The findings were these. Over the three years of the period, at six of the group's fourteen hotels, blocks of rooms totaling between forty and sixty rooms per property per night had been sold to Beacon Corporate Retreats LLC, a related-party entity controlled by a longtime associate of the founder, which had never occupied them. The payments for those rooms had been funded, in substance, by the group itself, through fees for retreat services and client development paid out of the group's marketing fund in amounts calibrated to the block billings. The revenue so recorded — fabricated room revenue, the report called it, in the flat vocabulary it had chosen and held to — amounted to approximately nineteen million dollars per year. Reported weekday occupancy at the flagship had averaged eighty-two percent during the period. Actual weekday occupancy at the flagship, reconstructed from the key system, housekeeping, engineering, and water records, had averaged seventy-one percent. The group's lenders had been furnished the reported figures in covenant compliance certificates throughout the period. The figures had been furnished, likewise, to Marek Capital in the data room, and formed part of the basis of the agreed price of three point one billion dollars. The report identified the standing instruction to front-office management, the false managerial log entry of November twenty-first, and the release of a prepaid guest's room under that instruction's operation, as operational consequences of the scheme at the level of the guest, and it appended, as its final exhibit, a desk agent's incident entry, written on the night, which it characterized — in the report's sole departure from its own flatness — as accurate in every particular the examiners had been able to test.
Victoria Lockhart read the summary at her desk, and then she read the exhibits respecting the marketing fund, and then she telephoned Isaac and said a sentence she had been saving, in the way of lawyers, for the hour it became usable: "We may now write the second letter."
The second letter was shorter than the report and longer than the first letter and, like the first, it contained no word that the contract had not supplied. It advised the Tamarack Hospitality Group that the definitive agreement was terminated by Marek Capital pursuant to its terms, the representations respecting the company's accounts and occupancy having failed in material respects as established by the independent examination commissioned by the company's own board; that Marek Capital accordingly owed no obligation to close; that the breakup fee claimed by the company's letter of November was not payable, the fee by its terms running in favor of the company only upon a buyer failure unconnected with a failure of the company's representations, and being, in the circumstances established, a claim the company was invited to withdraw; and that Marek Capital reserved all rights, including in respect of its costs. It was delivered, like the first, by courier, to the founder's office and to the chair of the board, before nine o'clock in the morning. Rosemary Satterfield, receiving her copy at Brookline, telephoned Victoria before ten — the first direct contact between the two companies' principals since November that did not pass through paper — and said: "Ms. Lockhart. The board has read the same report you have. The company's claim to the fee is withdrawn, as of this morning's meeting, and the minutes will show that the independent directors required no persuasion beyond the exhibits. I did not want your client to learn that from a filing." Victoria thanked her, and asked after nothing, and Rosemary, after a pause, said the thing that would be quoted between the two firms for years, in the way of a password: "We found our names were not in our own register, Ms. Lockhart. We are attending to it." And Victoria said, "We know something of registers, Mrs. Satterfield. My client keeps his in a gray folder. Good morning."