Marcus was already out of the garage, Mia riding on his shoulders like a tiny emperor, Jordan trailing with his basketball. Karen took in all of us in one sweeping glance β quick and complete, the way I watch people scan a trauma bay, because how someone looks at a room tells you what they're afraid of. She scanned us the way a surveyor scans a lot: not looking for the beauty, looking for the lines. I clocked it and dismissed it in the same breath. That is the sentence I would revise, if I could.
She was warm, though. Overly warm, I told Marcus that night, and he laughed β "You mean like, friendly?" β gently, the way he always does. Marcus has a theory that my job has made me suspicious of everyone, and he is not entirely wrong. But I liked her anyway, that first night. She was funny about the movers.
The casseroles started the next week. Chicken and wild rice. Then a baked ziti. Then something with sweet potatoes and marshmallows that Mia declared "the best thing I ever ate," which is a sentence Mia deploys against everything from ice cream to the air. The dishes had to be returned washed, which meant crossing the street, which meant going inside β which, I see now, was the point. She was building a reason to cross the street. A reason for me to cross it back.
I went inside maybe three times. The house was immaculate in a way that made ours feel like a frat house. No toys. No mail stacked on a counter. A house that no one is really living in stays clean. I filed that thought away under "none of my business."
Richard I met at the same time, standing by the truck with a clipboard. Firm handshake, two pumps, a joke about the HOA fees being worth it for the street trees. Smooth in a way that read, at first, as bland. Corporate pleasant. He and Marcus discovered a shared language β development, permitting, soil reports β and Marcus came inside that night glowing. "It's nice," he said. "A neighbor who gets what I do." The Northside job had been eating his evenings for months, and he was starved for someone to talk to about it who wasn't me. I was happy for him. I am still angry at myself for being happy for him.
The questions started small. Karen and I were on my front porch one afternoon β she had brought brownies, Mia had been sent to the backyard with a firm "inside voices or outside voices, your choice" β and Karen asked what Marcus was working on, the way you ask about the weather. I said he was a structural engineer, which was true and told her nothing. She laughed and said, "But what's the big one? The one that's keeping him out so late? My husband did that, back when we lived in Richmond β those late nights." And I told her. I told her it was a hospital. I told her it was the biggest project of his career. I even told her the timeline was tight, because I was flattered that someone was asking about Marcus's work like it was interesting, the way it actually is interesting when he explains it. I told her these things on my own porch, drinking lemonade, and she listened with her head tilted, and I felt so understood. That is the sentence that haunts me now: I felt so understood.
She asked if Marcus ever worked from home. She asked whether he kept his files at the office or on a laptop. She asked it the way she asked everything β lightly, with a laugh behind it, as if she were teasing herself for being nosy. "I'm such a snoop," she said once, "I should have been a spy." And I laughed. God, I laughed. I said, "Aren't we all," and refilled her glass, and told her about the hospital's foundation schedule like I was reading her a bedtime story.
The office visit. That is the part I have to write down carefully, because my memory wants to soften it. It was a Thursday. I had come home between shifts β I'd worked a night, gotten off at seven, gone back for a four-hour overlap because we were short β and I let myself in the front door at two in the afternoon, and I heard voices from Marcus's office. Not Marcus's voice. A woman's.
I stood in the hallway with my keys still in my hand. The door was half open. Karen was standing at Marcus's desk, and I mean standing at it, not beside it β her hip was against the drawer unit, and she was holding a framed photo of Marcus's graduating class from his master's program, and she was smiling at it like it was hers. On his desk, atop the Northside blueprints, lay a manila folder I had never seen β Meridian letterhead, a tab in Marcus's handwriting, something about testimony.
"Vanessa!" Karen said, bright as a bell, and she did not jump. That is the detail. An innocent person jumps. A person with nothing to hide startles when they are found alone in a room that isn't theirs. Karen did not startle. She turned with that tilted-head smile and said, "I'm so sorry, the door was open, I let myself β Richard sent me over to ask Marcus about the fence line, and I got distracted by the genius corner." She gestured at the photo. "Is this him? He looks about twelve."
"The fence line?" I said.
"Between our properties. Richard's worried about the oak." She was already moving past me, smooth, talking about the oak's root system the whole way to the front door. Marcus wasn't home. Richard hadn't sent her to ask Marcus anything β Marcus was in a meeting across town, which Karen would have known. She always seemed to know where Marcus was, the way she always seemed to know when I'd be home from a shift. "Tell Marcus I said hi," she called from her side of the street, and waved, and I stood in my doorway holding that manila folder in my mind like a hot coal.
I checked the folder when I went back inside. It was Marcus's β his handwriting, his tabs, his testimony outline. I told myself she hadn't touched it, that I was being ridiculous. I told Marcus that night, lightly, like a funny story. "She's probably bored, babe," he said, and went back to his drawings. It was nothing. I made it nothing. I was tired. I had worked a double. But that night I dreamed about the folder β the tabs, the handwriting, a woman's hip against Marcus's desk β and woke with my heart hammering like a code alarm, and told myself it was the shift work. I told myself a lot of things, those three weeks.
There were other things. Small, wrong details, accumulating like plaque. The colonial's blinds were always closed, even on beautiful days. A house with nothing to hide doesn't live behind closed blinds. Once, I saw Karen at her upstairs window at six in the morning, just standing there, looking at our house, and when she saw me see her, she lifted her coffee mug in a little salute, like it was a joke we were sharing. I waved back. I made it nothing.