And underneath all of that was the frame, and what I had seen when I crouched beside it. I kept going back to it in my mind, the way you keep touching a sore tooth with your tongue. The coating scraped away, bright and fresh. The fittings wrong at two connection points, a bolt at an angle it should never have sat at, a joint loose and shifted. The fresh marks on the steel, scratches and gouges that did not match rust or age or weather. I was not an engineer. I was a homeowner who gardened. But I knew what neglect looked like, and I knew what time did to metal, and this was not that. Time wears things down evenly, gradually, the way rain wears a path in soil. This was different. This was specific. Someone had been at that frame, had worked on it, had left it weaker than they found it, and I did not yet know who or why, but I knew, standing there with water soaking into my shoes, that the tank had not simply failed.
While I waited for them, I stood on the patio with Laura and looked at the garden, and I tried to put the afternoon back together in order. The coffee. The call. The twelve minutes inside. The boom. And underneath all of it, a question I did not want to ask yet, because I was afraid of the answer: who would do this, and why would they do it here, in this exact spot, on this exact afternoon?
That morning had started the way most of my mornings started, which is to say it had started with nothing worth remembering. I was leaving for a short grocery run, and Laura was meeting me there later, and I had my keys in my hand and a short list in my head, milk and bread and whatever else we had run out of, when I saw Marlene Bishop beside the narrow side gate that led into our garden.
The gate was in the eastern fence, the fence that separated our garden from the brick house next door where Marlene lived alone. I had known her for four years, ever since we moved in, and in that time I had learned the shape of her: polite in the street, sharp when she felt overlooked, always watching the block the way some people watch television, as if it were happening for her benefit. She was standing just inside our side of the gate, or just at it, close enough that there was no honest confusion about where she was, and when she heard me she turned with an expression I could not quite read.
"Marlene?" I said. "What are you doing back there?"
She did not hesitate. She did not look embarrassed, the way a person looks embarrassed when they have wandered somewhere they should not be. She looked at me steadily and said, "Looking for my cat."
I stared at her. Marlene Bishop did not own a cat. Everyone on the block knew that. She had lived next door for years, and in all that time there had never been a cat in her house, never a bowl on her porch, never a tail in her window, never a single mention of a pet of any kind. It was not a small detail. It was the kind of fact a whole street absorbs without ever discussing it, the way you know which houses have dogs that bark at the mail carrier and which houses keep their curtains closed all day. Marlene had no cat. She had never had a cat. And there she was, standing at my garden gate in the morning, telling me she was looking for one.
"There's no cat here," I said. I was already late to meet Laura, and I did not have time for a conversation about an animal that did not exist, and part of me, the part that still wanted neighbors to be reasonable, assumed there had to be some simple explanation I was missing. Maybe she meant a stray. Maybe she had seen something move in the bushes and decided to investigate. I waited for her to say so.
"My mistake," she said.
That was all. She stepped back toward her own property, calm and unhurried, as if the whole exchange had been perfectly normal, as if a woman standing at her neighbor's garden gate looking for a pet she did not own was the most ordinary thing in the world. I watched her go, and I felt a small tug of unease that I dismissed almost immediately, because I was late and because the grocery store was waiting and because Marlene had always been a little strange around the edges and I had trained myself not to make a project out of it.