A Police Chief Humiliated an Elderly Black Man—Then Learned Why His Own Department Had Been Watching Him

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That fact alone did not establish criminal conduct. Municipal contracts could be awarded to companies associated with public officials under some circumstances, depending on the rules and disclosures involved.

But it raised obvious questions.

And it gave Mercer a financial connection to the property my brother had investigated.

Rebecca leaned back.

“Well,” she said quietly, “that's not a coincidence I like.”

Neither did I.

At eight the next morning, Claire arrived with a second attorney.

His name was Marcus Bell.

He was a local civil-rights lawyer from the neighboring county, a man in his early fifties who wore an inexpensive gray suit and carried a notebook filled with handwritten tabs.

“I know Bellweather,” he said after introductions. “Not as well as I'd like, but enough.”

“What can you tell us?” Claire asked.

Marcus sat down.

“Daniel Mercer became chief seven years ago. Before that, he was a detective. His father had influence over county development contracts, and Daniel built relationships with the same people.”

“Any formal complaints?”

“Several. Most were closed without findings.”

“Against Mercer personally?”

“Yes.”

“What were they about?”

Marcus opened his notebook.

“Improper vehicle searches. Questionable towing practices. Retaliation against people who challenged citations. There was also a complaint involving a former municipal employee who claimed records had been altered.”

My attention sharpened.

“Who filed that complaint?”

“Thomas Price.”

Rebecca and I exchanged a glance.

Marcus noticed.

“You know him?”

“His son is an officer,” I said. “Evan Price.”

Marcus nodded slowly.

“Then you may already know more than I do.”

“Tell us what happened.”

He turned a page.

“Price worked as a maintenance supervisor at Willow Court. When the buildings were condemned, the town accused him of failing to report serious maintenance problems. They also claimed equipment had disappeared under his supervision.”

“Was he charged?”

“No criminal conviction. There was an administrative investigation, and he lost his job. His pension dispute dragged on for years.”

“Did he challenge the allegations?”

“He did. He claimed the maintenance reports had been rewritten after the fact.”

“Was there evidence?”

“That's the problem. The original inspection records were supposedly destroyed in a basement flood.”

I looked at Samuel's note.

If they say the records burned, ask about the second set.

“Not a fire?” I asked.

Marcus frowned.

“What?”

“Were the records destroyed in a flood or a fire?”

“According to the official account, a flood. Why?”

I showed him the note.

He read it carefully.

“Your brother wrote this?”

“Yes.”

Marcus looked up.

“Then we need to establish exactly which records he was talking about.”

Claire was already writing.

“We'll request the condemnation file, the contract awards, the towing invoices, and the records-retention logs.”

“Also the relocation assistance records,” I said.

Marcus nodded.

“Especially those.”

Rebecca looked at us.

“Why?”

I turned toward her.

“Because if the town paid relocation assistance to people who never received it, the money went somewhere.”

“And if they kept charging the county for residents who had already moved,” Marcus added, “the same names might appear in multiple payment systems.”

I thought about Samuel's words.

The numbers never added up.

Perhaps he hadn't been speaking metaphorically.

Perhaps he had been comparing actual amounts.

Claire closed her notebook.

“Before we build a theory, let's find the records.”

It was sensible advice.

And it became even more important an hour later, when Olivia Grant sent me the original video of the traffic stop.

We watched it together on Claire's laptop.

The recording began after Mercer had already approached my car.

Olivia had been standing across the street, partly behind a parked delivery van. The angle wasn't perfect, but the audio was clear.

Mercer could be heard demanding that I open the trunk.

I could be heard refusing consent.

Then came the moment he opened the driver's door.

The camera shifted as Olivia stepped sideways.

Mercer leaned into the vehicle.

A few seconds later, he straightened with Samuel's photograph in his hand.

He examined it.

Then he turned away and made a telephone call.

Olivia moved closer to the curb.

Mercer's voice was faint but understandable.

“Brooks had the picture. We need to know what else he brought.”

There was a pause.

Then he said something none of us had expected.

“No. The old man doesn't know about the account.”

Claire stopped the video.

“Play that again.”

We listened three times.

The words were unmistakable.

The old man doesn't know about the account.

Rebecca looked at me.

“What account?”

“I don't know.”

Marcus leaned forward.

“Could be a bank account. Could be a municipal account. Could be something else.”

Claire nodded.

“We won't assume.”

She resumed the video.

Mercer ended the call, returned to the car, and ordered Evan to detain me.

The recording continued until I was placed in the patrol vehicle.

It showed that I had not threatened anyone, had not attempted to leave, and had not physically resisted.

It also showed Mercer taking the photograph.

When the video ended, Claire sat silently for several seconds.

Then she said, “This gives us a strong basis to challenge the official account of the stop.”

Marcus agreed.

“But the phone call is what worries me.”

Rebecca looked at him.

“Because he knew about the photograph?”

“Because he seemed to be reporting to somebody.”

I thought about the way Mercer had behaved after hearing Samuel's name.

He had been confident when he approached the car.

He had become agitated when he saw the photograph.

And he had made a call before deciding to detain me.

“Who would he have called?” Rebecca asked.

Marcus looked at the frozen image on the laptop.

“Someone who understood why that picture mattered.”

By noon, our attorneys had sent preservation letters to the police department, the town government, the towing contractor, and the county development authority.

News in the same category

A Police Chief Humiliated an Elderly Black Man—Then Learned Why His Own Department Had Been Watching Him

30 Part