Cynthia came alone, on a Thursday, in the late afternoon, when the light was soft and the marigolds were at their brightest and Arthur was on the porch with his coffee, watching Elm Street go about its business. She came on foot, without the black sedan, without the clipboard, without Robert, and she wore a coat that was not tailored, and shoes that were not designer, and her hair was pulled back in a way that made her look, for the first time since Arthur had known her, not like a woman arriving, but like a woman who was not sure she would be welcome. She stopped at the bottom of the steps, and she looked up at the porch, and at the fresh white paint, and at the swept boards, and at Arthur in his chair, and she did not come up at once, because she understood, perhaps for the first time, that a porch is a man's own ground, and that stepping onto it is a thing that should be asked, not assumed.
Arthur saw her, and he did not stand, because standing was hard, and because he did not need to stand to be heard, and he said, "Cynthia," in a voice that was neither warm nor cold, but plain, the way he said the names of people he knew. Maya, who was in the kitchen, came to the doorway, and she did not come out, and she did not go away, because she understood that this was Arthur's visit, and that her place was near enough to hear, and far enough to let him speak for himself. Bear was not there. Slim was not there. Tank was not there. The porch was Arthur's, and the afternoon was Arthur's, and the woman at the bottom of the steps was alone, as Arthur had so often been alone, and that, Arthur thought, was a symmetry he had not asked for and did not intend to enjoy.
May I come up? Cynthia asked, and her voice was smaller than Arthur had ever heard it, smaller than the honeyed poison of the diner, smaller than the shriek on the day of the sedan, smaller, even, than the voice she had used when she tugged Robert's sleeve and led him away. It was the voice of a woman who had run out of scripts, and Arthur, who had run out of scripts long ago and had found that plain words served him better, nodded, once, and said, "You may."
She came up the steps slowly, holding the railing, and she sat in the chair opposite Arthur, the chair Mrs. Jensen sometimes sat in, and she folded her hands in her lap, and she looked at the marigolds, and at the street, and at her own hands, and she did not look at Arthur at first, because looking at him would have meant seeing what she had tried not to see for a long time: that he was a man, and that he was old, and that he was not confused, and that he had built the house she had tried to sell, with his own hands, in 1949, and that he knew it, and that he remembered it, and that he would not forget it because she asked him to.
I came alone, she said, at last. "Robert does not know I am here."
Arthur nodded, and he waited, because waiting was a thing he had learned to do well, in the war, and in the diner, and on the porch, and he knew that silence, offered kindly, was often the only invitation a person needed to say the true thing.
I wanted to ask you something, Cynthia said, and her hands tightened in her lap, and her voice tightened with them. "Do you hate us?"
Arthur looked at her then, really looked at her, and he saw not the sharp laugh, and not the honeyed voice, and not the woman in the far booth, but a woman who was afraid, and who had been afraid for a long time, and who had mistaken fear for care, and care for control, and who was now sitting on a porch she had tried to empty, asking a question she had never asked before. He thought about Martha, and about the roses, and about the envelope, and about the listing, and about the van, and he thought about hatred, and what it would cost him to carry it, and what it had already cost Robert and Cynthia to carry theirs, and he answered her plainly, because plain answers were the only ones he trusted.
No, Arthur said. "I do not hate you. I do not hate Robert. I only will not sign."
Cynthia breathed out then, a breath she seemed to have been holding for months, and her shoulders dropped, and her hands loosened, and she looked at Arthur, and she said, "I thought you did. I thought, after everything, you must."
I have hated very little in my life, Arthur said. "I hated the cold in Bastogne. I hated the waiting. I did not hate men. I will not start now, at eighty-nine, in my own house, on my own porch, with the sun going down. Hatred is a young man's luxury, Cynthia. I cannot afford it, and I do not want it."