Convenient was the word she used for it in private, from her first reading. She had seen the pattern before: a purge, a flood, a migration, a fire confined with miraculous precision to a single bank of cabinets. What that kind of official mind failed to appreciate was that modern evidence generated copies at every stage, in every hand, under rules written by people who had anticipated dishonesty. A county could purge its own manifests. It could not reach into Raleigh and purge the state's. It could not recall the triplicate forms pressed hard enough, on the day of transport, to carry an impression through two sheets of carbon. It could not retroactively steady the hand that had signed them.
Her method, over the months that followed, was deliberately unglamorous, and she would have been the first to say so. She built no theory in the first month. She built a chronology. On a wall of her office that faced away from the door, she pinned index cards in a line that lengthened by the week, each card carrying a date, a document, and the name of the person who had signed it. Beneath Delgado, the line began where all of its sorrows began, behind the old rail yard, with a drainage ditch and a recovery that produced, in a single operation, drugs, money, and a gun, the three classic temptations of an evidence room gathered together in one defendant's misfortune. Three kilograms of narcotics. Forty-two thousand dollars, bundled, the kind of cash that photographs well and counts easily and disappears, if it disappears, in round and deniable sums. One Kimber .45 pistol, a weapon of distinctive manufacture and traceable history, precisely the sort of firearm that could not lawfully be sold out of a locker without eventually surfacing somewhere it should not be.
Miguel Delgado himself occupied very little of the line at first, which troubled Naomi more, as the weeks passed, than any single missing gram. He had been represented by an overworked public defender carrying a caseload that Naomi, when she quietly obtained the figures, read twice in disbelief. He had taken a plea. Three years. There had been no suppression hearing that tested the seizure, no evidentiary hearing that tested the weight, no trial at which the state would have been required to produce, in open court, the full three kilograms its own officers claimed to have taken from behind the rail yard. A plea had closed the case the way a lid closes a box, neatly and without an audience, and with the case closed the evidence became eligible for the quiet administrative afterlife in which things no one is any longer obliged to produce can be disposed of, on paper, at leisure. Naomi pinned a card for the plea in red, the only red card on the wall. She did not yet know whether Delgado had been guilty of everything charged, or of half of it, or merely of being the man standing nearest when the ditch was searched. What she knew, and wrote on the card in block letters, was that no one with adequate time and resources had ever stood up on his behalf and asked the county to show its work. A defendant with a private attorney would have had the weights audited as a matter of course. A defendant with a public defender signing pleas between arraignments could be processed, convicted, and forgotten while the arithmetic of his own seizure went entirely unexamined.
From the plea, the chronology ran forward into disposal, and it was there, in the documents of disposal, that Naomi's legal pad began to fill with the marginal notations that would eventually harden into findings. The narcotics in State v. Delgado had, according to Blackwood County, been incinerated under Work Order 402. She obtained the work order, the furnace logs, and, because she was Naomi Carter and did not ask for the document she needed when she could also ask for the ten documents that surrounded it, the municipal incineration standards against which any lawful burn in the county's furnace had to be measured. The comparison took her less than an afternoon and left her sitting for a long time afterward with her pen uncapped, reading the same two pages in alternation. The temperature readouts recorded in the furnace logs for the burn under Work Order 402 were inconsistent with those standards. Not marginally inconsistent. Not inconsistent in the manner of an aging furnace running cool on a winter morning. Inconsistent in pattern and in plateau, in the sustained temperatures required to destroy what the manifest claimed had been destroyed, in the duration at those temperatures, in the elementary physics of reducing a stated quantity of material to ash. Material had been logged as incinerated in a furnace that, by its own recorded figures on the day in question, had not performed the work attributed to it, or had not performed it for the quantity stated, or had not performed it at all. She wrote the three alternatives on her pad, because precision at that stage required keeping them separate, and then she underlined a fourth line she had not intended to write: someone had needed the logs to say destroyed, whether or not anything was.