"Who?"
Calder looked up.
"The man who ordered my unit into an ambush."
His voice became hollow.
"The man responsible for forty-seven deaths."
Father Bennett stared at the photograph.
Calder turned it over.
A date had been written on the back.
Three months earlier.
Captain Elias Voss was alive.
And he was standing beside the men who had destroyed Calder's family.
Calder sat alone in the church for nearly an hour, studying the photograph until the faces seemed to blur.
He remembered Elias Voss as a young cavalry captain with polished boots, an immaculate uniform, and an extraordinary talent for convincing men to trust him.
Voss had been charming.
Educated.
Fearless in conversation.
And utterly indifferent to the lives of the soldiers under his command.
During the final winter of the war, Calder's unit had been ordered through a narrow valley near the New Mexico border. Intelligence suggested that a small enemy patrol occupied the far ridge.
Instead, nearly two hundred armed men waited behind the rocks.
The ambush lasted less than twenty minutes.
Forty-seven soldiers died.
Calder survived because his horse fell beneath him, shielding his body from the first volley.
He had spent the next six hours trapped beneath the dead animal, listening to wounded men call for water.
Voss disappeared during the fighting.
The army reported him killed.
Calder had believed the report.
Until now.
He turned the photograph over again.
The date remained.
Three months earlier.
Father Bennett sat beside him.
"Are you certain?"
Calder nodded.
"I'd know that face anywhere."
"Could it be someone who resembles him?"
"No."
The priest sighed.
"Then perhaps the dead have returned to trouble the living."
Calder looked toward the altar.
"Some of them never stopped."
He opened the leather notebook.
Daniel's handwriting filled the pages.
Names.
Dates.
Land purchases.
Bank transfers.
Freight shipments.
The entries formed a careful record of transactions extending back nearly fifteen years.
Calder read slowly.
At first, the numbers meant little.
Then patterns emerged.
Properties near the northern copper hills had been purchased through companies with different names but identical financial backers.
Several ranchers had sold after unexplained fires.
Others had disappeared.
Two had been accused of supplying weapons to Apache raiders.
Their land had subsequently been seized.
Calder turned another page.
There was his father's name.
Samuel Van.
Beside it, Daniel had written:
Claim 47-B. Original copper survey concealed. Bank foreclosure arranged through Harrow interests. Death recorded as accidental.
Calder felt his throat tighten.
His father had died beneath a collapsed mine entrance.
The official investigation had blamed unstable rock.
Calder had been away at the time.
Daniel had been seventeen.
Their mother had died the following winter.
Calder stared at the words until they seemed to burn through the paper.
Father Bennett placed a hand on his shoulder.
"Calder."
He did not answer.
The priest waited.
Finally, Calder closed the notebook.
"My father wasn't killed by a cave-in."
"We don't know that yet."
Calder looked at him.
"Daniel believed it."
"Belief isn't proof."
"Then we'll find proof."
Father Bennett studied him.
"And what will you do when you find it?"
Calder looked toward the photograph.
For a moment, he saw Voss standing above the battlefield, issuing orders while wounded men begged for help.
He imagined Brock Tally smiling outside the burning homestead.
He thought of Naya's brother lying beside the freight road.
"I don't know," he admitted.
The priest nodded.
"Then decide before the moment arrives."
Calder rose.
He wrapped the notebook and documents in oilcloth, leaving the box beneath the floorboards.
As he turned toward the door, Father Bennett spoke again.
"Daniel left another message."
Calder stopped.
"What message?"
"He said you should remember the place where your father taught you to listen."
Calder frowned.
"The place where he taught me to listen?"
The priest nodded.
"Those were his exact words."
Calder searched his memory.
His father had taught him many things.
How to shoe a horse.
How to repair a wagon.
How to read clouds before a storm.
How to recognize the difference between a coyote's cry and the sound of a wounded animal.
Then he remembered.
A small canyon north of the old mine.
Echo Hollow.
His father had taken the boys there when they were children, teaching them how sound traveled between the sandstone walls.
"Listen carefully," Samuel Van had said. "The land will tell you things if you stop trying to make it speak."
Calder looked toward the northern windows.
"Echo Hollow."
Father Bennett's expression changed.
"Does that mean something?"
"It means Daniel left me a trail."
Calder tucked the documents beneath his coat.
Then he walked toward the door.
Outside, the church bell began to ring.
And somewhere beyond Copper Bend, beneath the copper-colored hills, the secrets of Samuel Van's death waited in the darkness.
Naya woke to the smell of boiled linen and rain.
For a moment, she believed she was home.
She remembered her grandmother's cooking fire, the sound of Elan laughing outside their shelter, and Ash stamping impatiently near the water trough.
Then pain returned.
Her wrists throbbed.
Her throat felt raw.
And the unfamiliar ceiling above her belonged to Miriam Vale's clinic.
She turned her head.
A woman sat beside the window, mending a torn shirt.