floor at a meeting whose notice had allowed it — and Sofia confirmed, from the notice and the bylaws
together, that the emergency notice for that night, drafted by the chair herself, had listed as its business all
matters arising from the year's enforcement, which counsel had advised, in the opinion already before the
meeting, was wide enough to carry a recall, though the narrower and cleaner course was the board's own
vote first. "The meeting is entitled to know," Martin said, "that it need not choose the heaviest instrument
to do a necessary thing. It is also entitled to choose it. Both statements are in the bylaws' spirit, and I will
put whichever motion is made."
Sofia Bennett made the first motion. She made it standing at the secretary's place, in her clerk's voice,
without a single adjective: that the board of the Juniper Terrace Community Association remove Lorraine
Voss from the office of president, effective at the adjournment of that meeting, the grounds to be recorded
as the enforcement of a guideline without its required procedure, the presentation to the membership of an
undisclosed financial interest in a contract proposed to the association, and the exercise of a custody over
association keys that no instrument conferred — each ground stated as it had been established that night,
on documents, in the meeting's own agreed record. Priya Nair seconded it, as a director. Martin Hale, as
vice president, put it to the board at the table, the membership watching, each director answering by name
as Sofia called the roll of the board. Hale: aye. Nair: aye. Bennett: aye. Osei: aye. Voss: no. Four to one.
The presidency ended by the vote the bylaws provided, counted aloud, in the open, by the people elected to
cast it.
Lorraine received it the way she had received the ratification count: she wrote the figures on her pad,
correctly, in her neat hand. Then Gerald Osei, who had seconded nothing all night except motions about
paper, said that a presidency removed for grounds that went to trust could not be the whole of the
membership's business, and he yielded the floor, by name, to the members who had told him beforehand
that they wished to be named if the moment came — because a recall moved by a crowd belongs to no
one, he said, and a recall moved by named neighbours, who will sign the minutes and answer for it on their
own street, belongs to the record.
Helen Brooks moved the recall of Lorraine Voss as a director of the association. Ed Salas seconded it.
The Tran family, by Mai Tran, spoke for it in four sentences about a camera that had looked at a wall for
thirty-eight minutes in June. A member from Lupine Street spoke against it — not in defence of the year,
she said, but against recall as a habit, and in favour of letting a defeated president serve out a diminished
term under a board that had learned to read — and the room heard her with the same attention it had given
the other side, because by then the meeting had acquired the character June had asked for at seven o'clock:
it was deciding on papers, and a neighbour's caution was a paper too. The division was taken twice without
being challenged the second time. For the recall: one hundred and fifty-two. Against: forty-nine.
Abstentions: thirteen. The seat was vacant from the adjournment.
Lorraine Voss stood, gathered her folder of the fall agenda, her pamphlet, and the July authorization —
and stopped, with the authorization in her hand, because Sofia, quietly, reminded the room, not her, that the
association's copy of that document was within the preservation request and would remain with the
secretary. Lorraine looked at the page for a moment. Then she laid it back on the table, squared it once
more to the edge with a care that the room, to its credit, did not mock, took up only her folder and her
pamphlet, and said the last thing she said as an officer of Juniper Terrace.
"The association will find its affairs in order," she said. "Every paper I ever kept is filed. I have never
been a woman who lost a document." She paused, and something that was almost honesty and almost
defiance crossed her face and settled as neither. "That, apparently, is the difficulty."
She walked out through the membership, not quickly, along the centre aisle, past the aisle seat where
June sat with the green folder, and June — who could not see her pass, and knew it by the room — did not
turn her head, did not speak, and did not let the moment become the thing she had forbidden at her own
kitchen table in August: a war on the street, with an audience. Lorraine Voss left her own meeting on foot,
through the pavilion doors, into a street lit exactly as it had been lit when she arrived, and the meeting
went on without her, which was the point of every vote it had taken.
Martin Hale took the chair as vice president and presiding officer, and the last business was done at
speed, because it had all been drafted, before the meeting, by people who had learned to draft. On Priya's
motion, the board as reconstituted — Hale, Nair, Bennett, Osei — was confirmed in its interim authority