Tessa stood in the small studio with the messages still echoing, and she did not call either of them back that day. She was not ready for that many old rooms to open at once. Instead she sat at the upright piano and played the nocturne through, slowly, for no one, and thought about how strange it was that a story she had kept private for six years was now being carried by strangers, carefully, the way you carry something fragile that does not belong to you, and how, for the first time, that did not frighten her. It felt, instead, like the story had finally found hands strong enough to hold it besides her own.
That night, in a penthouse apartment on Fifth Avenue, Catherine Holloway read the profile twice. She read it once quickly, standing in the kitchen with her coat still on, and once slowly, sitting down, with a glass of water she did not drink. She read the part about Ruth twice, and the part about Nadia three times, and when she had finished, she sat for a long time looking out at the city, at the lights coming on across the park, at the life she had built beside a man she was no longer sure she knew.
She picked up her phone. She did not call her husband. She called Vivian Ashworth.
Vivian, she said, when Vivian answered, and her voice was steady, and tired, and clear. "I read the profile. I would like to speak with you. Not about Grant. About Tessa. About what I can do. I think — I think I have been quiet for too long."
Vivian listened, and said very little, and when Catherine had finished, Vivian said, "Come to the hall on Thursday. Not to be seen. To listen. And then we will talk about what doing something actually looks like."
Catherine said yes. She set the phone down. She stood at the window for a while longer, and for the first time in years, she did not feel like a woman waiting for her husband to come home. She felt like a woman deciding something for herself.
The trouble at school started on a Monday, in the hallway outside Nadia's chemistry class, with a boy named Tyler who had watched the gala video and the smear stories in equal measure and had decided, with the confidence of seventeen, that he understood the whole situation.
Hey, Powell, he said, loud enough for the hallway to hear, because hallways are where such things are always said. "Is your sister really a pianist, or is she just good at pretending? My dad says the whole thing was staged. He says Holloway paid her."
Nadia stopped walking. Her books were pressed against her chest, and her face went hot, and for a moment she was twelve again, and the world was too big, and her mother was gone, and the only person standing between her and everything was her sister, who was not there.
Then she remembered who she was. She was eighteen. She was the girl who had watched her sister practice in silence for six years and had never once asked her to stop. She was the girl who had kept time with a kitchen timer in a studio on West 78th Street. She was the girl whose sister had given up Juilliard so she could have a childhood, and she was not going to stand in a hallway and let a boy with a phone and a father's opinion rewrite that.
My dad says a lot of things too, she said, and her voice was steady, and the hallway, which had been buzzing, went quiet in the particular way hallways go quiet when someone is about to say something real. "But my sister didn't get paid. She got humiliated, in front of four hundred people, by a man who thought she was nobody. And then she played, and everybody in that room stood up, and nobody paid them to do that either. You can believe whatever your dad tells you. I was there for the six years before it. I know what it cost."
Tyler opened his mouth, and closed it, and looked at his shoes, and someone at the back of the small crowd that had gathered laughed — not unkindly, but the way people laugh when tension breaks — and a girl Nadia barely knew, a girl from her history class named Amara, stepped forward and said, "She's right. I watched the whole video. Nobody fakes that. And anyway, why would you want it to be fake?"
The hallway moved on. Nadia walked to chemistry with her books still pressed to her chest and her heart still beating too fast, and she told herself it was over, and she was wrong, because by lunch the story had traveled — the way stories travel in schools, faster than any newspaper — and by the end of the day, three different teachers had stopped her in the corridor to say, quietly, that they had read Daniel's profile, and that they were proud of her, and that they were proud of her sister, and Nadia, who had spent years being the quiet girl whose sister worked nights, did not know what to do with so much attention, and so she did what she always did when she did not know what to do: she went home and told Tessa.