"Who is the arresting officer?" Naomi asked quietly.
"Officer Thomas Mercer," David replied.
Naomi’s eyes snapped open. "Excuse me?"
"Grant Mercer’s younger brother," David confirmed. "He lateral-transferred to Oakhaven County two years ago. Naomi... they are railroading this kid. The local prosecutor is a hardliner running for a judge seat. He’s going to use this kid as a 'tough on crime' campaign poster. Julian is facing fifteen years in a state penitentiary for walking down a sidewalk while Black."
Naomi looked at the half-finished appellate brief on her computer screen. She reached over and clicked 'Save and Close.'
"Have his mother in my office at two o'clock," Naomi commanded. "And David? Send me everything you have on the Oakhaven County prosecutor's office. Every case file, every conviction rate, every dismissed complaint. I want his entire professional life on my desk by noon."
"Consider it done," David said, a fierce satisfaction in his voice.
At exactly two o'clock, the heavy mahogany doors opened again. Elias ushered two women into Naomi’s office. The older woman, Sarah Hayes, looked completely exhausted, her eyes red-rimmed and swollen from a sleepless night of weeping. She wore a faded blue uniform from a local commercial cleaning company. Beside her stood Alicia.
Naomi’s daughter had graduated with her master’s in public policy six months prior and had immediately refused three lucrative offers from high-powered consulting firms in Washington. Instead, she had walked into Naomi's new practice and informed her mother that she was the firm's new lead investigative analyst. Naomi hadn't argued.
"Mom," Alicia said softly, guiding Mrs. Hayes to one of the plush leather chairs opposite the desk. "I met Mrs. Hayes downstairs in the lobby. David sent over the preliminary discovery files."
Naomi stood up, walking around her desk to greet the woman directly. She extended her hand. "Mrs. Hayes. I am Naomi Brooks. Please, sit down."
Sarah Hayes took Naomi's hand. Her grip was trembling. "They told me you were the Attorney General. They said you were the only one who could stop this."
"I was the Attorney General," Naomi gently corrected her, taking the seat next to her rather than retreating behind the massive desk. "Now, I am a private defense attorney. Which means I don't have to worry about political optics anymore. Tell me about Julian."
For the next hour, Sarah Hayes painted a picture of a young man that stood in stark, glaring contrast to the violent felon described in the police report. Julian was an honor roll student. He was the captain of his high school debate team. He volunteered at a local community center teaching robotics to middle schoolers. He had been accepted into the university's highly competitive aerospace engineering program. He was terrified of police, having grown up watching the news, and had always been meticulously careful about how he dressed and how he carried himself when he left their working-class neighborhood.
"He called me right before it happened," Sarah wept, clutching a crumpled tissue. "He said he was lost. The houses in Oakhaven are so far apart, and the street signs are small. He was looking at his phone, trying to find the address for the tutoring session. He said a woman in a white SUV slowed down and stared at him. Ten minutes later, he was in an ambulance."
Naomi listened in silence, absorbing the details, finding the inconsistencies in the official narrative. A kid looking at GPS on his phone does not make "furtive movements toward a waistband." A kid who has spent his entire life avoiding police contact does not randomly assault two armed officers.
Alicia opened a thick manila folder resting on the coffee table. "I ran a preliminary background on the arresting officers. Thomas Mercer and a rookie named Brian Vance. According to the use-of-force reports from Oakhaven County over the last two years, Thomas Mercer has a suspiciously high rate of 'resisting arrest' charges attached to his stops. In almost sixty percent of his arrests involving minority suspects, he adds a resisting charge."
Naomi’s eyes darkened. "It’s a cover charge. You charge the suspect with resisting to justify the force you used to detain them in the first place."
"Exactly," Alicia nodded, sliding a printed spreadsheet toward her mother. "If the suspect pleads down, the resisting charge stays on the record, validating the officer's use of force. It’s a closed loop of accountability. But this is the first time one of his stops has resulted in a severe injury to an officer."
"How severe is the broken nose?" Naomi asked.
"According to the medical intake at the county hospital, it's a hairline fracture," Alicia said, scanning the document. "Treated with ice and painkillers. Officer Mercer returned to duty the next day."
Naomi stood up, pacing slowly toward the large windows overlooking the Richmond skyline. The anger she had felt on her own lawn four years ago had never truly vanished; it had simply cooled, hardening into a sharp, structural steel. Grant Mercer had lost his badge, but the system that produced him, the culture that trained him, had just mutated and moved a county over.
She turned back to Sarah Hayes. The woman looked small and broken in the large leather chair.
"Mrs. Hayes," Naomi said, her voice dropping into the authoritative, unshakeable register that used to terrify defense attorneys across the state. "I am going to take Julian's case. I am going to file an emergency motion for a bail reduction hearing tomorrow morning. We are going to get your son out of that cell."