The meeting was held at the kitchen table, because Arthur had said, when Ruth proposed it, that a man's competence should be judged in his own kitchen, where the coffee was hot and the light was honest, and not in an office where the chairs were too straight and the air smelled of other people's paper. Ruth Bennett arrived first, with her folder and her plain, careful manner, and she set a clean sheet of paper on the table and a pen beside it, and she did not fuss with them, because fussing would have suggested that the paper mattered more than the man. Dr. Alan Pierce arrived next, carrying his bag, and he shook Arthur's hand the way he always did, firmly, without making a show of gentleness, which Arthur appreciated, because Arthur had never liked being handled as if he might break. Daniel Osei arrived with his own folder, thick and orderly, and he nodded to Maya, and to Bear, who stood in the doorway with his arms crossed, not because he was guarding anything, but because the kitchen was small and Bear was large, and there was nowhere else for him to stand that did not block the light.
Maya made coffee, and she set out cups, and she did not sit down at once, because she was used to serving, but Ruth looked at her and said, "Maya, sit. This is your table too," and Maya sat, and Arthur, watching her, thought that Ruth had a gift for saying the thing that made a room settle. Mrs. Clara Jensen had been asked to come, and she came, with a casserole dish covered in a tea towel, because Mrs. Jensen believed that no meeting, however serious, should begin without food in the house, and she set the dish on the counter and took a chair by the window, and said she would only listen, which was her way of saying she would tell the truth if she was asked, and she would not volunteer it otherwise.
Ruth began, plainly, without preamble, because preamble was another kind of fuss. "Arthur," she said, "we are here to make a record. Not because anyone doubts you, but because a record, made properly, stops doubt before it starts. I am going to ask you some questions. Answer them in your own words. There is no hurry."
Arthur nodded, and he wrapped his hands around his coffee mug, and the warmth steadied him, the way it always did, and he waited.
What is your name? Ruth asked.
Arthur Covington, he said.
Where do you live?
Fourteen Elm Street, he said. "I framed this house with my own hands in 1949. I raised my son here. I planted roses here with my wife. I live here now, by my choice."
Who was your wife?
Martha Covington, Arthur said, and his voice, which had been steady, softened a fraction, the way a voice does when it says a name it has loved for a lifetime. "She is gone. Her photograph is on my nightstand. Her roses were in the beds out front, and now there are marigolds, which were her favourite. I miss her. I do not confuse missing her with being lost."
Tell me about the war, Ruth said, gently.
Arthur told it, plainly, as he had told it at the diner, and at the table, and on the porch, many times now, without boasting and without hurry. Bastogne. Snow chest deep. The Jeep. The keys. The wiring. The cold. The men who would have frozen. Tank, who had asked about the cold, nodded from his chair, and Slim, who had asked about the wiring, listened as if he had never heard it, which was Slim's kindness. Arthur finished, and he sipped his coffee, and he looked at Ruth, and he waited for the next question, because he understood that this was not a test of memory, but a record of a man being himself, in his own house, in his own words.
Who takes care of you? Ruth asked.
Maya does, Arthur said. "She is a certified geriatric caregiver. She cooks Martha's recipes. She listens to my stories without interrupting. She holds my hand when the nightmares come. She filed the paperwork. My VA benefits and my pension cover her care. That is the arrangement, and it is a good one, and I chose it."
And who are these men? Ruth asked, glancing at Bear.
My friends, Arthur said. "Bear, Slim, Tank, and the others. They are my brothers. They brought me home. They did not pretend. They stayed."
Do you understand the papers your son brought to the diner? Ruth asked, and her voice was careful now, because this was the question that mattered most, and she wanted it asked properly.
I understand, Arthur said. "Full power of attorney. It would give Robert control of my money, my medical decisions, my visitors. It would let him sell this house. I did not sign it. I will not sign it. I understand it perfectly, and that is why I will not sign it."