Ethan laughed.
Anna worked silently for several moments.
Then she glanced toward the western pass.
"Will the men return?"
"Yes."
"Today?"
"Probably."
She nodded as though confirming something she already knew.
"Jesse thinks we can defeat them."
"Jesse is brave."
"He is young."
"Those aren't mutually exclusive."
Anna pulled the thread tight.
"He wants to prove himself."
Ethan looked toward the camp.
The young man was helping carry supplies toward the northern caves.
"He'll have chances enough."
"That is what frightens me."
Anna handed back the strap.
Ethan examined the repair.
It was better than anything he could have done.
"Thank you."
She nodded.
Then she looked toward the spring.
"My mother died here."
Ethan's expression softened.
"I'm sorry."
Anna watched the water moving across the stones.
"She was ill. There were no doctors nearby. My father carried her for two days trying to reach help."
Ethan said nothing.
"She wanted to return to this valley. She said she could hear the water even when she closed her eyes."
Anna paused.
"She died before sunrise."
Ethan looked toward the cottonwoods.
"My mother died at Cedar Ridge."
Anna turned.
"Was she ill?"
"Yes."
"Did you have a doctor?"
"We did."
"Did it help?"
Ethan shook his head.
"No."
Anna looked down.
For a moment, the difference between their lives seemed less important than the grief they shared.
Then Anna spoke.
"People think having water is only about living another day."
Ethan waited.
"But it is also about remembering where someone lived their last day. Where a child first learned to walk. Where a family buried someone they loved."
She looked directly at him.
"Vance thinks he is taking a spring."
Ethan nodded.
"But he is taking more."
Anna rose.
"Much more."
She collected her basket and walked toward the camp.
Ethan remained beside his horse, thinking about her words.
The company saw the valley as a financial opportunity.
Tomas saw it as a responsibility.
Anna saw it as a place where memory lived.
Ethan was beginning to understand that all three perspectives would influence what happened next.
Later that morning, Tomas called the defenders together.
They gathered beneath the largest cottonwood.
Seven men stood before him, including Jesse and two teenagers who had never participated in a gunfight.
Ethan examined the rifles.
There were several old weapons in poor condition.
One shotgun had a cracked stock.
Another rifle had a stiff action.
The ammunition supply was smaller than he had hoped.
He looked toward Tomas.
"We can't win a long fight."
"I know."
"And we can't let them get into the camp."
"I know that too."
Ethan pointed toward the western approach.
"The canyon narrows before it reaches the spring. If Vance comes with twenty men, his biggest advantage is numbers."
Jesse nodded.
"So we stop them there."
"First, we make it clear that we want them to leave without anyone being hurt."
Jesse looked disappointed.
"They will not listen."
"Maybe not."
"Then why talk?"
"Because once shooting starts, we don't get to choose where every bullet goes."
The young man looked toward the camp.
Ethan continued.
"There are children here. Your families. Their safety matters more than proving we're tougher than Vance."
Tomas nodded.
"Agreed."
They spent the remainder of the morning improving observation points and preparing protected routes to the caves.
Ethan avoided making promises he could not keep.
He told the defenders they were badly outnumbered.
He explained that Frontier's men would likely have better weapons and more ammunition.
And he reminded them that retreating to protect the families would not be a defeat.
By afternoon, the youngest children had been moved into the caves.
Elena organized food, blankets, and water.
Anna established a small treatment area beneath a rocky overhang.
Jesse stood watch over the western trail.
As the sun began to fall, Ethan climbed a ridge overlooking the valley.
Below him, the spring reflected the fading light.
The cottonwoods swayed gently.
For a moment, Dry River seemed untouched by the danger approaching it.
Then Tomas appeared beside him.
"Do you regret coming here?"
Ethan considered.
"I regret losing my horses."
Tomas smiled.
"Only that?"
"Ask me again tomorrow."
They watched the sunset in silence.
Then Tomas said, "Your father told me once that courage is not always a loud thing."
Ethan looked toward him.
"What did he mean?"
"Sometimes courage is simply refusing to leave when someone needs you."
Ethan stared at the western horizon.
He thought of his father's final days.
Of the promises he had made.
And of the strange way three missing horses had led him into a fight he had never expected.
He adjusted his hat.
"Then I suppose we'd better be here when morning comes."
The riders appeared shortly after eight o'clock.
A long column of horses moved through the western canyon, raising red dust beneath the morning sunlight.
Ethan counted nineteen men.
At their head rode Vance.
He was enormous in the saddle, broad through the shoulders, wearing a black hat and a heavy leather coat. A pale scar ran down the side of his throat.
His expression was hard.
His movements deliberate.
He stopped near the mouth of the narrow passage.
"Tomas!" he shouted.
His voice echoed between the cliffs.
"Your time is up!"
Nobody answered.
Vance looked toward the cottonwoods.
"I told you what would happen if you were still here!"
Ethan stood from behind a rock.
"Morning, Vance."
The trail boss looked up.
His expression changed.
"Who are you?"
"Ethan Cole."
Vance stared.
Then his mouth twisted into a smile.
"Samuel Cole's boy."
Ethan remained still.
"That's right."
"What are you doing here?"
"Standing on public land."
Vance's smile vanished.
"This is private company property."
"Not according to the 1868 survey."
The riders shifted uneasily.
Vance looked toward the ridges.
"You got a copy of that survey?"
"My father did."
"Your father is dead."
Ethan felt his jaw tighten.
"That doesn't make the survey disappear."
Vance laughed.
"You think old papers are going to stop the Frontier Company?"
"I think fraudulent papers might interest a federal judge."
The trail boss's expression hardened.
He reached into his coat and produced the lease.
"Signed and sealed."
Ethan studied the document from above.
"The land wasn't available for private leasing."
"Tell that to the governor."