He fired again.
Ethan returned fire.
Vane disappeared.
Caleb and the others ran toward the ridge.
But Vane had already fled.
Ethan looked at Clara.
Are you hurt?
She shook her head.
No.
Then she looked at the tree.
The bullet had torn through the bark.
Something had been hidden behind it.
A metal box.
Ethan pulled it free.
Inside was a photograph.
Samuel Cole.
Jacob Reed.
And a third man.
Walter Crane.
Standing together beside Dry River.
The photograph had been taken eight years earlier.
Ethan stared.
His father had known Crane.
And perhaps Crane had once been his ally.
---
The photograph changed everything.
Ethan spent the next morning asking questions.
Clara remembered seeing Walter Crane with her father many years earlier.
Tomas remembered him too.
Crane wasn't always with the company, Tomas said.
Who was he?
Surveyor.
Ethan frowned.
A surveyor?
He worked with Samuel and Jacob.
Then why did he betray them?
Tomas looked toward the hills.
Money.
Ethan studied the photograph.
Three men.
Samuel.
Jacob.
Crane.
All standing beside the spring.
They had discovered something together.
But only Crane had joined the company.
Ethan returned to the hidden chamber.
He searched every document.
Finally, beneath a loose floorboard, he found a second ledger.
The first page contained three names.
Samuel Cole.
Jacob Reed.
Walter Crane.
The three had originally planned to protect Dry River from corporate control.
But Crane had changed sides.
The ledger contained his confession.
The company offered me fifty thousand dollars. I accepted.
Ethan continued.
Samuel says I have betrayed the valley. Jacob says I have betrayed myself. They are right.
The final entries were darker.
They know we found the underground reservoir. They intend to destroy the evidence.
Then:
If Samuel refuses to cooperate, they will make his death look like an accident.
Ethan stopped reading.
His hands became cold.
His father had not died in an accident.
He had been murdered.
Caleb stood behind him.
You're sure?
Ethan nodded.
The company ordered it.
Caleb looked sick.
Then Crane—
Knew.
They returned to the settlement.
Crane was waiting.
He stood alone beside the spring.
Ethan approached.
You killed my father.
Crane looked at him for a long moment.
No.
Then tell me the truth.
Crane's face aged ten years.
I didn't pull the trigger.
But you knew.
Yes.
Ethan's hand moved toward his pistol.
Crane didn't move.
I deserved that.
You helped them.
I did.
Why?
Because I was afraid.
Ethan stared.
Crane laughed bitterly.
I thought money would protect me. I thought if I joined them, I could control how far they went.
You couldn't.
No.
Crane looked at the water.
Men like me always think we are smarter than men like them.
What happened to Jacob?
Crane's voice broke.
They killed him.
And my father?
I warned him.
Ethan froze.
What?
I told Samuel to leave.
But he stayed.
He said if he ran, they would take the valley.
Ethan closed his eyes.
That sounded like his father.
What happened?
Crane looked down.
Silas Vane was ordered to scare him.
Scare him?
He followed Samuel into the canyon.
And?
Samuel fell.
Ethan's jaw tightened.
You let him die.
Crane whispered:
Yes.
Silence.
Then Crane removed his coat.
He pulled out a revolver.
He placed it on the ground.
I came here because I knew the company would eventually kill me too.
Ethan looked at him.
Why tell me now?
Because your father was right.
About what?
Water remembers.
---
Before Ethan could respond, riders appeared.
Silas Vane.
Six men.
They surrounded the spring.
Crane looked terrified.
Vane smiled.
Mr. Crane.
Crane didn't answer.
Vane looked at Ethan.
Step away.
Ethan didn't move.
Vane pointed his rifle.
The company wants the documents.
Tomas and the others emerged from the trees.
Vane laughed.
Don't.
He pointed toward the children.
Everyone froze.
You fire, they die.
Ethan felt rage rise in his chest.
Then he heard something.
A train whistle.
Far away.
The railroad.
Arthur Bell had said the railroad would investigate.
If the train reached the valley, witnesses would see what was happening.
Ethan looked at Crane.
Crane understood.
How long?
Ethan whispered.
Ten minutes.
Crane nodded.
Then he did something unexpected.
He kicked the revolver toward Ethan.
Vane reacted.
Crane charged him.
The two men collided.
A shot rang out.
The valley exploded into movement.
Tomas's people dove behind rocks.
Caleb fired from the cottonwoods.
Ethan tackled one of the riders.
Another man fired.
The bullet struck the ground beside him.
Crane and Vane struggled near the spring.
Vane gained the advantage.
He raised his pistol.
Ethan fired.
Vane's gun flew from his hand.
Crane struck him across the face.
Vane fell.
The remaining company riders fled.
When the dust settled, Crane was bleeding.
Ethan knelt beside him.
You saved my life.
Crane smiled weakly.
Your father would have done the same.
The train whistle sounded again.
Closer.
Arthur Bell arrived with federal investigators.
The evidence was finally enough.
Walter Crane gave a full confession.
Judge Harlan was arrested.
The company's local operation collapsed.
But one question remained.
Who had ordered Samuel Cole's death?
Crane looked at Ethan.
The man at the top.
Who?
Edmund Vale.
Ethan knew the name.
The founder of Frontier Water and Cattle Company.
A man who lived hundreds of miles away.
A man who had never personally visited Dry River.
And a man who owned enough money to buy almost anything.
Except, Ethan realized, the truth.
---
The investigation lasted three months.
Ethan returned to Cedar Ridge while federal officials examined the company's records.
Dry River became the center of attention.
Newspapers wrote about the hidden spring.
Railroad executives came to inspect the valley.
Lawyers arrived.
Politicians suddenly discovered an interest in water rights.