A Police Chief Humiliated an Elderly Black Man—Then Learned Why His Own Department Had Been Watching Him

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

“Nice ride.”

“Thank you.”

“Expensive for somebody just visiting family.”

“It has served me well.”

“Where's your family live?”

“My brother lived on Juniper Street.”

His eyes narrowed.

“Lived?”

“He passed away.”

“Name?”

“Samuel Brooks.”

The change was immediate.

Mercer stopped looking at my clothes.

He looked directly into my face.

“Samuel Brooks was your brother?”

“Yes.”

For a moment, he said nothing.

Then he walked toward the back of my car and spoke quietly into his radio.

I couldn't hear every word.

But I heard my brother's name.

And I heard him say, “Get someone over here who knows the old files.”

That was when I began to suspect the stop had nothing to do with traffic.

The younger officer approached.

“Sir, I'm Officer Evan Price. Would you mind standing over here?”

He pointed toward the shade beside the hardware store.

I followed him.

“Officer Price,” I said quietly, “did your chief tell you why he stopped me?”

Evan looked toward Mercer.

“No, sir.”

“Did you observe a traffic violation?”

“No, sir.”

He seemed surprised by his own answer.

Then he added, “I just got called to assist.”

I nodded.

“Thank you for being straightforward.”

Mercer returned a moment later.

“Open your trunk.”

“What's the basis for searching my vehicle?”

His jaw tightened.

“You have something to hide?”

“No. But that's not a legal basis.”

He stepped closer.

“You people always think knowing a few legal words makes you smarter than everybody else.”

I felt the old familiar weariness settle over me.

Not fear exactly.

Something heavier.

I had heard versions of that sentence since I was a boy.

At the segregated swimming pool.

At the bank where my father was denied a loan.

At the courthouse where my mother had once been told to use a different entrance.

I had hoped that at seventy-one, I might have earned the right to drive through my hometown without hearing it again.

Instead, I was standing beside a hardware store while a police chief treated my refusal to surrender my rights as evidence of guilt.

“I won't consent to a search,” I said.

Mercer smiled.

“Then we'll do this the difficult way.”

He turned to Evan.

“Detain him.”

The younger officer didn't move.

“Chief, for what offense?”

Mercer stared at him.

“For obstructing an investigation.”

“What investigation?”

The question hung between them.

Mercer stepped closer to Evan.

“Are you questioning me in front of a civilian?”

“No, Chief. I just need the reason for the report.”

I noticed the word report.

Not arrest.

Not safety.

Report.

Mercer lowered his voice.

“Do what you're told.”

Evan looked at me.

There was embarrassment in his face, but also something more complicated.

Recognition, perhaps.

Not of me.

Of a situation he had seen before.

“Mr. Brooks,” he said, “please place your hands where I can see them.”

I complied.

I didn't want to make a bad situation worse.

Mercer removed my phone from my jacket pocket and set it on the hood of the car.

Then he reached inside the open driver's door.

“Chief,” I said, “I haven't consented to that.”

He ignored me.

He opened the glove compartment.

Inside were my vehicle documents, a pair of reading glasses, a packet of tissues, and the envelope Leah had given me.

Mercer saw the photograph.

He picked it up.

For the first time since the stop began, his confidence slipped.

“Where did you get this?”

“It belongs to my family.”

He turned the photograph over.

His eyes moved across Samuel's handwriting.

Then he folded the picture and slipped it into his shirt pocket.

“That is private property,” I said.

He closed the glove compartment.

“Evidence.”

“Of what?”

He didn't answer.

Instead, he looked at Evan.

“Take him in.”

Evan stood very still.

“Chief, we haven't established—”

“Now.”

A woman across the street had stopped beside a parked bicycle.

She was holding up her phone.

Mercer noticed her and pointed.

“Stop recording police business.”

She didn't lower it.

“I'm on a public sidewalk,” she said.

Mercer took a step toward her.

I spoke before I could stop myself.

“Chief, leave her alone. She hasn't interfered with anything.”

He turned back toward me.

There was a peculiar satisfaction in his expression.

As though I had finally given him the excuse he wanted.

“That's enough.”

He took my arm.

Evan moved forward, perhaps intending to help.

Mercer pulled me toward the patrol car.

I stumbled against the curb, caught myself on the door frame, and felt a sharp ache travel through my shoulder.

It was not the sort of pain that makes a person cry out.

It was the kind that reminds you how old your body has become.

“Careful,” Evan said.

Mercer ignored him.

The woman across the street was still recording.

I looked directly at her.

“Please keep that video,” I said.

Mercer pushed me into the back seat.

The door closed.

Through the window, I saw Evan looking down at the pavement.

And then I saw Mercer remove Samuel's photograph from his pocket and study it again.

He was not smiling anymore.

The ride to the police station took less than ten minutes.

I remembered the route. We passed the public library, the old Methodist church, and the elementary school where Samuel and I had learned to read from books with missing covers.

Bellweather looked peaceful through the patrol-car window.

People carried groceries. A woman watered flowers outside a bakery. Two boys rode bicycles along a row of brick houses.

Nothing about the town suggested that an elderly man could be detained without a clear explanation while the police chief carried away a photograph of his dead brother.

News in the same category

A Police Chief Humiliated an Elderly Black Man—Then Learned Why His Own Department Had Been Watching Him

30 Part