I watched him write in his small notebook, and I watched what he wrote, as best I could from where I stood. He wrote at length about the stop sign and the tint and the smell he claimed to have detected, and he wrote about the sobriety tests in general terms, but I did not see him write any number for the breath test, and I did not see him enter a result in the space where a breath reading would ordinarily be recorded. He closed the notebook, put it in his pocket, and turned back to me as though the matter were settled. It was not settled in my mind. I knew, with the certainty of a person who has not had a drink in days and who has just blown into a device that should have registered nothing, that the reading had been 0.00, and I knew, from watching him, that he had chosen not to write that number down. That omission stayed with me, sharp and clear, even as the rest of the afternoon grew more confusing. It was a small detail, a blank space where a number should have been, but it felt significant, because a complete and honest record would have included it, and this record, as far as I could see, did not. I did not accuse him in that moment, because I did not yet know how far this would go, and because I was still trying, against mounting evidence to the contrary, to believe that this was a misunderstanding that could be corrected with patience and clear communication.
I tried once more to ask, calmly, why I was being detained if the breath test had shown no alcohol, and why I could not simply be allowed to continue to Chattanooga, where I had a commitment the following morning that mattered to a great many people. I explained, without pleading and without boasting, that I was a senior officer travelling to speak at a memorial dedication, that I had a hotel reservation, that my uniform and my speech notes were in the vehicle, and that I had done nothing to warrant being held on the side of the road. Sheriff Merritt listened, or appeared to listen, with his arms crossed and his jaw set, and when I finished, he said that I had been argumentative, that I had questioned his authority repeatedly, and that he was placing me under arrest for obstruction. The word landed heavily, because it did not match anything I had done. I had answered every question. I had complied with every test. I had stepped out of my vehicle when asked. I had spoken respectfully throughout, even when I was frightened and confused. I had asked questions, yes, but asking a calm, respectful question about why a person is being detained is not obstruction, and I knew it, and I believed he knew it too. I said so, once, clearly, and he told me to turn around and put my hands behind my back.
I turned around slowly, because I did not want to give anyone any reason to claim I had resisted, and I placed my hands behind my back, palms facing outward, the way I had seen people do it in training films and on the news, though I had never imagined I would be doing it myself on a rural road in Tennessee on a Friday afternoon. The younger deputy, Deputy Jason Pierce, thirty-eight years old, stepped forward and took my wrists in his hands. He was not rough in the way he first touched me, but when he closed the handcuffs, he closed them tightly, far tighter than they needed to be to hold my wrists securely. I felt the metal bite immediately, a sharp, constricting pressure around both wrists, and I winced before I could stop myself. I told him, quietly, that the cuffs were too tight and that they were hurting me, and I asked him if he could loosen them just enough that they would still be secure but would not cut into my skin. He did not loosen them. He checked them, or appeared to check them, by tugging once on the chain, and he said they were fine, that they were standard, and that I would be all right. Sheriff Merritt, who was standing nearby, said nothing about the cuffs, and when I looked at him, he was already turning back toward my vehicle, as though the matter of my comfort were no longer his concern.