and stands of juniper, and the light came up slowly behind them, turning the rocks from gray to a pale gold. Nia had not been back to the canyon since the day the smoke filled it. Thirteen years had passed, and then a few weeks more, and she had carried the place inside her all that time as a wound and a memory and a question. Now she was going to stand in it again, not as a girl running, but as a woman who had survived, with her brother beside her and the man who had once pulled her behind a rock riding behind her, and she did not know what she would feel when the walls rose up around her. She only knew she had to go, and that going with the two of them was different from going alone.
The trail narrowed as it dropped toward the canyon mouth, and the air changed, growing cooler in the shade of the high walls. The sound of the horses' hooves changed too, from the soft thud of dust to the sharper ring of stone, and Nia felt her breath shorten. She remembered this sound. She remembered running over this same stone with smoke in her throat and her heart hammering so hard she thought it would break her ribs. She remembered her mother's voice calling her name, and then not calling it, and the way the world had gone strange and loud and then, for a long time, very quiet. She stopped her horse where the canyon opened wider, and for a moment she could not make herself go farther. Kai rode up beside her and said nothing, and after a moment he reached out and took her hand, his fingers warm and steady around hers, and that was enough. She nodded, and they rode on together, side by side, into the place where their family had ended and where, in some way she was only now beginning to understand, their family had also refused to end.
The canyon floor was scattered with stone, and in the middle of it, where the old camp had been, there was nothing left that a stranger would have recognized as a home. No tents, no fires, no voices. Only the walls, and the sky above them, and the wind moving through the dry grass. Nia dismounted and walked slowly across the ground, her boots finding their own way, and she stopped where she thought her family's fire had been. She knelt and pressed her palm flat against the earth, and the stone was cool and indifferent under her hand, and she felt grief come up in her not as a sharp thing but as a deep one, like water rising from far underground. Kai knelt beside her, and Thad stood a little apart, his hat in his hands, his head bowed, waiting to be told whether he belonged here or whether his presence was one more trespass. Nia looked up at him, and she saw the man he was now, not the boy of eighteen, and she saw the thirteen years of wondering in his face, and she knew that whatever she said next would matter more than anything she had said to him before.
She stood, and she began to gather stones. Small ones, flat ones, stones that fit in the hand, and she laid them in a careful ring where the fire had been, one stone for each person she could name, and then more stones for the ones whose names she had lost to smoke and time. Kai joined her, and then Thad, after a moment's hesitation, knelt and began to gather stones too, laying them gently beside hers, his big hands careful with the work, as if the stones themselves might break. They worked in silence for a long time, and the ring grew, and when it was done it sat on the canyon floor like a small, stubborn answer to everything that had tried to erase the people who had lived here. Nia stood back and looked at it, and her eyes were wet, and she did not wipe them, because there was no one here she needed to hide her grief from, and because grief, finally, was not the same as defeat.
Then Thad spoke. He had not planned words, and his voice came out rough and plain, the way it always did when something mattered too much to dress up. He said he was sorry. He said he had been eighteen and afraid and obedient, and that he had not fired, but that he had been there, and that being there and doing nothing more than pulling one girl behind a rock had never been enough to wash his hands clean in his own mind. He said he had spent thirteen years wondering about the girl, and that finding her had not eased his guilt but had given it a name and a face, and that he would carry what he had done and failed to do for the rest of his life, whether she forgave him or not. He said he was not asking her to forgive him, because forgiveness was not his to ask for, and because a man who had stood in a canyon while a family was destroyed did not get to set the terms of his own pardon. He stopped then, and stood with his hat crushed in his hands, and waited, and the canyon held its breath around them.
Nia listened to all of it, and she felt the thirteen years inside her shift and settle, like stones finding their place in a wall. She thought of the girl she had been, sixteen and running, and of the soldier who had grabbed her and pulled her behind a rock, and of how she had fought him because she thought he was trying to hurt her, and of how he had held her down and covered her with his own body while the shooting went on. She thought of the man he had become, who had