whole house smelled of rosemary and wood smoke. It was the first Sunday dinner since spring that everyone had agreed to attend, and Elias had spent two days preparing for it as if preparation could control what happened once people sat down.
On the kitchen counter, beside the flour tin, a small tablet showed two pale images: the back porch, empty except for a stack of firewood, and the front hallway, empty except for the coat stand and the narrow rug Nora had bought in Santa Fe. The cameras had been Caleb's idea after a string of porch thefts in the neighborhood.
“You don't have to watch them, Dad,” his son had said while fitting the second one above the hallway door. “They just watch for you.”
At six o'clock exactly, Caleb's car came up the drive.
Elias saw his son first on the tablet — shoulders hunched against the cold, carrying a bottle of wine — and then Simone, Caleb's wife, stepping carefully over the gravel in heeled boots, smiling the bright, effortful smile she wore at all family occasions. In ten years of marriage, she had called Elias by his first name perhaps a dozen times. Usually she called him nothing at all, and spoke to the space beside him.
“You've done the roast,” she said, coming into the warmth, as if it were a surprising development. “Lovely.”
“Lovely means she hoped we'd order in,” Caleb said, and kissed his father's cheek, and for a moment the house felt almost easy.
June arrived twenty minutes later with her son Milo, who was nine and solemn and who went straight, as he always did, to the photograph of his grandmother on the hall table.
“Grandma Nora's ring,” he said, touching the frame. “The blue one. You said I could see it again.”
“So I did,” Elias said. “After dinner, young man. It's safe in the study.”
Simone, hanging up her coat, turned at that. “The sapphire? I thought Caleb said it was going to be valued. For the insurance.”
“For a lot of things,” Elias said mildly. “After dinner.”
Dinner began well. June talked about her new job at the library archive. Milo explained, at length, the rules of a card game no one else understood. Caleb poured wine and, for once, did not mention the offer a developer had made on the house, or the letter from the bank, or the fact that Elias had refused, three times now, to discuss selling the land behind the orchard.
Only Simone kept glancing toward the hallway, as people glance at a clock when they are waiting for permission to leave.
When Elias went to the kitchen to fetch the pie, he heard the soft click of the study door. He did not think much of it. The house was old; it made small, private noises all evening. He heard the water run in the downstairs bathroom. He heard June laughing at something Milo had said. He set the pie on a trivet and wiped his hands on a towel and thought, foolishly, that they might get through the whole night kindly.
Then Simone screamed.
It was not a startled sound. It was high and deliberate and it brought everyone out of their chairs. She was standing in the study doorway with Nora's velvet box in her hand, her face white under her makeup.
The box was open.
The box was empty.
“Don't,” she said, when Elias took a step toward her. “Don't come near me. It was here at Easter. I saw it here at Easter, and now it's gone, and you — ” She looked at Caleb, and her voice broke at exactly the right place. “This morning he told you himself he was going into that drawer. Ask him. Ask him what he did with it.”
“I said I was going to check the clasp,” Elias said. He could hear how thin his own voice sounded. “The clasp was loose last winter. I never opened — ”
“Dad.” Caleb was between them now, one hand raised, not quite toward either of them. “Dad, just — just tell us where it is.”
“I don't have it.”
“You were the only one who knew the drawer was unlocked,” Simone said.
That was when Elias remembered the tablet in the kitchen.
The hallway camera looked straight past the study door. It would have seen him. It would have seen all of them, entering and leaving, all evening. He went past Caleb, past June holding Milo against her side, and picked up the tablet with hands that were not quite steady.
“Then we don't have to argue,” he said. “We can look.”
Simone said nothing.