“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"The court will distinguish carefully between established facts, disputed allegations, and matters requiring additional investigation."

Ethan listened.

He appreciated the judge's caution.

But he could also feel impatience growing inside him.

People had been threatened.

Homes damaged.

Witnesses pursued.

And the legal process still seemed determined to move one careful step at a time.

Anna touched his hand beneath the table.

He looked at her.

She smiled faintly.

He took a breath.

The first witness was Richard Vale.

The engineer explained his role in the original railroad survey.

He described the northern route.

Then the proposed southern alignment.

He presented his calculations.

The attorneys questioned him about distances, grades, water availability, construction costs, and property boundaries.

Richard answered calmly.

When Frontier's lawyer suggested that he had been dismissed for incompetence, the older engineer removed a folder containing his employment evaluations.

Every report praised his work.

The courtroom grew quiet.

The attorney changed direction.

"Mr. Vale, you acknowledge the southern route is technically feasible?"

Richard nodded.

"With appropriate engineering."

"Then your objection was political."

"No."

"Personal?"

"No."

"Why did you refuse to certify it?"

Richard looked toward Judge Harrison.

"Because the company represented the required land rights as secured when they were not."

The attorney paused.

Richard continued.

"A railroad can cross difficult ground. It cannot honestly claim a route is legally available when the necessary rights remain disputed."

Several spectators nodded.

The next witness was Margaret Ellis.

She described her work in the territorial land office.

She explained the altered survey entries and the methods used to replace older records with revised versions.

The Frontier attorney questioned her memory.

Why had she waited seven years?

Why had she changed her name?

Why had she not reported her suspicions earlier?

Margaret answered without attempting to make herself appear heroic.

"I was afraid."

The courtroom grew still.

She continued.

"A clerk disappeared. My house was searched. I had a young daughter."

The attorney pressed.

"So you chose silence?"

Margaret looked down.

"Yes."

"Then how can the court trust your judgment now?"

Margaret raised her head.

"Because I have brought the original documents and because I am willing to answer for my own mistakes."

The room remained silent.

She continued.

"I cannot recover the years I spent hiding. But I can tell the truth today."

Ethan felt Anna's hand tighten around his.

The next witness was Thomas Reed.

His injured leg remained supported by a wooden brace.

He described the work at the diversion channel.

The explosive charges.

The storm.

The order to open the barrier.

When asked who gave the instruction, he answered clearly.

"Arthur Pembroke."

The attorney objected to statements attributed to Mercer that Reed had not heard directly.

Judge Harrison sustained the objection.

Ethan felt frustration rise.

But the judge allowed Reed to testify about the supervisor's instructions and his own observations.

The distinction mattered.

The court was not permitting accusations to substitute for firsthand evidence.

Reed described his refusal to ignite the charges.

Then the explosion.

The flood.

His injuries.

The courtroom listened in grim silence.

Afterward, Anna testified about the damage at Dry River.

She described families fleeing to higher ground.

Children trapped by water.

Ethan rescuing a boy from the current.

The destruction of shelters and supplies.

Her testimony was calm.

Precise.

She did not exaggerate.

That made it more powerful.

When the attorney asked whether heavy rain alone could have caused the flooding, Anna acknowledged that storms sometimes produced dangerous runoff.

Then she explained the unusual timing and the evidence found near the diversion works.

The judge made careful notes.

Finally, Tomas was called.

The old man approached the witness stand with quiet dignity.

He described the families' long use of Dry River.

The seasonal journeys.

The shared spring.

The original agreements.

The arrival of Vance.

The threats.

The armed confrontation.

Then the flood.

The attorney questioned whether Tomas possessed legal title to the spring.

Tomas looked toward the judge.

"Our families used the valley long before the Frontier Company existed."

The attorney repeated the question.

"Do you possess a deed?"

Tomas paused.

"The records your government kept do not contain every promise made to our people."

The room became silent.

He continued.

"But the agreement presented to this court recognizes shared use. It was meant to protect the water from becoming the private possession of one company."

Judge Harrison nodded.

"Please continue."

Tomas looked toward the spectators.

"My people have known hardship. We have made mistakes, and we have endured wrongs. I do not ask this court to pretend the past was simple."

He paused.

"I ask only that the promises written into these records be examined honestly."

Ethan looked down.

The old man's words carried more weight than any shouted accusation could have.

When Tomas finished, the courtroom remained quiet for several seconds.

Then Judge Harrison called a recess.

Outside, Ethan stood beneath the courthouse steps.

The afternoon sun shone across the square.

Anna joined him.

"How do you think it went?"

He considered.

"Better than I feared."

She nodded.

"Richard was convincing."

"So was Margaret."

"And Tomas."

Ethan smiled faintly.

"Especially Tomas."

They watched people leaving the courthouse.

Several reporters hurried toward the telegraph office.

Merchants discussed the testimony.

Ranchers argued about the railroad.

For the first time, Ethan sensed that the dispute was no longer controlled by Frontier's public statements.

The evidence was being heard.

The witnesses were being believed enough to warrant further investigation.

And the company's claim of unquestioned ownership had been seriously challenged.

Then a carriage stopped near the courthouse.

It was black.

Expensive.

Drawn by two matched horses.

A driver climbed down and opened the door.

Harold Mercer stepped onto the street.

Ethan felt his stomach tighten.

Anna followed his gaze.

"Who is that?"

"Mercer."

The financier looked toward the courthouse.

Then saw Ethan.

For a moment, neither moved.

Mercer smiled faintly.

He crossed the square.

"Mr. Cole."

Ethan remained still.

"Mr. Mercer."

The financier looked toward Anna.

"And you must be one of the witnesses from Dry River."

Anna met his gaze.

"My name is Anna."

Mercer inclined his head politely.

"An unfortunate business, all of this."

News in the same category

“Choose One of My Three Daughters,” the Apache Chief Told the Cowboy — He Chose All Three, Then Rode Into War Beside Them

29 Part