Tessa thought for a long time before she answered. She thought about Ruth in the hospital bed, skin like parchment, fingers still warm, whispering, "Don't you dare quit that school. Promise me." She thought about the funeral, and the scholarship office calling, and the voicemail she had kept like a ghost. She thought about the promise she had made and broken in the same breath, and the six years of silence that had followed, and the way she had carried the broken promise like a stone in her pocket, touching it every day to remind herself of what she had lost.
I was angry, she said, honestly. "For a long time, I was so angry I couldn't pray. I was angry at the cancer, and at the hospital, and at Juilliard for going on without me, and at myself for not being able to do both things at once. But I was never angry at Mama. Mama didn't make me promise because she wanted me to suffer. She made me promise because she was dying, and she was afraid that the world would take the music, too, and she wanted me to fight for it. She didn't know — she couldn't have known — that the fight would look like staying home."
So what does 'don't quit' mean now? Nadia asked. "If it doesn't mean Juilliard, and it doesn't mean the recital, and it doesn't mean — what does it mean?"
Tessa looked at her sister, and at the keyboard in the corner, and at the window where the lights of Lenox Avenue burned steady and ordinary, and she felt something shift inside her, a door opening that had been stuck for six years.
I think it means don't quit on yourself, she said, slowly. "Not for Mama. Not for me. Not for anybody's story about you. I think Mama would say — I think she'd say, 'Baby, I cleaned their floors so you could play their stages, and I didn't mean the stages in the concert halls. I meant any stage where you get to be who you are.'"
Nadia was quiet for a moment. Then she said, very clearly, and very steadily, in the voice of a person who has finally found the true thing and intends to say it out loud, "Then take it back, Tess. Take the music back. Not for Mama. Not for me. For yourself. Because it's yours, and you never actually gave it away. You just — put it down for a while. And now you get to pick it up again."
Tessa sat in the lamplight with her sister's hand in hers, and the apartment was small, and the night was ordinary, and the words hung in the air between them like a chord resolving, and for the first time since the gala, she did not feel afraid of what came next. She felt ready. She felt, very quietly and completely, like herself.
The smear began on a Tuesday, with a small item on a gossip website, the kind of site that printed rumors in the morning and corrections in the afternoon, if it printed corrections at all. The headline said: GALA PIANO VIRAL STAR: STAGED? And the article, which Daniel Okafor read aloud to Tessa over the phone with a fury he was trying very hard to control, suggested — without quite saying, in the careful way of people who know exactly what they are doing — that the whole thing might have been arranged. A plant. A performance, rehearsed in advance, designed to embarrass a generous philanthropist. Anonymous sources, the article said. People familiar with the event. People who preferred not to be named.
Anonymous sources, Daniel said. "Which means one source, Tess, and I will bet you anything you like that his name is Holloway, and his lawyer wrote the check."
Tessa sat on the bed with the phone against her ear, and listened, and felt the old fear come back, cold and familiar, the fear she had lived with for six years: the fear that the world would decide she was a fraud, that the music was not really hers, that she had stolen a moment that belonged to someone else. She had survived Holloway's cruelty in public. She was not sure she could survive being called a liar in private, in print, in a hundred little cuts she could not answer because answering would only make it worse.
It got worse anyway. By Thursday there were three more items, each one a little bolder than the last. One questioned whether she had really attended Juilliard at all. One suggested that the video had been edited, that the sound had been dubbed, that no waitress could play Chopin like that without a trick. One, the cruelest, printed a photograph of the apartment building on Lenox Avenue, taken from across the street with a long lens, and described it, in loving detail, as the kind of place where a person might be persuaded to say anything for money.
Preston Vale's letter arrived the same day, in a heavy cream envelope, delivered by courier to the apartment door. Mrs. Alvarez brought it up, her face tight with worry, and stood in the doorway while Tessa opened it with hands that would not quite stop shaking. The letter was polite, and precise, and terrifying in the way only polite, precise letters can be. It reminded her that she was an employee of the Langford Hotel, currently on leave pending review. It reminded her that statements to the press could constitute a breach of her obligations. It suggested, in the smooth language of lawyers, that any further public performance, any further cooperation with journalists, any further "exploitation" of the gala incident, might result in the termination of her employment, and in legal proceedings, the nature of which it did not specify, because it did not need to.