Priya thought, watching her, the most expensive sentence Lorraine Voss had ever pronounced, and she
pronounced it correctly.
The second item was shorter, and its shortness was its own verdict. To adopt, as an interim guideline
with immediate effect, the sentence from the 2019 summary pamphlet: that unapproved exterior lighting
was prohibited and subject to removal.
Priya moved against her own side's expectation and asked, before debate, that counsel's written opinion
— the third of Sofia's October requests, delivered that week and available at the table — be summarised by
the secretary. Sofia summarised it exactly: that a summary pamphlet could not amend a guideline; that an
interim guideline adopted in that form would conflict with paragraph (c) and paragraph (d) of the guideline
it purported to interpret, since it omitted notice, cure, hearing, and the safety exemption entire; that
adoption could not give it effect for any period before adoption; and that, in counsel's opinion, enforcement
taken in reliance on the pamphlet sentence in preference to the filed guideline had been enforcement
without authority under the association's own documents. Counsel's opinion also addressed the question
the board had asked about keys, and Sofia read that paragraph whole, because it had been requested in
October by a recorded vote and the membership was entitled to it in the room where the key had been
used: in counsel's opinion, no provision of the bylaws, the guidelines, or the management agreement
conferred on the president, as president, any authority to hold, sign out, or use a utility key in the
management company's custody; custody lay where the key policy placed it, with the custodian and the
licensed contractor named in it.
"I wrote that question in October hoping I was wrong about the answer," Sofia said, closing the opinion.
"I was not wrong."
Against that reading, the second item had almost no debate to sustain it. Its mover, the same member
from Alder Street, spoke with diminishing conviction about the need for a simple rule people could
understand, and was answered, gently, by Martin Hale from the table: that the guideline the secretary had
read at seven o'clock was four paragraphs, in plain English, and that the membership had understood it
perfectly well for an hour and a half; simplicity obtained by deleting a neighbour's hearing was not
simplicity but omission. The division, when it came, was not close enough to require a second count. For
adoption: nineteen. Against: one hundred and eighty-eight. Abstentions: seven. The pamphlet sentence was
not adopted. It remained what its own second page had always said it was — a summary, for convenience
— and the filed guideline, whole, was the rule of Juniper Terrace again, in the minutes, by a vote no one
could later describe as ambiguous.
The third item took longest, because it was the item with money in it, and money, unlike a guideline,
has to be followed figure by figure or it escapes out of the meeting and lives somewhere else.
Priya, as treasurer, presented the term sheet entire, as the October vote had required it to be produced.
She described the programme fairly first — she was scrupulous about that, and the LumenField
representative who had been invited and had chosen, wisely, not to attend would have recognised his own
proposal in her account: a community relighting programme, fixtures replaced lot by lot with a standard
shielded fitting, an association rebate on the contract price, a schedule of works. Then she turned to the
schedule that had not been in the February draft.
"In the draft sent by Mr. Halvorsen on the ninth of February," she said, "the consideration is the rebate,
and nothing else. I have that draft. In the copy returned from the president's email on the seventh of March,
with the message that the consulting arrangement was 'as we discussed, for the contract stage,' there is a
new schedule. Under it, for every lot converted under the programme, a referral fee of one hundred and
seventy-five dollars would be paid — not to this association, whose rebate is separate and smaller — but to
an entity named in the schedule: Voss Management Consulting LLC. At full conversion of two hundred
and fourteen lots, that fee totals thirty-seven thousand, four hundred and fifty dollars. The entity is, on the
public record the board has obtained, a limited liability company organised in 2019, with a mailbox
address on Fairview Avenue, whose annual reports lapsed after 2020. Its officer is Lorraine Voss. No
payment has ever been made under this schedule. I want that sentence in the minutes beside the figures, in
the same size of type: the programme was never approved, no contract was signed, and no money ever
moved. What the membership is being asked to judge is not a theft. It is an arrangement, inserted into a
contract the association was asked to approve, that would have paid the president who inserted it for every
neighbour's lot her enforcement converted — beginning, on the sequencing list, with the lots her
enforcement touched first."
She then read the sequencing list, because the board had agreed that the thirty-one households on it
were entitled to hear their own addresses in the room rather than discover them in a file. Thirty-one lots, in
the order of the May spreadsheet that had been supplied to LumenField from the president's office and