"Why come now?" Sam asked.
"Because Briggs has decided to kill everyone who knows about the accident."
"You're one of them."
"Yes."
"And you helped him."
Vale lowered his eyes.
"I did."
Sam's finger tightened around the rifle.
"Why should I listen to you?"
"Because I can tell you who gave the order."
Sam stepped closer.
"Who?"
Vale swallowed.
"Your mother was not the only person Briggs wanted dead that night."
Sam felt his pulse hammer.
"Who else?"
Vale looked toward the stone house.
"Your father."
The words struck with the force of a blow.
Sam stared at him.
"My father wasn't there."
"No. But he was supposed to be."
Vale glanced toward the ridge again.
"Briggs planned to kill both of them. The wagon was meant to go over the embankment with everyone inside. But William changed his plans at the last minute."
"Why?"
"Because he had discovered the plot. He sent your father away—"
Vale stopped himself.
Sam's expression darkened.
"Which father?"
"Your father, William. He sent himself away from the wagon, and your mother insisted on taking his place."
Sam could barely breathe.
"That makes no sense."
"She believed she could draw the men away from him. She thought the danger would pass if she took the documents and left town."
Sam looked toward the creek in the distance.
His mother had known.
She had known something was coming.
And she had still climbed into the wagon with him.
"Who arranged it?" he asked.
Vale looked at him.
"Briggs gave the order. But the money came from Nathaniel Voss."
"And Harrow?"
"Judge Harrow made certain the investigation disappeared."
Sam lowered his rifle slightly.
"Why did you help them?"
Vale's face twisted.
"Because I was a coward."
He reached inside his coat.
Sam raised the rifle again.
"Slowly."
Vale pulled out a folded paper and held it between two fingers.
"This is the original payment receipt. It has Briggs's signature."
Sam took it.
The signature matched the one on the ledger.
There was also a second line.
Witness: Arthur Vale.
Sam looked up.
"You signed it."
"Yes."
"Then you were part of it."
"I was."
"Why should I believe anything you say?"
Vale looked at him with tired eyes.
"Because I have spent fifteen years trying to forget the sound of your mother calling your name."
Sam felt something break inside him.
He remembered the storm.
The broken wagon.
His mother's hand.
He had spent seven years believing she had died because he had failed to listen.
Now the man who had helped arrange her death stood before him, admitting that she had called his name while the wagon overturned.
Sam moved toward him.
"Tell me exactly what happened."
Vale nodded.
But before he could speak, a rifle cracked from the ridge.
Vale jerked backward.
Blood spread across his chest.
Sam caught him before he hit the ground.
The white flag fell into the dirt.
Across the valley, a second shot echoed.
Sam looked toward the southern ridge.
A rider was disappearing behind the rocks.
Silas Redd.
Vale struggled to breathe.
"He's coming," he whispered.
"Who?"
Vale gripped Sam's sleeve.
"Briggs."
His eyes moved toward the mountains.
"He's not coming for the land anymore."
His fingers tightened.
"He's coming for the truth."
Then his hand fell away.
Sam lowered him gently to the ground.
For a long moment, he remained kneeling in the dirt.
Then he stood.
The grief in his face had become something colder.
He looked toward the ridge where Redd had vanished.
"Get everyone inside," he said.
Elias hurried to obey.
Sam checked the rifle.
"Daniel, take the eastern ridge. Joseph, secure the northern trail. Nobody leaves the settlement alone."
Kale appeared at the doorway.
"What happened?"
Sam looked at the dead man.
"He knew who killed my mother."
Kale's expression tightened.
"And now?"
Sam raised his eyes toward the distant hills.
"Now Briggs knows we have the proof."
A horn sounded from the southern entrance.
Once.
Then twice.
The signal carried across the valley.
On the ridge, dark figures began to appear.
Briggs had brought his men back.
And this time, they were not carrying a paper agreement.
They were carrying rifles.
The horn sounded a third time.
Its low note rolled between the cliffs and faded above the river. Every person in the settlement understood what it meant. Doors closed. Children were hurried into the stone house. Men took their positions along the walls and behind the natural defenses of the valley.
Sam stood near the southern entrance, watching the ridge.
Briggs had brought more men than before.
There were at least twenty-five riders, spread across the high ground. Some carried rifles. Others had shotguns resting across their saddles. Silas Redd sat near the center, his pale face turned toward the settlement.
Briggs himself rode at the front.
He wore the same dark coat he had worn the previous morning.
A man dressed for business, not battle.
Sam rested his Winchester against his shoulder.
"How many rifles do we have?" he asked Daniel.
"Twenty-three that work. Five more that need repairing."