She remembered being grabbed. She remembered the soldier behind the rock — Thad, eighteen, terrified, holding her still — and she remembered, now that she let herself remember, that after the gunfire moved on, after the shouting faded down the canyon, the soldier had let her go, and she had run, and she had run into worse. She remembered soldiers dragging people, not just shooting them. She remembered a wagon, or a line of prisoners, or both, because the memory would not hold still. She remembered faces turned toward her, mouths open, hands reaching, and she remembered running past them because stopping meant dying, and she had been sixteen and wanted to live, and she had lived, and the guilt of that had ridden her for thirteen years like a second shadow.
Who was taken alive? Who was dragged away rather than left? She turned the questions over and over, the way a person turns a stone over in her hand looking for a mark. She remembered an old man being left where he fell. She remembered a woman she did not know being carried, not dragged, by two soldiers, because she could not walk. She remembered a boy.
The boy came back to her slowly, the way dawn comes back to a canyon, first a line of light and then the whole shape of it. He was ten. He had been hiding with her, or near her, in the rocks, and when the soldiers found the hiding place they pulled him out, not shot him, pulled him out by the arm while he kicked and screamed, and she had screamed too, and someone — a soldier, or her mother, she could not tell — had pushed her back down and told her to stay, saving her by keeping her hidden while the boy was taken. She remembered his face turning back toward the rocks as they dragged him away, his mouth open, his eyes wide, and she remembered the sound he made, which was her name, or half her name, cut off by distance and smoke.
Her younger brother. Kai.
She had not said his name in thirteen years. She had not let herself say it, because saying it meant admitting that he might be dead, and she had not been able to carry that either. She had told herself, in the years after, that he was gone, that the canyon had taken everyone, that she was the last, because believing she was the last was simpler than believing he was alive somewhere, suffering somewhere, waiting somewhere for a sister who never came. The town called her the last Apache woman, and she had hated the label, and some part of her had also hidden inside it, because if she was the last, then there was no one left to fail.
But Whitlock had said someone else survived, and Vain had spent thirteen years making sure she never found out who. And the boy pulled from the rocks alive had been ten years old, and his name was Kai, and he was her brother, and he might be alive still, thirteen years later, a man of twenty-three, somewhere in Vain's keeping.
She listened to the house the way she had listened to it on the first night, and the sounds told her who was awake and who was not. Thad was outside her door again; she could tell by the faint creak of the porch boards now and then, a weight shifting, a boot set down and lifted, the patient rhythm of a man who had decided to stay awake. Whitlock breathed in the front room, deep and uneven, the sleep of a man who had ridden hard and would wake at the smallest sound. A horse stamped in the corral. The wind moved around the eaves and died. Somewhere far off, a coyote called once and was not answered.
She thought about the morning before the smoke again, and this time she let it stay longer, because the ordinary parts of it were the parts she had lost first. The smell of the cookfire in the morning air. Bread cooling on a flat stone. Her mother's hands in her hair, quick and sure, talking about the day ahead, about food and work and nothing important, because important things did not announce themselves on ordinary mornings. Her father mending something by the fire, his hands patient, his voice low. Kai near the water with the other children, his voice high and clear, teasing her about her braid, stealing a bite of bread when he thought no one was looking and grinning with his mouth full when she caught him. She had been sixteen and half dreaming the dreams of a girl who did not yet know the world could end before supper, and the memory of that ordinary morning hurt more than the memory of the smoke, because the smoke had only taken hours, while the ordinary morning had been a whole life, and it was gone.
She thought about the town's label, too: the last Apache woman. She had hated it, because it was a lie told by people who wanted her people finished. But some part of her had also hidden inside it, because if she was the last, then there was no one left to fail. Vain had understood that, and he had spent thirteen years keeping Kai hidden and letting distance do the rest, so that she would believe the lie and stop looking, which was exactly where Vain wanted it.