Samuel Cole had witnessed the agreement.
So why didn't he expose them?
Caleb's expression became grim.
Maybe he tried.
A sound came from the doorway.
Both men turned.
An unfamiliar man stood there.
He wore a black coat despite the heat.
A silver watch chain crossed his vest.
His boots were polished.
He smiled politely.
Mr. Cole.
Ethan reached for the rifle above the fireplace.
The stranger raised both hands.
No need for that.
Who are you?
My name is Walter Crane.
Caleb stiffened.
Ethan knew the name.
Crane was the regional director of Frontier Water and Cattle Company.
You came a long way.
Not really.
Crane looked around the office.
I've been watching this ranch for two years.
Ethan's hand tightened around the rifle.
What do you want?
The same thing my employers want.
The spring.
Precisely.
Ethan held up the survey.
Crane's smile faded.
Ah.
So you know this is legitimate.
I know many things.
Then you know your lease is fraudulent.
Crane took a slow breath.
Mr. Cole, legality is often a matter of timing.
Forgery is still forgery.
Only if someone can prove it.
Caleb stepped forward.
We have the original.
Crane looked at him.
Do you?
The room went silent.
Ethan understood the threat.
Crane had not come to negotiate.
He had come to see what Ethan knew.
Crane adjusted his gloves.
Your father was a stubborn man.
You knew him?
Everyone in the territory knew Samuel Cole.
What happened to him?
Crane's eyes hardened.
He died.
I know that.
I was referring to how.
Ethan stepped closer.
My father died when a horse threw him.
That is what the report says.
Ethan froze.
What does that mean?
Crane smiled again.
Nothing.
He turned toward the door.
Twenty men will arrive at Dry River at sunrise.
They won't take the spring.
Crane looked over his shoulder.
Everyone says that before they lose something.
He walked out.
Caleb waited until the sound of hoofbeats disappeared.
Then he whispered:
Do you believe your father was murdered?
Ethan stared at the open doorway.
I don't know.
He looked down at the survey.
But I'm going to find out.
---
They rode back to Dry River before noon.
The camp was preparing for the arrival of the company.
Women gathered water.
Men checked rifles.
Children were moved toward the eastern cliffs.
Tomas waited beneath the cottonwoods.
You found it.
Ethan held up the survey.
My father kept the original.
Tomas studied it.
Then your father knew.
About everything?
Not everything.
Tomas looked toward the cliffs.
But enough.
Ethan showed him the brass key.
Tomas nodded.
Your father found the red stone.
Where is it?
Tomas pointed toward the canyon.
Beyond the spring.
What is there?
A place your father and Jacob Reed discovered.
What's inside?
Tomas hesitated.
The truth.
---
That afternoon, Ethan and Tomas rode into the canyon.
The passage was narrow enough that their shoulders nearly touched the rock walls.
At the end stood a red sandstone formation shaped like a broken tower.
Tomas dismounted.
Here.
Ethan saw a small iron lock embedded in the stone.
He inserted the brass key.
It turned.
A hidden panel opened.
Inside was a narrow chamber.
There were documents.
Boxes.
A rusted rifle.
And a small wooden chest.
Ethan opened it.
Inside were letters.
One bore his father's handwriting.
Another was signed by Jacob Reed.
Ethan read the first.
Samuel, if you are reading this, then the company has found the valley. They will tell everyone the water belongs to them. It does not. But the survey alone may not be enough. They have purchased men in the territorial office. They have paid Judge Harlan. They have copies of documents we never signed.
Ethan looked at Tomas.
Judge Harlan.
Tomas nodded.
The judge controls the hearing.
Ethan continued reading.
If they come for the spring, do not fight them only with rifles. Make the truth impossible to bury.
Beneath the letter was another document.
A list of names.
Ranchers.
Officials.
Bankers.
Sheriffs.
And payments.
Thousands of dollars.
Ethan's stomach tightened.
This wasn't simply a water dispute.
It was a conspiracy.
The railroad wanted Dry River.
The company wanted the water.
Officials had been paid.
And his father had discovered it.
A final letter lay beneath the others.
Ethan recognized the handwriting immediately.
It was written by Samuel.
Ethan, if you ever find this, I am sorry. I wanted to protect you from men who believe everything has a price. But if Dry River calls you, do not ignore it. Water remembers where it belongs. So should you.
Ethan closed his eyes.
His father had known he might someday stand here.
Outside, thunder rolled across the desert.
Tomas looked toward the entrance.
Storm.
Ethan listened.
Then came another sound.
Hoofbeats.
Many of them.
Tomas's face hardened.
They came early.
Ethan stepped outside.
On the western ridge, twenty riders appeared against the orange sky.
At their center rode Walter Crane.
And beside him was Judge Harlan.
The battle had begun.
---
The Frontier Water and Cattle Company arrived at Dry River before sunset.
Twenty-three men.
All armed.
They rode in a disciplined line and stopped fifty yards from the settlement.
Walter Crane dismounted.
Judge Harlan remained in the saddle.
A large man with a gray beard rode beside them.
Ethan recognized him.
Silas Vane.
The company's chief enforcer.
Tomas stood at the front of the camp.
Ethan joined him.
Crane called out.
Mr. Cole!
Ethan answered.
Crane.
We've come to enforce a legal claim.
You have no legal claim.
Judge Harlan raised a document.
This lease has been recognized by the territorial office.
Ethan held up the original survey.
And this agreement was signed twenty years before your company existed.
Harlan smiled.
Old papers.
Original papers.
Still old.
Tomas stepped forward.
This valley belongs to the people who have lived here.
Harlan looked at him.