Cops Tackled a Black Woman Watering Her Own Garden — Then a Black SUV Convoy Pulled Up 30 Seconds Later

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

A heavy side door opened, and a bailiff led Julian Hayes into the courtroom.

Naomi’s heart tightened in her chest. The twenty-year-old college student looked absolutely terrified. He was wearing the bright orange jumpsuit, his hands shackled to a waist chain. But it was his face that made Naomi’s breath catch. His left eye was swollen shut, surrounded by a violent, blossoming purple bruise. His lower lip was split and stitched. He moved stiffly, clearly favoring his right ribs.

This was the "aggressive stance." This was the kid who had supposedly assaulted two armed police officers.

The bailiff unhooked Julian from the chain gang and guided him to the seat next to Naomi. Julian sat down slowly, wincing. He looked at Naomi with his one good eye, trembling slightly.

"Mr. Hayes," Naomi said softly, leaning closer to him. "I am Naomi Brooks. I am your attorney. You do not speak today. You do not answer any questions. You let me do all the talking. Do you understand?"

Julian nodded, a single tear escaping his swollen eye and tracking down his bruised cheek. "They beat me," he whispered, his voice cracking. "I just ran because they pulled their guns. I was so scared. I didn't hit anyone. They threw me on the ground and started hitting me."

"I know," Naomi said, placing a steadying hand over his trembling, shackled wrists. "I know, Julian. And we are going to prove it."

The bailiff called the court to order as Judge Harold Franklin took the bench. Franklin was an older judge, a former prosecutor himself, known for setting high bail and moving his docket with ruthless efficiency.

"Call the case of the State versus Julian Hayes," the clerk announced.

"Robert Sterling for the State, Your Honor," Sterling barked, standing up aggressively.

Naomi stood gracefully, smoothing the front of her jacket. "Naomi Brooks, Your Honor. Entering my appearance as lead counsel for the defense."

Judge Franklin peered over his reading glasses. He recognized her immediately. A flicker of surprise crossed his weathered face, quickly replaced by a guarded neutrality. "General Brooks. A surprise to see you in my courtroom. We don't usually get the heavy hitters down here for a preliminary bail hearing."

"The circumstances of my client's detention required immediate attention, Your Honor," Naomi replied smoothly.

"Very well. Mr. Sterling, the State's position on bail?"

Sterling grabbed his notes. "Your Honor, this defendant committed a violent, unprovoked assault on a law enforcement officer. He fled a lawful investigatory stop, leading officers on a foot pursuit. Upon being apprehended, he actively resisted, striking Officer Mercer in the face and causing a facial fracture. The defendant poses a severe flight risk and a clear danger to the community. The State requests bail remain at two hundred and fifty thousand dollars."

Judge Franklin looked toward Naomi. "Ms. Brooks? I assume you object."

"I do, Your Honor. I object to the bail amount, and I object to the State's entire characterization of reality," Naomi said, stepping out from behind the defense table.

She walked toward the center podium. "My client is a twenty-year-old engineering student with a 3.8 GPA. He has no prior criminal history. No juvenile record. He is a lifelong resident of this state. He is not a flight risk; he is a college sophomore who was walking to a tutoring job."

Naomi turned slightly, gesturing toward Julian. "The State claims my client launched an unprovoked assault on two armed police officers. I would ask the Court to look at my client's face. Look at his eye. Look at his split lip. The police report claims that a twenty-year-old kid with a backpack full of calculus textbooks managed to inflict a hairline fracture on an officer while simultaneously receiving a brutal, concussive beating. It defies physics, and it defies common sense."

Sterling jumped to his feet. "Objection! Counsel is testifying and attempting to litigate the facts of the case during a bail hearing!"

"Sustained," Judge Franklin said, though he was staring intently at Julian's bruised face. "Ms. Brooks, confine your arguments to the bail criteria."

"Understood, Your Honor," Naomi pivoted seamlessly. "The criteria for bail is risk of flight and danger to the community. Julian Hayes works at a community center teaching robotics. His mother cleans office buildings to help pay for his textbooks. He is anchored to this community by every conceivable metric. A quarter of a million dollars bail for a college student is not a guarantee of appearance; it is a punitive ransom designed to force a plea deal from an innocent kid sitting in a cage."

Naomi leaned into the podium. "Furthermore, Your Honor, we have formally requested the body-camera footage of this incident. The State has informed us that, miraculously, both officers' cameras experienced catastrophic mechanical failures during the exact sixty seconds this alleged assault took place. Given the highly suspicious lack of objective evidence, holding this boy on a quarter-million dollar bond is a miscarriage of justice."

Sterling’s face was purple. "The camera malfunctions are being investigated by the department, Your Honor! That does not invalidate the sworn testimony of two officers!"

Judge Franklin held up a hand, silencing the prosecutor. He looked back at Naomi, then at Julian. The judge was a law-and-order man, but he wasn't blind. The boy at the defense table looked exactly like what he was: a terrified, beaten kid.

News in the same category

Cops Tackled a Black Woman Watering Her Own Garden — Then a Black SUV Convoy Pulled Up 30 Seconds Later

30 Part