When an Arrogant Sheriff Handcuffs a Solitary Woman for Driving Forty-Four in a Forty-Five, He Has No Idea Her Single Phone Call Reaches the Highest Command Post in America

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Inside the sheriff's office, the deputies split, not loudly, and not all at once, but in the small choices they made when they were interviewed alone. Some closed ranks. They said the stops had been lawful, that the limit was posted, that drivers were responsible for reading signs, that the bonds were set by the court and not by the sheriff, and that Oak Haven was a small place trying to keep its roads safe with limited resources. They said Sarah Hayes had been argumentative, that she had not complied promptly, that the three charges were standard when a driver did not follow instructions. They said it in the same words, as if they had rehearsed it, and the investigators noted the sameness without commenting on it. They said they had done their jobs, and they believed it, or they had decided to believe it for the length of the interview, and they left the room and went back to their shifts and did not talk about it again in the office. The closing of ranks was not dramatic. It was a door shutting quietly, and then staying shut.

Others told the truth quietly, in rooms where no other deputy was present, in voices that stayed low even when the door was closed. One deputy said the sign at the county line was hard to see in the late afternoon, and that he had said so to Boyd more than once, and that nothing had changed. Another said the deputies had been told, not in writing but in the way things are told in small offices, to watch the stretch just inside the line, because that was where the stops were, and where the money was. Another said the three charges had been used for years as a package, not because every driver had committed all three offenses, but because the package made it harder for a driver to fight, and easier for the Monday docket to move quickly. Another, the youngest, said he had stopped a driver the week before Sarah Hayes was stopped, a driver who had wept and pleaded for a warning, and he had given the warning, and Boyd had asked him later why he had not written the citation, and he had not given a warning since. He said this without anger, as if he were reporting a fact about the weather, and the investigator wrote it down and asked him to repeat it, and he did, in the same words. None of these deputies asked to be named in any report. None of them wanted to be seen as disloyal. They simply told what they had seen, and then they went back to work, and they did not tell each other what they had said.

Sarah Hayes herself stayed mostly offstage while all of this happened, and that was by choice and by temperament. She was interviewed once, factually, in a room with a table and a recorder, and she answered the questions that were asked. She stated her name, her length of service, 26 years of federal service with an operational command background, and the facts of the stop as she remembered them. She had been driving a rented silver Chevrolet Malibu on State Route 89 in Virginia. She had been traveling at 44 miles per hour in a 45-mile-per-hour zone. She had been stopped just inside the county line. She had been cuffed by Sheriff Boyd Cleary. She had been charged with resisting arrest, disorderly conduct, and failure to comply. She had been given a Monday morning date before Judge Vance. She had made a single phone call, as was her right, and that call had reached the national command authority, and after that call the process that was now unfolding had begun. She did not elaborate on the call. She did not name anyone. She did not describe the conversation. She answered what was asked, and when the interviewer asked if she had anything to add, she said no. The interview lasted less than an hour. The transcript, when it was filed, was short, and it was consistent with the radar log, and with the dash recording, and with the booking paperwork, in every material detail.

News in the same category

When an Arrogant Sheriff Handcuffs a Solitary Woman for Driving Forty-Four in a Forty-Five, He Has No Idea Her Single Phone Call Reaches the Highest Command Post in America

45 Part